QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by Jeepzilla:
Again, he didn't get more then 100 passing attempts because he's been injured constantly..

For someone who preaches context, you refuse to use it here.

Which has what to do with what I said? We're talking about 100 passing attempts. I brought up a player who was regarded as a generational talent and his first 100 passing attempts (and how f**king horrible it looked). I can provide a list of young QBs and their s**tty first 100 passing attempts if you'd like? That's all we have to establish anything on him…basically nothing and people are cool tossing him in the trash or trying to move him for nothing.

people couldn't stomach the idea of lance playing year one because "we were trying to win a SB" now those very SAME people are telling me BCB gets to struggle and play through whatever because they said so. How about we quit the hypocritical b******t?

if you want to talk about health, that's an issue with Lance and apparently Brock all the same. My point is none of these QBs should be given the keys to the car and be allowed to struggle for any extended amount of time. I just listened to Chris Simms say that he knows kyle, and he will have no problem "pulling the band-Aid" on any QB if they struggle and put in the next guy in.

Lol
it has everything to do with Lance getting more reps.
how the heck is he suppose to get more reps when he's been injured a lot?

he has had two surgery's on his ankle and two on his finger and he had a knees sprain I believe against the cards..

if he'd have stayed healthy last year, Kyle possibly would have rode with him all year and worked thru his ups and downs.
the point is, we don't know.

now with Purdy playing as well as he did, Kyle may feel he wants to go with the player that is more ready TODAY.

lets see how it plays out.

Originally posted by NYniner85:
I've just learned to wait a little bit before putting all my eggs in one QB basket. Same s**t with Kap.

our fan base is thirsty for a FQB. There's no patience at all. I get it

I am old enough to remember when you advocated we cut JG in 2021 and start a rook TL from the jump

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by NYniner85:
I've just learned to wait a little bit before putting all my eggs in one QB basket. Same s**t with Kap.

our fan base is thirsty for a FQB. There's no patience at all. I get it

I am old enough to remember when you advocated we cut JG in 2021 and start a rook TL from the jump

And in hindsight you can't say he was wrong. We didn't win it all that season and we have 0 clue where Lance and the team would be now had we played him.

Originally posted by Jeepzilla:
I feel Brock showed more poise and had better numbers in the playoffs than Jimmy ever has. That alone is a reason to be positive.

Lance could be really good in the regular season, but a lot of QB's choke when playoffs come around. What Purdy showed in the playoffs give me confidence that he won't just crash and burn.

Based off what the Dallas game? I mean objectively I don't think he played particularly well there. Seattle stinks and we played them like 3 weeks prior. I will say in that game he did more than Jimmy ever did in the playoffs. Hoping he maintains his play and works on some stuff that needs to be worked on. We will see. No off season to develop just rehab

IMO if we lose CMC for any extended amount of time, we're in trouble. Regardless of who the QB is. I'm praying Kyle doesn't ride him into the ground.

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by NYniner85:
I've just learned to wait a little bit before putting all my eggs in one QB basket. Same s**t with Kap.

our fan base is thirsty for a FQB. There's no patience at all. I get it

I am old enough to remember when you advocated we cut JG in 2021 and start a rook TL from the jump

And in hindsight you can't say he was wrong. We didn't win it all that season and we have 0 clue where Lance and the team would be now had we played him.

Oh he was wrong, making it to the playoffs is the first step (actually second). And with a raw Trey Lance, no way the 9ers would've made it to the playoffs, you're kidding yourself if you say/think otherwise.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by NYniner85:
I've just learned to wait a little bit before putting all my eggs in one QB basket. Same s**t with Kap.

our fan base is thirsty for a FQB. There's no patience at all. I get it

I am old enough to remember when you advocated we cut JG in 2021 and start a rook TL from the jump

Yeah and I was right. We didn't win a Super Bowl and we paid him a f**k ton of money that could have went elsewhere. We ALL knew who Jimmy was at that point…the organization was doing whatever they could to move off him.

Now we still don't know who Lance is. I had complete patience in letting him play and develop. Sitting the bench hasn't done s**t and we're into YR3. Try again to making up a straw man rebuttal 🥱

Originally posted by Kolohe:
Oh he was wrong, making it to the playoffs is the first step (actually second). And with a raw Trey Lance, no way the 9ers would've made it to the playoffs, you're kidding yourself if you say/think otherwise.

Wrong how? We didn't win anything last I checked. We didn't get Lance on the field to develop. We have no clue what he is or isn't. We just got to watch s**tty Jimmy in the playoffs. Running around hurt like always.

you have no clue if they could have made it to the playoffs…I've seen you post s**t about not being satisfied with going to just the playoffs. Now you're trying to back it up saying it was a success lol. Please.

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by NYniner85:
I've just learned to wait a little bit before putting all my eggs in one QB basket. Same s**t with Kap.

our fan base is thirsty for a FQB. There's no patience at all. I get it

I am old enough to remember when you advocated we cut JG in 2021 and start a rook TL from the jump

And in hindsight you can't say he was wrong. We didn't win it all that season and we have 0 clue where Lance and the team would be now had we played him.

Oh he was wrong, making it to the playoffs is the first step (actually second). And with a raw Trey Lance, no way the 9ers would've made it to the playoffs, you're kidding yourself if you say/think otherwise.

That's the beauty of hypothetical situations...can't prove them wrong or right.

What we do KNOW is we didn't win it all with Jimmy starting.

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by NYniner85:
I've just learned to wait a little bit before putting all my eggs in one QB basket. Same s**t with Kap.

our fan base is thirsty for a FQB. There's no patience at all. I get it

I am old enough to remember when you advocated we cut JG in 2021 and start a rook TL from the jump

And in hindsight you can't say he was wrong. We didn't win it all that season and we have 0 clue where Lance and the team would be now had we played him.

On a number of fronts I def can. First off he is impatient, which was his claim above, so he is guilty of what he is accusing others. Second, TL wasn't healthy if you recall correct, which have put us in a bind, if we had to play him injured, or some other guy off the street in his place. Third, he wasn't ready, which is why KS didn't play him year 1 to begin with, imo. You can burn young QBs, if you play em before they are ready to perform well, they lose confidence. Wilson I would say wasn't emotionally or mentally ready to be QB1, and now he isn't (Zach Wilson).

This is my opinion, and as a matter of opinion, I can certainly say he was wrong then, and still is, regarding rushing TL into action. KS agreed via his actions.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by Kolohe:
Oh he was wrong, making it to the playoffs is the first step (actually second). And with a raw Trey Lance, no way the 9ers would've made it to the playoffs, you're kidding yourself if you say/think otherwise.

Wrong how? We didn't win anything last I checked. We didn't get Lance on the field to develop. We have no clue what he is or isn't. We just got to watch s**tty Jimmy in the playoffs. Running around hurt like always.

you have no clue if they could have made it to the playoffs…I've seen you post s**t about not being satisfied with going to just the playoffs. Now you're trying to back it up saying it was a success lol. Please.

Isn't this contradicting since Lance is running around and is always hurt?

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by Furlow:
Jimmy! Jimmy!

Wellll…most of the people that are going nuts over Brock just migrated off the Jimmy train. They're now diminishing what they were so "convicted" in with Jimmy to prop up BCB. It's pretty wild actually lol.

But yes it's the Brock thread.

I don't see anyone diminishing what Jimmy did. He was spectacular in 2017 and turned around the entire franchise with his play and leadership.

Purdy is simply better.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
On a number of fronts I def can. First off he is impatient, which was his claim above, so he is guilty of what he is accusing others. Second, TL wasn't healthy if you recall correct, which have put us in a bind, if we had to play him injured, or some other guy off the street in his place. Third, he wasn't ready, which is why KS didn't play him year 1 to begin with, imo. You can burn young QBs, if you play em before they are ready to perform well, they lose confidence. Wilson I would say wasn't emotionally or mentally ready to be QB1, and now he isn't (Zach Wilson).

This is my opinion, and as a matter of opinion, I can certainly say he was wrong then, and still is, regarding rushing TL into action. KS agreed via his actions.

this dude 😂 Faithful claimed Lance was gonna be the MVP toss 40 TDs blah blah blah. Now he's all but over him after 30 passing attempts last yr has the balls to call me inpatient.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
On a number of fronts I def can. First off he is impatient, which was his claim above, so he is guilty of what he is accusing others. Second, TL wasn't healthy if you recall correct, which have put us in a bind, if we had to play him injured, or some other guy off the street in his place. Third, he wasn't ready, which is why KS didn't play him year 1 to begin with, imo. You can burn young QBs, if you play em before they are ready to perform well, they lose confidence. Wilson I would say wasn't emotionally or mentally ready to be QB1, and now he isn't (Zach Wilson).

This is my opinion, and as a matter of opinion, I can certainly say he was wrong then, and still is, regarding rushing TL into action. KS agreed via his actions.

this dude 😂 Faithful claimed Lance was gonna be the MVP toss 40 TDs blah blah blah. Now he's all but over him after 30 passing attempts last yr has the balls to call me inpatient.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
On a number of fronts I def can. First off he is impatient, which was his claim above, so he is guilty of what he is accusing others. Second, TL wasn't healthy if you recall correct, which have put us in a bind, if we had to play him injured, or some other guy off the street in his place. Third, he wasn't ready, which is why KS didn't play him year 1 to begin with, imo. You can burn young QBs, if you play em before they are ready to perform well, they lose confidence. Wilson I would say wasn't emotionally or mentally ready to be QB1, and now he isn't (Zach Wilson).

This is my opinion, and as a matter of opinion, I can certainly say he was wrong then, and still is, regarding rushing TL into action. KS agreed via his actions.

this dude 😂 Faithful claimed Lance was gonna be the MVP toss 40 TDs blah blah blah. Now he's all but over him after 30 passing attempts last yr has the balls to call me inpatient.

I am just pointing out you said the fanbase lacks patience, I see that in you, when you wanted to play him day 1, ready or not.

I get it, when the org takes a guy that high, and gives up that much draft capital, we all want to see the guy.

I was fine with him sitting year 1. I am fine if he sits year 3, if he needs it for his development.

BP I try to be patient with also, if he needs time from his injury, we shouldn't rush him. I find teams with the most patience at the position, do the best. KC was patient with Mahomes. GB patient with Rodgers, now Love. Those two orgs, do well at QB.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
I am just pointing out you said the fanbase lacks patience, I see that in you, when you wanted to play him day 1, ready or not.

I get it, when the org takes a guy that high, and gives up that much draft capital, we all want to see the guy.

I was fine with him sitting year 1. I am fine if he sits year 3, if he needs it for his development.

BP I try to be patient with also, if he needs time from his injury, we shouldn't rush him. I find teams with the most patience at the position, do the best. KC was patient with Mahomes. GB patient with Rodgers, now Love. Those two orgs, do well at QB.

How was KC any more patient with Pat than Kyle was with Trey? And how do you even know if the peckers' patience with Love means he'll do well?