Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 745 users in the forums

Brandon Aiyuk is a Quitter! Pick #25, 2020 NFL Draft

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by 9ers4eva:
Hes in breach of contract. Why wouldn't they be able to go for his guaranteed money?

They can. It's just not the full amount. It's the allocations of signing bonus* in the year's he's in breach, but not beyond those years. He's been in breach for a part of 2025 and a part of 2026 (so far).

This is clearly defined in the CBA, and what JD said is clearly excluded in plain writing.

Ask this question another way, why would they be able to clawback the portions of his bonus from 2024 that were clearly earned, when he wasn't in breach?
[ Edited by SmokeyJoe on Aug 31, 2026 at 10:13 AM ]
he should do like larry david and just show up to work and act like nothing happened just claim he was joking around walk right into the position meeting room
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
he should do like larry david and just show up to work and act like nothing happened just claim he was joking around walk right into the position meeting room

It'd be nice, but we're not that lucky sadly. The Rams got Aaron Donald after 2 years away from the game, it'd be awesome to counter that with an even more impactful move of our own.
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
They can. It's just not the full amount. It's the allocations of signing bonus* in the year's he's in breach, but not beyond those years. He's been in breach for a part of 2025 and a part of 2026 (so far).

This is clearly defined in the CBA, and what JD said is clearly excluded in plain writing.

Ask this question another way, why would they be able to clawback the portions of his bonus from 2024 that were clearly earned, when he wasn't in breach?

Makes sense not to get the 24 money. All the rest if he's in breach however.
If he doesn't show up tomorrow he's totally screwed right?
Originally posted by 9ers4eva:
Makes sense not to get the 24 money. All the rest if he's in breach however.

https://overthecap.com/collective-bargaining-agreement/article/4/section/9

The most important/relevant sections:

Forfeitable Breach. Any player who (i) willfully fails to report, practice or play with the result that the player's ability to fully participate and contribute to the team is substantially undermined (for example, without limitation, holding out or leaving the squad absent a showing of extreme personal hardship); or (ii) is unavailable to the team due to conduct by him that results in his incarceration; or (iii) is unavailable to the team due to a nonfootball injury that resulted from a material breach of Paragraph 3 of his NFL Player Contract; or (iv) voluntarily retires (collectively, any "Forfeitable Breach") may be required to forfeit signing bonus, roster bonus, option bonus and/or reporting bonus, and no other Salary, for each League Year in which a Forfeitable Breach occurs (collectively, "Forfeitable Salary Allocations"), as set forth below:

Forfeitable Salary Allocations. For the purposes of this Section, the term "Forfeitable Salary Allocations" means: (i) for signing bonus, the Salary Cap allocation for the player's signing bonus for that League Year; and (ii) for roster, option and reporting bonuses that are earned in the same League Year as the Forfeitable Breach, the allocation of such bonus for that League Year, out of the total amount of such bonus as allocated over that League Year and any remaining League Years in the player's contract, notwithstanding the Salary Cap treatment of such bonuses. For example, without limitation, if a player has a $1 million roster bonus that is earned in the same year the player committed a Forfeitable Breach, then, regardless of when that roster bonus is to be paid, that bonus is attributable to the same year as the Forfeitable Breach; if the player has that year and one additional year remaining on his contract, then $500,000 of the roster bonus will be allocated to each of those years for purposes of any potential forfeiture calculation. If the Forfeitable Breach occurs in the second League Year in this example (i.e., the League Year after the roster bonus in this example is earned), there shall be no forfeiture of any portion of such roster bonus.

Maximum Forfeitable Salary. Under this Section, and without limitation, under no circumstances may a player be required to forfeit more than 100% of his Forfeitable Salary Allocations for each League Year in which he commits a Forfeitable Breach. With respect to roster bonus, option bonus and reporting bonus, a forfeiture may only occur if the Forfeitable Breach occurs in the same League Year in which the bonus is scheduled to be earned.
So as long as he doesn't report they'll be able to get back 18.4 mil eventually
Originally posted by 9ers4eva:
So as long as he doesn't report they'll be able to get back 18.4 mil eventually

The number is off but you get the concept. If he never reports for the remainder of his deal, or if he officially retires, they'll be able to get back the bulk of his signing bonus. As of now, they are in line to clawback a small percentage of it.

Also, they had an insurance policy that paid them x amount of dollars. That's going to be viewed as a refund from the player so whatever that dollar amount was ($5m or less I believe), Aiyuk will keep it.
Originally posted by 9ers4eva:
So as long as he doesn't report they'll be able to get back 18.4 mil eventually

Unpopular opinion but we got to just get this guy gone at this point. Are we stuck until he sends his intent letter? Is that the hold-up. Going after past monies is just more memes and never ending press by this clown how the 9ers are raping him. The 9ers made a mistake. F the money and get the hell out of here and close the story.
Originally posted by 9erson3:
Unpopular opinion but we got to just get this guy gone at this point. Are we stuck until he sends his intent letter? Is that the hold-up. Going after past monies is just more memes and never ending press by this clown how the 9ers are raping him. The 9ers made a mistake. F the money and get the hell out of here and close the story.

No, they can flat out release him. The owners care about the actual cash.

This point seems to be a disconnect with the fans. Fans care about salary cap space. Owners care about dollars.

Maybe they'll eventually just say f**k it and cut him, but I don't see why they would. He was a story during the offseason, but is it realistically going to become a distraction when football is being played? Possible I guess, but it's pretty quiet now.
[ Edited by SmokeyJoe on Aug 31, 2026 at 11:12 AM ]
  • dj43
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 38,318
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Originally posted by 9erson3:
Unpopular opinion but we got to just get this guy gone at this point. Are we stuck until he sends his intent letter? Is that the hold-up. Going after past monies is just more memes and never ending press by this clown how the 9ers are raping him. The 9ers made a mistake. F the money and get the hell out of here and close the story.

No, they can flat out release him. The owners care about the actual cash.

This point seems to be a disconnect with the fans. Fans care about salary cap space. Owners care about dollars.

Maybe they'll eventually just say f**k it and cut him, but I don't see why they would. He was a story during the offseason, but is it realistically going to become a distraction when football is being played? Possible I guess, but it's pretty quiet now.

Good point.

I don't see him being a distraction at all. The pace of the season and the strength of the schedule we will be facing is going to keep everybody focused. BA is a just a page in an old newspaper that nobody even reads anymore. It's sad to see what he has done to himself.
I saw Demarcus Robinson is taking #11

Gets really awkward is Aiyuk shows up at the facility now lol
  • dj43
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 38,318
Originally posted by bigmur49:
I saw Demarcus Robinson is taking #11

Gets really awkward is Aiyuk shows up at the facility now lol

Originally posted by bigmur49:
I saw Demarcus Robinson is taking #11

Gets really awkward is Aiyuk shows up at the facility now lol
I forgot what stipulations were against him by not showing up before the first. I thought I saw something that he can't comeback until next year or something?
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone