QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by thl408:

Originally posted by boast:
first time seeing sports knockoffs made in other countries?

lol it's missing an 's' after 49er and so I'm reading it with a chinese accent.

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by YACBros85:
Yes. If it wasn't a contested 50/50 ball.

Call it subjective all you want. But pff has operational definitions so they are fair with their evaluations. So compared to the other 41 QB's that qualified, he was middle of the pack in the TWP% category.

So if he lobs up every pass for his WR to fight for a ball, he will never get dinged with a TWP? IMO it's a flawed stat then. If you throw a ball behind someone and it's just floating up there, I'd say that putting the ball in harms way.

Why do you have to take it to such extremes? Like I stated in the post you responded to.

Pff has operational definitions so they are fair with their evaluations. So compared to the other 41 QB's that qualified, he was middle of the pack in the TWP% category.

Nothing is being extreme. I'm pointing out how flawed that sounds. That's all

thoughts on that almost INT from Diggs as well? Looked like he threw it directly Barr near the LOS and tipped it. I feel like he didn't even see him standing there.

also I watched some of the snaps (from what I could find)

I saw an amazing seam route throw by Brock flat footed QBs guys in his grill. Great throw

I also saw two plays that if Lance did it… we'd be screaming that he didn't know what he was doing. Two plays that were similar to the preseason game from Lance, with seeing a guy open and not pulling the trigger.

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by SLCNiner:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Brock Purdy 23 Make The San Francisco 49ers Great Again Shirthttps://t.co/UYYwilurR3 pic.twitter.com/AXpRul0U74

— Aliba shirt (@AlibaShirt) August 16, 2023

Brock & CMC make the 49ers great again! Haaha

🤮🤮🤮

I didn't mean it as anytbing political, I just thought it was funny that some random person is tryna profit off this. Lol

That's ugly as s**t, toss in the catch phrase

personally I like the brock purdy hat that's out there much more.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by YACBros85:
Yes. If it wasn't a contested 50/50 ball.

Call it subjective all you want. But pff has operational definitions so they are fair with their evaluations. So compared to the other 41 QB's that qualified, he was middle of the pack in the TWP% category.

So if he lobs up every pass for his WR to fight for a ball, he will never get dinged with a TWP? IMO it's a flawed stat then. If you throw a ball behind someone and it's just floating up there, I'd say that putting the ball in harms way.

Why do you have to take it to such extremes? Like I stated in the post you responded to.

Pff has operational definitions so they are fair with their evaluations. So compared to the other 41 QB's that qualified, he was middle of the pack in the TWP% category.

Nothing is being extreme. I'm pointing out how flawed that sounds. That's all

thoughts on that almost INT from Diggs as well? Looked like he threw it directly Barr near the LOS and tipped it. I feel like he didn't even see him standing there.

also I watched some of the snaps (from what I could find)

I saw an amazing seam route throw by Brock flat footed QBs guys in his grill. Great throw

I also saw two plays that if Lance did it… we'd be screaming that he didn't know what he was doing. Two plays that were similar to the preseason game from Lance, with seeing a guy open and not pulling the trigger.

It becomes extreme when you reach the heights of "every pass" to try and win an argument. And you still ignored the fact that pff evaluates player stats through operational definitions and its more about where he sits amongst his peers than is about the objectiveness of the isolated stat alone.

Originally posted by tankle104:

I really really hope I'm right. The Brock Purdy #13 T-shirt arrived last week. It's next to the @SteveYoungQB (Lefty GOAT) one in the closet. https://t.co/SrBwpJAJOr

— Brian Feeley (@DrBrianFeeley) August 16, 2023

Letssssz goooo

Why so long to get a Purdy shirt?:) I got my jersey last yr. Next to my Rice jersey & Kittle signed jersey

Originally posted by Montana:

Originally posted by tankle104:

I really really hope I'm right. The Brock Purdy #13 T-shirt arrived last week. It's next to the @SteveYoungQB (Lefty GOAT) one in the closet. https://t.co/SrBwpJAJOr

— Brian Feeley (@DrBrianFeeley) August 16, 2023

Letssssz goooo

Why so long to get a Purdy shirt?:) I got my jersey last yr. Next to my Rice jersey & Kittle signed jersey

A girl bought me a Purdy jersey for my birthday! So I'm locked n loaded too!

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by Montana:

Originally posted by tankle104:

I really really hope I'm right. The Brock Purdy #13 T-shirt arrived last week. It's next to the @SteveYoungQB (Lefty GOAT) one in the closet. https://t.co/SrBwpJAJOr

— Brian Feeley (@DrBrianFeeley) August 16, 2023

Letssssz goooo

Why so long to get a Purdy shirt?:) I got my jersey last yr. Next to my Rice jersey & Kittle signed jersey

A girl bought me a Purdy jersey for my birthday! So I'm locked n loaded too!

LIES!

Originally posted by Waterbear:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by Montana:

Originally posted by tankle104:

I really really hope I'm right. The Brock Purdy #13 T-shirt arrived last week. It's next to the @SteveYoungQB (Lefty GOAT) one in the closet. https://t.co/SrBwpJAJOr

— Brian Feeley (@DrBrianFeeley) August 16, 2023

Letssssz goooo

Why so long to get a Purdy shirt?:) I got my jersey last yr. Next to my Rice jersey & Kittle signed jersey

A girl bought me a Purdy jersey for my birthday! So I'm locked n loaded too!

LIES!

😭😭 I can dream! Hahah

I hate that we can get updates for practice live now 😭

Originally posted by tankle104:
I didn't mean it as anytbing political, I just thought it was funny that some random person is tryna profit off this. Lol

Reminds me of the guy a few years back that had a photo with him and Aldon wearing a Make the 49ers Great Again hat going around every 49ers forum and site trying to get people to buy it.

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by YACBros85:
Yes. If it wasn't a contested 50/50 ball.

Call it subjective all you want. But pff has operational definitions so they are fair with their evaluations. So compared to the other 41 QB's that qualified, he was middle of the pack in the TWP% category.

So if he lobs up every pass for his WR to fight for a ball, he will never get dinged with a TWP? IMO it's a flawed stat then. If you throw a ball behind someone and it's just floating up there, I'd say that putting the ball in harms way.

Why do you have to take it to such extremes? Like I stated in the post you responded to.

Pff has operational definitions so they are fair with their evaluations. So compared to the other 41 QB's that qualified, he was middle of the pack in the TWP% category.

Nothing is being extreme. I'm pointing out how flawed that sounds. That's all

thoughts on that almost INT from Diggs as well? Looked like he threw it directly Barr near the LOS and tipped it. I feel like he didn't even see him standing there.

also I watched some of the snaps (from what I could find)

I saw an amazing seam route throw by Brock flat footed QBs guys in his grill. Great throw

I also saw two plays that if Lance did it… we'd be screaming that he didn't know what he was doing. Two plays that were similar to the preseason game from Lance, with seeing a guy open and not pulling the trigger.

It becomes extreme when you reach the heights of "every pass" to try and win an argument. And you still ignored the fact that pff evaluates player stats through operational definitions and its more about where he sits amongst his peers than is about the objectiveness of the isolated stat alone.

So maybe TWP isn't the correct stat to debate with, if we're talking about bad passes or putting the ball in harms way?

Again so any passes that are lobbed up in the air aren't considered TWPs? That's just a "50/50" passing attempt? Really? That's what you're telling me…nothing extreme pointing out a flaw in a random stat that clearly has its issues. Yes it's a tool, does it cover all the basis of what some might consider "turnover worthy" no. Again it's subjective overall, regardless if they have "their" definition of what is or isn't.

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by Waterbear:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by Montana:

Originally posted by tankle104:

I really really hope I'm right. The Brock Purdy #13 T-shirt arrived last week. It's next to the @SteveYoungQB (Lefty GOAT) one in the closet. https://t.co/SrBwpJAJOr

— Brian Feeley (@DrBrianFeeley) August 16, 2023

Letssssz goooo

Why so long to get a Purdy shirt?:) I got my jersey last yr. Next to my Rice jersey & Kittle signed jersey

A girl bought me a Purdy jersey for my birthday! So I'm locked n loaded too!

LIES!

😭😭 I can dream! Hahah

Hahahaha

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:

Originally posted by tankle104:
I didn't mean it as anytbing political, I just thought it was funny that some random person is tryna profit off this. Lol

Reminds me of the guy a few years back that had a photo with him and Aldon wearing a Make the 49ers Great Again hat going around every 49ers forum and site trying to get people to buy it.

I remember that! If I was to get anything Brock related it would probably be this hat