Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 444 users in the forums

Harbaugh's 2011 49ers VERSUS Shanahan's 2019 49ers(hypothetical)Who would win?

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by hondakillerzx:
damn the disrespect for Harbaugh is unreal a lol. Dude was a great coach and got wins out of the same team that was a perennial loser before her arrived. That said Shanny is an offensive genius and our defensive front is monstrous this year. LB edge goes to 2011, offensive line mightve been better than this years and they had Gore and VD. Crabs is better than anything we have now at WR but Jimmy smokes both Kap and Alex. this 2019 team will probably be better when all is said and done. i think the only major win for 2011 is Willis and Bowman. they also had cowboy and aldon wreaking havoc on every play but this four man front is more dangerous and lets our DBs do their job

Even though I think the 2019 team matches up well, I agree the disrespect is ridiculous. Kyle has more speed on the outside and a better QB to help his run game. As much of a machine as VD was, Kittle just has more game and is a much more natural and fluid player.

People always wanna say Harbaugh wasn't good enough, but it was really some fluke plays and calls that kept us from a title (and unfortunate timing of Smith injuries in 2012). We saw what Harbs could do with a real offense in 2012. That was our only good offense Crab (preachilles), Delanie, VD, Gore. Alex held them back, but we got a glimpse when Kap came in.

I think Kap gets disrespected badly too. The 10 games he had a real offense, he was unreal. Then we came out with Marlon Moore and the boys in 2013, and everything progressively went downhill from a roster and organizational standpoint. He went through some down years as the org duked it out with his coach, and hired Tomsula, but Kap proved he still had game in 2016. We give Jimmy a lot of excuses, but Kap played under remarkably worse circumstances and avgd 250 total ypg and a 16/4 ratio in 11 starts.
The above videos are auto-populated by an affiliate.
Originally posted by kdoggie:
Harbaugh and Roman gave the ball to LaMichael James at the 5 and then fades into the end zone in the Super Bowl. F that.

I'll take Shanahan and his creativity at the 5 all damn day.

They gave the ball to Lamike, then tried a couple quick hitters to get them close so they could pound it in. Both quick hitters fell incomplete. THEN the fade came.

Once the Lamike run got stuffed and the first quick hitter fell incomplete, we should have dialed up passes into the end zone. One read plays like Vernon post or something. It's definitely disappointing that they had a perfect play drawn up for the Saints but nothing for a SB matchup.
The worst of the quick hitter plays was when they reused a play from the November 2011 giants game.

Crabtree lined up in the backfield and releasing out to the pylon.... it was so telegraphed that I'll never forget shouting at my tv saying "don't reuse that play"
I just wish Delanie pulled to lead block for Frank into the end zone. F-ing hell I hate re-hashing so many what if scenarios.
Originally posted by hondakillerzx:
damn the disrespect for Harbaugh is unreal lol. Dude was a great coach and got wins out of the same team that was a perennial loser before her arrived. That said Shanny is an offensive genius and our defensive front is monstrous this year. LB edge goes to 2011, offensive line mightve been better than this years and they had Gore and VD. Crabs is better than anything we have now at WR but Jimmy smokes both Kap and Alex. this 2019 team will probably be better when all is said and done. i think the only major win for 2011 is Willis and Bowman. they also had cowboy and aldon wreaking havoc on every play but this four man front is more dangerous and lets our DBs do their job

agree
2019
Jimmy G over kap n Alex no contest.
Dline over justin n aldon.
Stable of RBs that produce with speed, pass catching, decent at pass blocking
WRs have potential but might go with crabtree for now
Kittle over davis
Warner and kwon are faster than bow n willis not as hard hitting
Sherman over Carlos Rogers multiple pick season and the other 2011 DBs.
Faster safeties but not as big hitters as goldson n whitner
Despite Gould's last game I'll take him over ackers

2011
Gore all down back but slower than 2019 RBs.
Might slightly be better at run defense with Sopoaga and McDonalds fatazzes clogging the running lanes.
For now Tony Montana squad with ginn over richie n company, but still a lot of games for Richie to take one to the house multiple times this season.
  • cciowa
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 60,541
Originally posted by hondakillerzx:
damn the disrespect for Harbaugh is unreal lol. Dude was a great coach and got wins out of the same team that was a perennial loser before her arrived. That said Shanny is an offensive genius and our defensive front is monstrous this year. LB edge goes to 2011, offensive line mightve been better than this years and they had Gore and VD. Crabs is better than anything we have now at WR but Jimmy smokes both Kap and Alex. this 2019 team will probably be better when all is said and done. i think the only major win for 2011 is Willis and Bowman. they also had cowboy and aldon wreaking havoc on every play but this four man front is more dangerous and lets our DBs do their job

spot on.. unreal. the juvenile name calling and dis respect to the guy who brought us back to being relevant . great post
  • cciowa
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 60,541
Originally posted by kdoggie:
Harbaugh and Roman gave the ball to LaMichael James at the 5 and then fades into the end zone in the Super Bowl. F that.

I'll take Shanahan and his creativity at the 5 all damn day.

no no no..... here is what happened. after gore ripped off the run to the 7.. gore was out which is fine for one series.. so on first and goal from the 7, they gave it to little james and even james got two yards vs a defense that was set up to stop the run.,. that should have been a clear message,..... on second and goal from the 5 behind the best run blocking line in the nfl..... and a fully rested gore with dixon and ck.... you run the f**king ball
Originally posted by Aj_hwd954:
Handshake controversy? Another thing to add to the list of 2011 similarities

I was just thinking of that!!!
Originally posted by FL9er:
This thread is about as silly as Skip Bayless debating himself:


debating himself? now that is funny
Originally posted by cciowa:
no no no..... here is what happened. after gore ripped off the run to the 7.. gore was out which is fine for one series.. so on first and goal from the 7, they gave it to little james and even james got two yards vs a defense that was set up to stop the run.,. that should have been a clear message,..... on second and goal from the 5 behind the best run blocking line in the nfl..... and a fully rested gore with dixon and ck.... you run the f**king ball

I was kind of getting around to that. If LaMike can rip off 2 yards, then Gore would have found a way to get in the end zone.
Originally posted by Team49ers:
2019
Jimmy G over kap n Alex no contest.
Dline over justin n aldon.
Stable of RBs that produce with speed, pass catching, decent at pass blocking
WRs have potential but might go with crabtree for now
Kittle over davis
Warner and kwon are faster than bow n willis not as hard hitting
Sherman over Carlos Rogers multiple pick season and the other 2011 DBs.
Faster safeties but not as big hitters as goldson n whitner
Despite Gould's last game I'll take him over ackers

2011
Gore all down back but slower than 2019 RBs.
Might slightly be better at run defense with Sopoaga and McDonalds fatazzes clogging the running lanes.
For now Tony Montana squad with ginn over richie n company, but still a lot of games for Richie to take one to the house multiple times this season.

Shanny's Play-calling and scheme > Harbaugh's any day. no disrespect to harbaugh at the same time.
[ Edited by SkyZer0 on Oct 9, 2019 at 10:53 AM ]
  • dj43
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 37,944
Originally posted by SkyZer0:
Play-calling and scheme > Shanny any day. no disrespect to harbaugh either.

Just a fact.
Originally posted by dj43:
Originally posted by SkyZer0:
Play-calling and scheme > Shanny any day. no disrespect to harbaugh either.

Just a fact.

oops lol
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone