QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by SLCNiner:
No way would I have Prescott above Purdy. I think Tua should be higher also. After this year I feel Hurts will plummet also. Still don't know the fascination with Jackson. Outside of his running he's a mediocre passer, small and fragile. I truly feel this season puts Sturdy Purdy in the top 5 talk. So far this year, I'd be correct.

He was ranking them overall… not just based on this year.

For me, I think I agree with the poster (a few posts) up who says it's too early to rank Purdy. Same with Jordan Love.

If Purdy were to play as he has going forward I could see him ranked as high as 5th, behind the four QBs I think the vast majority of people would consider elite.

Suppose that's fair enough. Hurts had an MVP season last year had it not been for the missed games, and I truly believe he comes back to earth this year. I do have faith in Purdy, especially based off his playoff performances, which is the same reason I sing Jackson and Prescott. This year will tell us exactly what we need to know from Brock, playoffs included.

I think it is too early to rank Purdy top 10. He has only played 10 games, so the sample size is too small. I put him just below Goff and Carr, only bc bigger sample size. That being said I rank him higher than guys like Jimmy, Love, and Tannehill. Now if he keeps this up for the rest of the year he will be top 8.
My ranking is

1.Mahomes
2.Burrow
3.Allen
4.Herbert
5.Rodgers
6.Hurts
7.Jackson
8.Dak
9.Cousins
10.Tua
11.Smith
12.Wilson
13 Carr
14.Goff
15.Purdy (Could be #8 by end of year)
16. Jimmy
17.Love

Originally posted by SLCNiner:
Suppose that's fair enough. Hurts had an MVP season last year had it not been for the missed games, and I truly believe he comes back to earth this year. I do have faith in Purdy, especially based off his playoff performances, which is the same reason I sing Jackson and Prescott. This year will tell us exactly what we need to know from Brock, playoffs included.

Hurts had an amazing season on a great team but I could see him regressing a bit. Would love to see it, lol. Even with the great season he had, I would put him in the second tier of a QB ranking list. The top tier for me would be firm with Mahomes, Allen, Herbert, and Burrow.

Originally posted by D0PEMAN:
The main point is that us 49er fans fully expect a Superbowl win this year. And in order to accomplish that, Brock Purdy must prove that he can throw deep ACCURATELY. All Superbowl winning QBs had make these throws at some point in order to take the cake.

Just think about all the prior Superbowl winning QBs, they could ALL throw deep, accurately.

Please show us Brock Purdy. May this not be the thing that holds this team back, in the end.

Lulz

Originally posted by Jeepzilla:

Originally posted by D0PEMAN:
The main point is that us 49er fans fully expect a Superbowl win this year. And in order to accomplish that, Brock Purdy must prove that he can throw deep ACCURATELY. All Superbowl winning QBs had make these throws at some point in order to take the cake.

Just think about all the prior Superbowl winning QBs, they could ALL throw deep, accurately.

Please show us Brock Purdy. May this not be the thing that holds this team back, in the end.

Lulz

Originally posted by WildBill:
Purdy doesn't have to be statically great, just has to operate Kyle's offense and make a play here and there and avoid making the big guffaw.

hmmmm. if the defense is #1 again,...and if we can legit rely on a 2nd, 3rd RB to pound the ball with,...then perhaps. But there is a wealth of talent out there to catch passes this year.

Originally posted by WildBill:

Originally posted by clara543:

Originally posted by tankle104:
It's difficult to have a ton of yards and stuff in this offense because of how talented we are. We are very balanced, which makes sense cause of our rushing attack.

we would have to have an off game and rely on him to carry us, like the raiders game. Even then he didn't break 300 yards.

it's possible but not an easy task with the talent we have and our play calling style.

I don't see why not? Kyle Shanahan's offense with Atlanta did produce a 5,000 yard passer in Matt Ryan and a 1,100 yard rusher in Devonta Freeman.

Helps when you have Julio Jones. Not to mention an established QB like Ryan. Not dissing Deebo or Aiyuk, but Julio, 6-3 4.39 40

Julio is 1 guy,...lol. We have this Kittle guy too,...he's pretty nice as well. We're certainly top-heavy in pass catchers.

Originally posted by D0PEMAN:

Originally posted by Jeepzilla:

Originally posted by D0PEMAN:
The main point is that us 49er fans fully expect a Superbowl win this year. And in order to accomplish that, Brock Purdy must prove that he can throw deep ACCURATELY. All Superbowl winning QBs had make these throws at some point in order to take the cake.

Just think about all the prior Superbowl winning QBs, they could ALL throw deep, accurately.

Please show us Brock Purdy. May this not be the thing that holds this team back, in the end.

Lulz

if we hit the wide open guy down the middle, we keep driving

Originally posted by D0PEMAN:

We all wish he would have hit that pass, but it was wasn't necessarily a game deciding play anymore than a variety of other factors including:

- The missed plays Jimmy left on the field throughout the 4th quarter that were not deep passes.
- Going away from the run game, which was our bread and butter
- Our defense allowing a 3rd and 15 conversion and effectively collapsing overall in the 4th quarter.

Even if Jimmy converts that play the Chiefs still have the time to drive down the field and tie or win the game. It wasn't a magic bullet, lol.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by D0PEMAN:

We all wish he would have hit that pass, but it was wasn't necessarily a game deciding play anymore than a variety of other factors including:

- The missed plays Jimmy left on the field throughout the 4th quarter that were not deep passes.
- Going away from the run game, which was our bread and butter
- Our defense allowing a 3rd and 15 conversion and effectively collapsing overall in the 4th quarter.

