49ers vs. Eagles Tickets Available! →

There are 166 users in the forums

QB Brock Purdy Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online

QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by TrojanPV:
Demand a fortune? We probably couldn't even get a 6th round pick for him. He'll be lucky to be on a roster in a few years.

He's still 23 (right now) so someone may take a flier on him, but he's just so far behind the development curve in terms of playing time. And that's unlikely to change in the next 1-2 years unless we have massive injuries again (always possible).

And I gotta believe that if QB whisperer Shanny gives up on him, the league will listen.

Geno Smith is starting in SEA right now and he is pretty good. Are you familiar with his story?
Originally posted by tankle104:
Some random offensive coach out here criticizing our boy.

https://apple.news/A2neKP0lNTFqAupHtTd1iRQ

I tend to pay more attention to the coaches that drafted him are paying him and that have him in the building
Originally posted by Pillbusta:
Originally posted by tankle104:
Some random offensive coach out here criticizing our boy.

https://apple.news/A2neKP0lNTFqAupHtTd1iRQ

I tend to pay more attention to the coaches that drafted him are paying him and that have him in the building

I think it's the same unnamed source that is knocking Jordan love. Lol although I don't think much of a love, I just don't really get randomly knocking a handful of players anonymously
Originally posted by tankle104:
Some random offensive coach out here criticizing our boy.

https://apple.news/A2neKP0lNTFqAupHtTd1iRQ

I mean it's not totally far fetched. That's the beauty we don't need a QB that can play great on 25 other teams. We need a QB that is great at what he's asked to do here
[ Edited by krizay on Jul 31, 2023 at 6:04 PM ]
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
Originally posted by tankle104:
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
Originally posted by tankle104:
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
Originally posted by tankle104:
I think the team is also looking at the upcoming salary cap and at this point, that falls in Brock's favor. The team has openly talked about the trade up because they wanted a rookie scale QB to help with the salary cap going forward to keep the team in tact. Since Lance will only have one more year remaining before he will demand a fortune, I think the team views Brock as QB1 and is going to give him as many opportunities as possible to secure that - outside of his stellar play last year.

so I think that's something Lance doesn't have working in his favor in regards to getting QB1. He would have to play out of his mind to change that right now.

that's just my opinion, I don't think the team cares about being "right" with the picks or trying to recoup the lost capital - I think they look at that as over and done with.

i just want to see Brock get better and then Lance and darnold get as crisp as possible to make the QB room strong for the season, If they're needed.

You got me at TL will demand a fortune

Well if he plays well, not even great, just above average - the going rate is like $35M+ these days. Since the top QBs are making late $45M-$50M. I don't think there is any way in hell we would want to do that to our cap.

I view TL as a backup, no offense to TL, and I know ppl get sore on the subject.. but I am trying to keep a reality based view. BP is QB1. TL is backup. So TL gets backup dollars, he can take a look at Darnold, if he wants to know what that looks like. The current Darnold contract. We can update this calculation, if he moves up from backup to starter.

I view him as the backup too, because that's what he currently is. I was just saying that some people are hoping he can beat out Brock, I was saying that I don't think Kyle/John really care for that because they desire a cheap QB who can play at a high level. Since this is year 3/4 of his contract, we've sorta lost that benefit and he it goes in and plays well - he's going to want a ton of money soon. Where as Brock will be cheap for the next three years. So Lance would have to play significantly better than Brock to justify that. I don't think the team is eager to do that.

Yup, BP helps the salary cap in a number of ways, It's a rook deal, it is year 2 of that deal, instead of TL which is year 3. Also he makes about 800-900k per year (varies a bit each year). TL makes like 10x what BP does. even on the rook deal, BP is way cheaper. I don't think TL will want a ton of money soon, I think he would just want a place where he can have an NFL paycheck, and compete, like what Sam has now. I'm forecasting BP to get the starts, and play well, for the time being. Only way I see a big TL payday, is if BP gets hurt, so TL has games to showcase himself, or if BP doesn't play well, giving TL such games.

It's an interesting situation.

Could Lance have officially be on the cusp or already at the point of turning the corner? I mean, let's be honest, even if the injuries hadn't happened, it's not really any surprise he needed a bit more time to adjust.

Let's say he's there now, like at that sort of pre-breakout stage young guys get, where they need maybe 6-8 games (or so) of reps before they really start coming into their own.

But, in this hypothetical, what is best for us..

Brock stays healthy all year, plays well, and we hope Trey does a small extension to lower his cap hit and continue developing here?

If he has to play this year and does super well, does he compete with Brock to start next year? Or do we try to trade him? What would his market be?

There's a lot of possibilities. At the end of the day I'm just glad we have fortified the position to hopefully never have a repeat of how last season ended.
Clelin Ferrell hit the ball out of Brocky's hand today ?

CUT HIM
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Seems like Brock is a mixed bag today. Do better tomorrow

I'm hearing he was solid, strung two bad plays in a row but other than that he was good
Originally posted by riverrunzthruit:
Clelin Ferrell hit the ball out of Brocky's hand today ?

CUT HIM

What bothered me most was not hearing that any o lineman knocked CF on his ass for that.
Originally posted by riverrunzthruit:
Clelin Ferrell hit the ball out of Brocky's hand today ?

CUT HIM

Uh he needs that to happen now. It's going to happen in real games
Originally posted by Pillbusta:
Originally posted by TrojanPV:
Demand a fortune? We probably couldn't even get a 6th round pick for him. He'll be lucky to be on a roster in a few years.

He's still 23 (right now) so someone may take a flier on him, but he's just so far behind the development curve in terms of playing time. And that's unlikely to change in the next 1-2 years unless we have massive injuries again (always possible).

And I gotta believe that if QB whisperer Shanny gives up on him, the league will listen.

Geno Smith is starting in SEA right now and he is pretty good. Are you familiar with his story?

Yeah you gotta be QB1, play, and play well. TL isn't QB1, and he has yet to play much, or play very well. While it could happen, I wouldn't say he's in line for a big payday, unless his situation changes. BP would be in line for the payday. But it's a ways off for both guys. Final year of the contract, is most important, as Daniel Jones shows. Geno also. They both played well, in contract years.
Originally posted by frenchmov:
Originally posted by riverrunzthruit:
Clelin Ferrell hit the ball out of Brocky's hand today ?

CUT HIM

Uh he needs that to happen now. It's going to happen in real games

Uh no, he does not need that to happen in practice where EVERYONE knows QBs aren't supposed to be hit or even touched
Anyone notice the quads on Brock? Clearly when he couldn't throw he was in a squat rack pumping out reps. I think he's going to carry D linemen this year if they try to jump on him.
Originally posted by frenchmov:
Originally posted by riverrunzthruit:
Clelin Ferrell hit the ball out of Brocky's hand today ?

CUT HIM

Uh he needs that to happen now. It's going to happen in real games

Yeah, people need to understand that the injury that happened to broke was like 1/10000 chance, per doctors. It had to happen at a specific moment while he was throwing at a specific angle and the pass rusher had a specific angle and speed.
i understand we don't want him getting hurt but if he can experience those situations now, it'll better prepare him for the season.

don't blame Ferrell - blame whatever bunk as lineman let him through.
Originally posted by tankle104:
Originally posted by frenchmov:
Originally posted by riverrunzthruit:
Clelin Ferrell hit the ball out of Brocky's hand today ?

CUT HIM

Uh he needs that to happen now. It's going to happen in real games

Yeah, people need to understand that the injury that happened to broke was like 1/10000 chance, per doctors. It had to happen at a specific moment while he was throwing at a specific angle and the pass rusher had a specific angle and speed.
i understand we don't want him getting hurt but if he can experience those situations now, it'll better prepare him for the season.

don't blame Ferrell - blame whatever bunk as lineman let him through.

Lol yeah I would bet my house that you wouldn't feel that way if Purdy got re-injured.
Originally posted by Pillbusta:
Geno Smith is starting in SEA right now and he is pretty good. Are you familiar with his story?

Yup. And if I use the same exact splits I used for TL/Brock/Mac/Fields, Geno has 2200 attempts. Versus only 400 for Lance.

It's a nice story for Geno to have one good season at the age of 32. But if that's the comparison you are using to justify TL, it's quite a reach.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone