QB Brock Purdy Thread

Wonder what Joe thinks...?

Originally posted by Mankster:

Wonder what Joe thinks...?

ITTTTTT DOESSSNNNN'TTTT WHAT THE BEST EVER QB OF ALL TIME THINKS OF STEADY PURDYYYYY !!!

there's just not enough evidence to give him a FINAL GRADE.. bottom line is at this moment, the team is in good hands w/Steady Purdy !!!

Originally posted by 9moon:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by 9moon:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by D0PEMAN:

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by D0PEMAN:

We all wish he would have hit that pass, but it was wasn't necessarily a game deciding play anymore than a variety of other factors including:

- The missed plays Jimmy left on the field throughout the 4th quarter that were not deep passes.
- Going away from the run game, which was our bread and butter
- Our defense allowing a 3rd and 15 conversion and effectively collapsing overall in the 4th quarter.

Even if Jimmy converts that play the Chiefs still have the time to drive down the field and tie or win the game. It wasn't a magic bullet, lol.

Fair post. However my point is that a deep bomb is what it takes sometimes to change the game (happens a lot in the Superbowl). If this had been completed for 6 it would've been a heavy momentum swing, and who knows what could've happened after that. Maybe Jimmy would be wearing the ring today.

deep throws don't happen a lot in the superbowl, heck it didn't even happen in that super bowl in your clip

BOTTOM LINE - the game should not have came down to this pass.. we were UP 10 points and had the best RB in the POST SEASON..

no it shouldn't, but the run was stuffed and had to throw on 3rd & long

U may want to watch the Shanny Super Bowl Fiasco again and learn how easily he gave up not only with the running game, but also stopped calling the Deeva and Juice's #s...

Also, do you NOT wonder why 26 started the game over 31, and why he waited until the 2nd QTR to use 31?

lol i watched it many times, i was even there.

the run was stuffed, we had to throw

Originally posted by 9moon:
ITTTTTT DOESSSNNNN'TTTT WHAT THE BEST EVER QB OF ALL TIME THINKS OF STEADY PURDYYYYY !!!

there's just not enough evidence to give him a FINAL GRADE.. bottom line is at this moment, the team is in good hands w/Steady Purdy !!!

You spelled STURDY wrong.

Originally posted by WildBill:

Originally posted by clara543:

Originally posted by tankle104:
It's difficult to have a ton of yards and stuff in this offense because of how talented we are. We are very balanced, which makes sense cause of our rushing attack.

we would have to have an off game and rely on him to carry us, like the raiders game. Even then he didn't break 300 yards.

it's possible but not an easy task with the talent we have and our play calling style.

I don't see why not? Kyle Shanahan's offense with Atlanta did produce a 5,000 yard passer in Matt Ryan and a 1,100 yard rusher in Devonta Freeman.

Helps when you have Julio Jones. Not to mention an established QB like Ryan. Not dissing Deebo or Aiyuk, but Julio, 6-3 4.39 40

It helps when you have a bad-average defense and you're in shootouts. We haven't had a bad defense for a while and the only time we have, was the raiders game, and Brock showed up for that one.

we have a very balanced attack, that is good and efficient at both. We also have a dominant defense. That falcons team had a crap defense that gave up like 25 ppg. They were constantly in shootouts and the game were decided in the fourth. Or if you got to the fourth, it was close enough to where they tried to keep scoring points to extend the lead. It's very different.

also, 1100 rushing yards in a year is a good year but it's not amazing. It's just 69 yards a game. That doesn't really sound like a super balanced offense like we have.

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by DonnieDarko:

Originally posted by tankle104:
Dude was crying as a kid cause his team didn't win and he hated that he couldn't help… lmao this guy is ridiculously competitive. I love it.

i always loved how competitive guys like Brady & Kobe were - it just snowed in their play every time they touched the ball. I'm not saying he is, or will be, them. I just like the fact that he is Uber competitive. You can see it on each drive - he's pissed when a drive doesn't work out. I love it

I get the impression jimmy is less driven

Well there is a difference between between competitive and then there is like "I want to win at everything I do". I think Jimmy is a competitor but I also think he views the results as "is what it is". Where as someone like Brock, I get the impression he is isn't like that. He's more of "eff that, what can I do to get better to kick their ass"

Yup. Jimmy rarely showed any fire. He would just sit on the sidelines and smile even when losing. Raider fans just got to witness it first hand last week

yeah, I never cared for that. I personally think someone should take these losses harder - even if he does take it hard, and is trying to hide it, I don't think he should. be pissed off - feel those emotions and let them drive you. I personally feel like that has been a reason he never really got better. Jimmy was just the same always, and never really grew from his mistakes.

This is just a lot of revisionist history as far as I'm concerned. One of the things that I always liked about Jimmy was how jacked he got after the team scored. You could especially see it when they scored from close to the goal line. There were also some great clips from his five-game run in 2017 when he was on the sidelines talking guys up and telling them how good they were. I don't think he could have generated the loyalty he did among the players if they felt he wasn't serious about winning. That being said, even Jimmy might have a tough time matching Brock's fire after a score. That guy just howls, which I think is great.

Of course, I'm also not of the school, as suggested above, that believes players need to show how pissed off they are about losing. They're professionals, getting paid to do a job, but I doubt many of them would be where they are if they didn't get stung by a loss, especially some of the ones the Niners have endured the last few years. However, I prefer to leave the histrionics to the "fans" in their memorabilia lined man-caves who feel compelled to post YouTube videos of themselves jumping around like idiots to show how seriously they take losing. A bunch of psychos if you ask me,

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by WildBill:

Originally posted by clara543:

Originally posted by tankle104:
It's difficult to have a ton of yards and stuff in this offense because of how talented we are. We are very balanced, which makes sense cause of our rushing attack.

we would have to have an off game and rely on him to carry us, like the raiders game. Even then he didn't break 300 yards.

it's possible but not an easy task with the talent we have and our play calling style.

I don't see why not? Kyle Shanahan's offense with Atlanta did produce a 5,000 yard passer in Matt Ryan and a 1,100 yard rusher in Devonta Freeman.

Helps when you have Julio Jones. Not to mention an established QB like Ryan. Not dissing Deebo or Aiyuk, but Julio, 6-3 4.39 40

It helps when you have a bad-average defense and you're in shootouts. We haven't had a bad defense for a while and the only time we have, was the raiders game, and Brock showed up for that one.

we have a very balanced attack, that is good and efficient at both. We also have a dominant defense. That falcons team had a crap defense that gave up like 25 ppg. They were constantly in shootouts and the game were decided in the fourth. Or if you got to the fourth, it was close enough to where they tried to keep scoring points to extend the lead. It's very different.

also, 1100 rushing yards in a year is a good year but it's not amazing. It's just 69 yards a game. That doesn't really sound like a super balanced offense like we have.

Well, they also had Tevon Coleman rush for 600 yards. Overall, they had around 1900 yards rushing.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Lol the last play "that is a great incompletion". That's funny, I noticed it live too, the miscommunication there and I was like "damn, should of been at worst a first down, most likely a touchdown". A lot to like and a lot of things to improve on.

id be curious how much or his technique issues/inconsistency is due to his off season rehab and not training/honing his craft.

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by WildBill:

Originally posted by clara543:

Originally posted by tankle104:
It's difficult to have a ton of yards and stuff in this offense because of how talented we are. We are very balanced, which makes sense cause of our rushing attack.

we would have to have an off game and rely on him to carry us, like the raiders game. Even then he didn't break 300 yards.

it's possible but not an easy task with the talent we have and our play calling style.

I don't see why not? Kyle Shanahan's offense with Atlanta did produce a 5,000 yard passer in Matt Ryan and a 1,100 yard rusher in Devonta Freeman.

Helps when you have Julio Jones. Not to mention an established QB like Ryan. Not dissing Deebo or Aiyuk, but Julio, 6-3 4.39 40

It helps when you have a bad-average defense and you're in shootouts. We haven't had a bad defense for a while and the only time we have, was the raiders game, and Brock showed up for that one.

we have a very balanced attack, that is good and efficient at both. We also have a dominant defense. That falcons team had a crap defense that gave up like 25 ppg. They were constantly in shootouts and the game were decided in the fourth. Or if you got to the fourth, it was close enough to where they tried to keep scoring points to extend the lead. It's very different.

also, 1100 rushing yards in a year is a good year but it's not amazing. It's just 69 yards a game. That doesn't really sound like a super balanced offense like we have.

Well, they also had Tevon Coleman rush for 600 yards. Overall, they had around 1900 yards rushing.

Yeah. They averaged 120 rushing yards a game. Which is pretty good, fifth in the league that year.

i also looked up pass attempts a game and last season we averaged 29 and in 2016 the falcons had 33 - so not a major difference.

i guess the main difference is bigger plays in the pass game? For example, If brock hit those three deep misses, his stats probably look a lot better. 5k passing yards is 294 passing yards a game (17 game season, 2016 was 16 games which is 312 yards a game.).

maybe it's more attainable than I thought. I still think a big factor is the defense. When you get a sizable lead, like we often do, it changes the way you attack the field cause you're playing the clock and trying to grind it out. Seems like it's more attainable than I originally thought.

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Lol the last play "that is a great incompletion". That's funny, I noticed it live too, the miscommunication there and I was like "damn, should of been at worst a first down, most likely a touchdown". A lot to like and a lot of things to improve on.

id be curious how much or his technique issues/inconsistency is due to his off season rehab and not training/honing his craft.

Purdy had a really strong first half, and and a decent second half. Hard to say whether it's anything to worry about, or just an up and down half of play. One thing we can say for certain is that his floor is now no worse than decent.

Originally posted by Chance:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Lol the last play "that is a great incompletion". That's funny, I noticed it live too, the miscommunication there and I was like "damn, should of been at worst a first down, most likely a touchdown". A lot to like and a lot of things to improve on.

id be curious how much or his technique issues/inconsistency is due to his off season rehab and not training/honing his craft.

Purdy had a really strong first half, and and a decent second half. Hard to say whether it's anything to worry about, or just an up and down half of play. One thing we can say for certain is that his floor is now no worse than decent.

Yeah, I wish he didn't have that miscommunication with CMC there at the end, would of been an easy touchdown. Had 2-3 other touchdowns he missed too.

it's wild to think that we scored 30 and it should of been way more. Lol the potential of this offense if we can fire on all cylinders is insane.

Originally posted by btthepunk:
I predict he's going to look good in preseason and some fools in here will be claiming he should start over Lance and to trade Lance.

From page 4