Originally posted by the_dynasty:
Originally posted by LifelongNiner:Dak Prescott had an exceptional regular season which earned him his all pro honors and is a top 5-10 qb in the league
I didn't say they aren't to be trusted. I said if you WANT to use the 2nd team All-Pro nod, do you also believe Dak Prescott is the 2nd best QB in the league? Since you went there...where do you stand on All Pro QB Dak Prescott?
I'm saying Aiyuk isn't a top 5 guy yet. He might be soon, but he isn't there yet. Not after one great year.
All pro honors are for regular season.
I do agree with your second statement, so maybe we do agree. If so then I apologize :)
I get the meaning of the All Pro distinction. In the same way that Dak is just top 5-10, Aiyuk is top 10 in spite of his All Pro Distinction. I'm not sure what his contract demands are, but my original point is that there isn't anything he's done justifying he should get a top 5 receiver contract. Thinking he is or paying him that way is speculation.
Personally, I think he can be that guy, but we can't handle put contracts based on how we feel about a player. We are definitely in agreement.
