QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by NinerTy:
Can someone explain why the Niners can't generate multiple scores in the first half of games (as they did against the Bucs)? Even with Purdy there seems to be no energy or life to the offense during the first half of games

Originally posted by 49ersRing:
Brock's arm is worse than Brees's was in his last year when he realized his arm wasn't good enough to compete anymore. That's why he's a poor man's Drew Brees. That doesn't mean he can't be good in this system with Kyle Shanahan working around his limitations, but there is a definite cap on how great he can be. He'll never be able to compete against the Mahomes and Josh Allens of the world.

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:
Brock's arm is worse than Brees's was in his last year when he realized his arm wasn't good enough to compete anymore. That's why he's a poor man's Drew Brees. That doesn't mean he can't be good in this system with Kyle Shanahan working around his limitations, but there is a definite cap on how great he can be. He'll never be able to compete against the Mahomes and Josh Allens of the world.

Ring's takes about Purdy are as bad as his takes were about Jimmy.

the boldest above is hilarious.

Originally posted by Wubbie:
The throw to Ray Ray McCloud that Kittle intercepted really said a lot to me about his arm strength. There was some really nice zip on that ball that assured me his arm was stronger than the college scouting reports indicated.

Originally posted by Pillbusta:

Originally posted by billbird2111:
You really think there will be an offseason battle for starting QB if Purdy wins the Championship? Which he is poised to now do?

OK.

There will be if only one for the sake of optics. Trey was drafted to be the franchise. He will get a shot at it this offseason vs Brock. That does not mean he will make up any ground there but he will compete just like all of our guys compete and coach will go with the guy he believes gives him the best shot at winning going forward. That is just the way I see it going down because Brock was not drafted number 1 overall and then is playing like he is playing. Because so much was spent on Trey he will compete because they need to see if he can become the Josh Allen or even Jalen Hurts of the future. If he can't beat out Brock this summer he will hold the clipboard and run the scout team just as Brock has

Originally posted by Wubbie:

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:
Brock's arm is worse than Brees's was in his last year when he realized his arm wasn't good enough to compete anymore. That's why he's a poor man's Drew Brees. That doesn't mean he can't be good in this system with Kyle Shanahan working around his limitations, but there is a definite cap on how great he can be. He'll never be able to compete against the Mahomes and Josh Allens of the world.

Ring's takes about Purdy are as bad as his takes were about Jimmy.

the boldest above is hilarious.

The throw to Ray Ray McCloud that Kittle intercepted really said a lot to me about his arm strength. There was some really nice zip on that ball that assured me his arm was stronger than the college scouting reports indicated.

Originally posted by mojo_lo:
not a great game by Brock, started seeing more flaws manifest, e.g., two passes batted down and 1 INT, poor 1st half.

that said, he kept his bcb cool and we won handily. 2nd half was much better. had a 114.6 PR. never got flustered.

could he have done it without our dominating D? maybe...

could Jimmy have won that game? i think he would have too.

could Trey have won that game? don't think he's ready.

Originally posted by 49er-from-Yavin-IV:

Originally posted by mojo_lo:
not a great game by Brock, started seeing more flaws manifest, e.g., two passes batted down and 1 INT, poor 1st half.

that said, he kept his bcb cool and we won handily. 2nd half was much better. had a 114.6 PR. never got flustered.

could he have done it without our dominating D? maybe...

could Jimmy have won that game? i think he would have too.

could Trey have won that game? don't think he's ready.

May go into the record books as an interception, but that interception was not on Brock, it was on Jennings who tipped it to the defender.

Originally posted by mojo_lo:
not a great game by Brock, started seeing more flaws manifest, e.g., two passes batted down and 1 INT, poor 1st half.

that said, he kept his bcb cool and we won handily. 2nd half was much better. had a 114.6 PR. never got flustered. it's good to see the rook win against a tough team.

could he have done it without our dominating D? maybe...

could Jimmy have won that game? i think he would have too.

could Trey have won that game? don't think he's ready.

Originally posted by mojo_lo:
not a great game by Brock, started seeing more flaws manifest, e.g., two passes batted down and 1 INT, poor 1st half.

that said, he kept his bcb cool and we won handily. 2nd half was much better. had a 114.6 PR. never got flustered. it's good to see the rook win against a tough team.

could he have done it without our dominating D? maybe...

could Jimmy have won that game? i think he would have too.

could Trey have won that game? don't think he's ready.

Originally posted by mojo_lo:
not a great game by Brock, started seeing more flaws manifest, e.g., two passes batted down and 1 INT, poor 1st half.

that said, he kept his bcb cool and we won handily. 2nd half was much better. had a 114.6 PR. never got flustered. it's good to see the rook win against a tough team.

Originally posted by dj43:
Those were the result of an All-Pro DT doing what he has been doing all season long. Batted passes are on the OL for not forcing the DL to keep their hands down to protect themselves. It isn't always easy but it is what needs to happen if the QB is to have consistent passing lanes.