Even if Jimmy converts that play the Chiefs still have the time to drive down the field and tie or win the game. It wasn't a magic bullet, lol.

Fair post. However my point is that a deep bomb is what it takes sometimes to change the game (happens a lot in the Superbowl). If this had been completed for 6 it would've been a heavy momentum swing, and who knows what could've happened after that. Maybe Jimmy would be wearing the ring today.

Originally posted by D0PEMAN:

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by D0PEMAN:

We all wish he would have hit that pass, but it was wasn't necessarily a game deciding play anymore than a variety of other factors including:

- The missed plays Jimmy left on the field throughout the 4th quarter that were not deep passes.
- Going away from the run game, which was our bread and butter
- Our defense allowing a 3rd and 15 conversion and effectively collapsing overall in the 4th quarter.

Even if Jimmy converts that play the Chiefs still have the time to drive down the field and tie or win the game. It wasn't a magic bullet, lol.

Fair post. However my point is that a deep bomb is what it takes sometimes to change the game (happens a lot in the Superbowl). If this had been completed for 6 it would've been a heavy momentum swing, and who knows what could've happened after that. Maybe Jimmy would be wearing the ring today.

Shanny have TAKEN OUT those deep post pattern from his playbook after CJ and PETTIS couldn't perfected it !!

coach GRIESE needs too teach STEADY PURDY to put MORE air on the ball when he's throwing those BOMBS !!

Originally posted by D0PEMAN:

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by D0PEMAN:

We all wish he would have hit that pass, but it was wasn't necessarily a game deciding play anymore than a variety of other factors including:

- The missed plays Jimmy left on the field throughout the 4th quarter that were not deep passes.
- Going away from the run game, which was our bread and butter
- Our defense allowing a 3rd and 15 conversion and effectively collapsing overall in the 4th quarter.

Even if Jimmy converts that play the Chiefs still have the time to drive down the field and tie or win the game. It wasn't a magic bullet, lol.

Fair post. However my point is that a deep bomb is what it takes sometimes to change the game (happens a lot in the Superbowl). If this had been completed for 6 it would've been a heavy momentum swing, and who knows what could've happened after that. Maybe Jimmy would be wearing the ring today.

deep throws don't happen a lot in the superbowl, heck it didn't even happen in that super bowl in your clip

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by D0PEMAN:

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by D0PEMAN:

We all wish he would have hit that pass, but it was wasn't necessarily a game deciding play anymore than a variety of other factors including:

- The missed plays Jimmy left on the field throughout the 4th quarter that were not deep passes.
- Going away from the run game, which was our bread and butter
- Our defense allowing a 3rd and 15 conversion and effectively collapsing overall in the 4th quarter.

Even if Jimmy converts that play the Chiefs still have the time to drive down the field and tie or win the game. It wasn't a magic bullet, lol.

Fair post. However my point is that a deep bomb is what it takes sometimes to change the game (happens a lot in the Superbowl). If this had been completed for 6 it would've been a heavy momentum swing, and who knows what could've happened after that. Maybe Jimmy would be wearing the ring today.

deep throws don't happen a lot in the superbowl, heck it didn't even happen in that super bowl in your clip

BOTTOM LINE - the game should not have came down to this pass.. we were UP 10 points and had the best RB in the POST SEASON..

Originally posted by 9moon:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by D0PEMAN:

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by D0PEMAN:

We all wish he would have hit that pass, but it was wasn't necessarily a game deciding play anymore than a variety of other factors including:

- The missed plays Jimmy left on the field throughout the 4th quarter that were not deep passes.
- Going away from the run game, which was our bread and butter
- Our defense allowing a 3rd and 15 conversion and effectively collapsing overall in the 4th quarter.

Even if Jimmy converts that play the Chiefs still have the time to drive down the field and tie or win the game. It wasn't a magic bullet, lol.

Fair post. However my point is that a deep bomb is what it takes sometimes to change the game (happens a lot in the Superbowl). If this had been completed for 6 it would've been a heavy momentum swing, and who knows what could've happened after that. Maybe Jimmy would be wearing the ring today.

deep throws don't happen a lot in the superbowl, heck it didn't even happen in that super bowl in your clip

BOTTOM LINE - the game should not have came down to this pass.. we were UP 10 points and had the best RB in the POST SEASON..

no it shouldn't, but the run was stuffed and had to throw on 3rd & long

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by 9moon:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by D0PEMAN:

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by D0PEMAN:

We all wish he would have hit that pass, but it was wasn't necessarily a game deciding play anymore than a variety of other factors including:

- The missed plays Jimmy left on the field throughout the 4th quarter that were not deep passes.
- Going away from the run game, which was our bread and butter
- Our defense allowing a 3rd and 15 conversion and effectively collapsing overall in the 4th quarter.

Even if Jimmy converts that play the Chiefs still have the time to drive down the field and tie or win the game. It wasn't a magic bullet, lol.

Fair post. However my point is that a deep bomb is what it takes sometimes to change the game (happens a lot in the Superbowl). If this had been completed for 6 it would've been a heavy momentum swing, and who knows what could've happened after that. Maybe Jimmy would be wearing the ring today.

deep throws don't happen a lot in the superbowl, heck it didn't even happen in that super bowl in your clip

BOTTOM LINE - the game should not have came down to this pass.. we were UP 10 points and had the best RB in the POST SEASON..

no it shouldn't, but the run was stuffed and had to throw on 3rd & long

U may want to watch the Shanny Super Bowl Fiasco again and learn how easily he gave up not only with the running game, but also stopped calling the Deeva and Juice's #s...

Also, do you NOT wonder why 26 started the game over 31, and why he waited until the 2nd QTR to use 31?