QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by English:

Originally posted by riverrunzthruit:
https://www.49erswebzone.com/articles/168295-one-writer-ponders-texans-trade-49ers-brock-purdy/

The Texan writer is an idiot. Not further comment needed.

Originally posted by Polkadots:

Originally posted by riverrunzthruit:
https://www.49erswebzone.com/articles/168295-one-writer-ponders-texans-trade-49ers-brock-purdy/

I mean, this is the problem with society as a whole. We have done away with merit. Any moron can get a job like this, when said moron should probably be out digging holes.

The author has zero logical sense. He says, about Purdy, "he is the "real deal" instead of a "one-hit-wonder."" The author follows this with, "it may not take a first-round pick to swing a deal for him. Parting with a couple of second, third, or fourth-round picks over the next two years would be a win-win." No guy, it would not be a win for the 49ers. It's not about where you drafted a guy, it's about what that player brings to the table. If you believe Purdy is the real deal, then Purdy is worth a s**t ton. Not just a singular first round pick, but multiple, especially given his current cost.

f**king idiots everywhere. When is Elon going to get his s**t together so I can buy a ticket off this planet.

Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:
It isn't the wishful thinking that's the problem. It's a the LUDICROUS notion that Brock isn't worth MULTIPLE first round picks, let alone not even one.

Originally posted by tankle104:
Well.. yeah. Lol that's widely understood. That's why baseball players come back throwing harder most of the time. I thought that went without saying.

Originally posted by Waterbear:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by tankle104:
It is true that we don't have any reliable data of these past surgeries/rehab for football but I don't think he will miss the season, unless something ridiculous happens.

i think he'll be back week 1, but I know that I'm being optimistic. There is a good chance he won't be ready for the first 4 weeks or so of the season.

the arm strength thing is even something Purdy said, so that's not just us being optimistic. He said it's possible his arm is stronger after the rehab. It may not be but if he is saying it, I believe it.

Darnold of been brought in because Purdy possibly wouldn't be ready week 1, I'm sure that was a factor, doesn't explain them saying he has a chance to start. That part falls on Lance and his lack of development/health.

The only way it's "stronger" is because he will be focusing on other muscle groups around the elbow/arm during rehab. He will be working out other things because he can't throw…the surgery itself will not make his arm "stronger" like when pitchers have a total restructure of their UCL (TJ) and can throw harder. He did not have that surgery. Totally different scenarios. I just want to make that clear

they can say whatever they want. They told us Bucker was gonna be a 49er "for an every long time" that didn't happen. I take damn near everything they say right now with a grain of salt. They have no reason to say anything truthful. Also sure say Sam has a chance, I'm sure they would say Jason Poe has a chance to start at OG if it helps motivating everyone. To me it's meaningless coach/GM speak.

There's a difference in "wanting to believe" everything and just looking at what actually happens and the science behind all of it with his injury.

im not here to have a long debate about QBs anymore. It will all work itself out during camp.

Originally posted by SLCNiner:
Couldn't agree more. I was trying to point out the irony in how he dissects every word Kyle and John say about both QBs, trying to say it proves the team decided to move on from Trey. When Brock says he's not even sure if he'll play this season though, it falls on deaf ears. Should have heeded your advice about him long time ago. 🤦

Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:

Originally posted by Polkadots:

Originally posted by riverrunzthruit:
https://www.49erswebzone.com/articles/168295-one-writer-ponders-texans-trade-49ers-brock-purdy/

I mean, this is the problem with society as a whole. We have done away with merit. Any moron can get a job like this, when said moron should probably be out digging holes.

The author has zero logical sense. He says, about Purdy, "he is the "real deal" instead of a "one-hit-wonder."" The author follows this with, "it may not take a first-round pick to swing a deal for him. Parting with a couple of second, third, or fourth-round picks over the next two years would be a win-win." No guy, it would not be a win for the 49ers. It's not about where you drafted a guy, it's about what that player brings to the table. If you believe Purdy is the real deal, then Purdy is worth a s**t ton. Not just a singular first round pick, but multiple, especially given his current cost.

f**king idiots everywhere. When is Elon going to get his s**t together so I can buy a ticket off this planet.

It isn't the wishful thinking that's the problem. It's a the LUDICROUS notion that Brock isn't worth MULTIPLE first round picks, let alone not even one.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:
It isn't the wishful thinking that's the problem. It's a the LUDICROUS notion that Brock isn't worth MULTIPLE first round picks, let alone not even one.

I don't think that's a ludicrous notion. Every team scouted him as a udfa a year ago. He played at an extreme high level for short duration, on a loaded team. His throw arm is now jacked. I think many teams wouldn't even touch, thanks to the injury question, let alone part with a first, let alone part with multiple ones. The injury needs clarity.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:
It isn't the wishful thinking that's the problem. It's a the LUDICROUS notion that Brock isn't worth MULTIPLE first round picks, let alone not even one.

I don't think that's a ludicrous notion. Every team scouted him as a udfa a year ago. He played at an extreme high level for short duration, on a loaded team. His throw arm is now jacked. I think many teams wouldn't even touch, thanks to the injury question, let alone part with a first, let alone part with multiple ones. The injury needs clarity.

This. No one is trading multiple 1sts for Brock. I don't think anyone would trade one 1st as of right now.

I wouldn't be shocked if most GMs would be saying the only reason Brock looked like he did was because of Kyle and the roster…especially since everyone of them passed on him multiple times.

Originally posted by 49ersRing:
He's worth what the market determines he's worth. I'm not sure a lot of teams are lining up to give us two first round picks for a former 7th round pick with just 8 games under his belt on an extremely talented offense coming off of a major elbow injury that will keep him out for at least the entire offseason.

It doesn't matter either way, because we'd be crazy to trade any of our QBs at this point.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:

It isn't the wishful thinking that's the problem. It's a the LUDICROUS notion that Brock isn't worth MULTIPLE first round picks, let alone not even one.

I don't think that's a ludicrous notion. Every team scouted him as a udfa a year ago. He played at an extreme high level for short duration, on a loaded team. His throw arm is now jacked. I think many teams wouldn't even touch, thanks to the injury question, let alone part with a first, let alone part with multiple ones. The injury needs clarity.

This. No one is trading multiple 1sts for Brock. I don't think anyone would trade one 1st as of right now.

I wouldn't be shocked if most GMs would be saying the only reason Brock looked like he did was because of Kyle and the roster…especially since everyone of them passed on him multiple times.

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:
It isn't the wishful thinking that's the problem. It's a the LUDICROUS notion that Brock isn't worth MULTIPLE first round picks, let alone not even one.

I don't think that's a ludicrous notion. Every team scouted him as a udfa a year ago. He played at an extreme high level for short duration, on a loaded team. His throw arm is now jacked. I think many teams wouldn't even touch, thanks to the injury question, let alone part with a first, let alone part with multiple ones. The injury needs clarity.

This. No one is trading multiple 1sts for Brock. I don't think anyone would trade one 1st as of right now.

I wouldn't be shocked if most GMs would be saying the only reason Brock looked like he did was because of Kyle and the roster…especially since everyone of them passed on him multiple times.

That would be dumb because no one has ever done what Brock has done, it is unique.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Well.. yeah. Lol that's widely understood. That's why baseball players come back throwing harder most of the time. I thought that went without saying.

Well some in here have been "hoping" or under the assumption that his arm could come back stronger because of the surgery…which simply isn't true.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:

It isn't the wishful thinking that's the problem. It's a the LUDICROUS notion that Brock isn't worth MULTIPLE first round picks, let alone not even one.

I don't think that's a ludicrous notion. Every team scouted him as a udfa a year ago. He played at an extreme high level for short duration, on a loaded team. His throw arm is now jacked. I think many teams wouldn't even touch, thanks to the injury question, let alone part with a first, let alone part with multiple ones. The injury needs clarity.

This. No one is trading multiple 1sts for Brock. I don't think anyone would trade one 1st as of right now.

I wouldn't be shocked if most GMs would be saying the only reason Brock looked like he did was because of Kyle and the roster…especially since everyone of them passed on him multiple times.

That would be dumb because no one has ever done what Brock has done, it is unique.

He looked great in a short stretch like he was the FQB. I recall that done in 2017 also. Dif situations, as no two situations are exact same, but I see the parallels.