49ers vs. Vikings Tickets Available! →

There are 802 users in the forums

Countdown

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by SamMills51:
Our owner is stupid. He fired our best GM ever in Gettleman and rehired the guy originally fired for messing up the team cap, which the guy recently fired was hired for fixing his mess in the first place, which eventually got him fired.

So yeah. Besides the idiotic idea of keeping two bad kickers, we have an incompetent owner and now incompetent interim GM.

Correct me if I'm wrong here but didn't your interim GM play a big part in the drafting and putting together the core of your current roster?

Almost half your Super Bowl starters came from his time as GM - Cam Newton, Luke Kuechly, Thomas Davis, Greg Olsen, Josh Norman, Ryan Kalil, Jonathan Stewart, Charles Johnson, Graham Gano, Brad Nortman, and JJ Jansen. I haven't looked at the rest of that roster but there might have been others that came from Hurney's time as GM.

It is true he put you guys in a terrible cap situation. Didn't he give Deangelo Williams and Jonathan Stewart pay days? But put aside some of those questionable cap moves that he made to retain your best players, he did do a good job in building a strong foundation on which Gettleman built on.

The other thing to bear in mind with Gettleman is that he apparently alienated some of the players. He arguably played a role in Jordan Gross' 'early' retirement. He showed one of the iconic Carolina Panthers - Steve Smith - the door and little respect on the way out because he essentially said Steve Smith was 'past it', yet the guy went on to have a strong finish to his career in Baltimore. He threw his toys out of the pram with Josh Norman and rescinded the franchise tag (I'm struggling to think of another example when that's happened?). He cut Deangelo Williams, granted he was an ageing back and they saved money, but he was still a very popular veteran. And it is a possibility that Greg Olsen and Thomas Davis could have both been heading out of the door had Gettleman stayed on because of the way he was handling their extension requests. Now I appreciate that the NFL is a business and teams move on from popular veteran players every single season. However, it seems to me that Gettleman had a tendency to not always show key veterans the respect they deserved and eventually that can lose a person their job. There is no disputing the guy drafted well for the most part, but I think in his case he probably rubbed one too many veteran players up the wrong way and your owner made the call to fire him rather than lose the heart of your football team (i.e. Thomas Davis) and another key leader (i.e. Greg Olsen).

Perhaps I'm wrong in this assessment. I am after all looking at things from the outside.
Originally posted by Mike1989:
Correct me if I'm wrong here but didn't your interim GM play a big part in the drafting and putting together the core of your current roster?

Almost half your Super Bowl starters came from his time as GM - Cam Newton, Luke Kuechly, Thomas Davis, Greg Olsen, Josh Norman, Ryan Kalil, Jonathan Stewart, Charles Johnson, Graham Gano, Brad Nortman, and JJ Jansen. I haven't looked at the rest of that roster but there might have been others that came from Hurney's time as GM.

It is true he put you guys in a terrible cap situation. Didn't he give Deangelo Williams and Jonathan Stewart pay days? But put aside some of those questionable cap moves that he made to retain your best players, he did do a good job in building a strong foundation on which Gettleman built on.

The other thing to bear in mind with Gettleman is that he apparently alienated some of the players. He arguably played a role in Jordan Gross' 'early' retirement. He showed one of the iconic Carolina Panthers - Steve Smith - the door and little respect on the way out because he essentially said Steve Smith was 'past it', yet the guy went on to have a strong finish to his career in Baltimore. He threw his toys out of the pram with Josh Norman and rescinded the franchise tag (I'm struggling to think of another example when that's happened?). He cut Deangelo Williams, granted he was an ageing back and they saved money, but he was still a very popular veteran. And it is a possibility that Greg Olsen and Thomas Davis could have both been heading out of the door had Gettleman stayed on because of the way he was handling their extension requests. Now I appreciate that the NFL is a business and teams move on from popular veteran players every single season. However, it seems to me that Gettleman had a tendency to not always show key veterans the respect they deserved and eventually that can lose a person their job. There is no disputing the guy drafted well for the most part, but I think in his case he probably rubbed one too many veteran players up the wrong way and your owner made the call to fire him rather than lose the heart of your football team (i.e. Thomas Davis) and another key leader (i.e. Greg Olsen).

Perhaps I'm wrong in this assessment. I am after all looking at things from the outside.

Yes, Hurney was good at drafting first rounders. However, he's had a terrible history of big busts, overvaluing 1st rounders, and doing terrible the rest of the draft. The only bright spot from 2011 was getting Cam. Everyone else was a bust.

He got lucky on the Olsen trade. It was a no-brainer move. Hurney didn't have much to do with it more-so than the Bears being stupid.

Gettleman had absolutely no cap, yet built up a majority of solid players that were in Superbowl 50. Short, Star, Superbowl-level Ealy, Turner, Norwell, Oher, Thompson, Coleman, Ginn, and a whole lot of other contributors.

Getting rid of Smitty was weird at the time. Even Gettleman admits he could've handled it differently. But nevertheless, it's been said our 2013 locker room atmosphere was plagued by Smith complaining about not getting the ball enough, and some even say he often broke out into fights and punched Cam a few times. Thus led to his departure.

DeAngelo Williams was not a popular guy either. Nobody liked him much at all. He didn't even seem to be exerting any effort at all. It was a no-brainer cut.

The Norman fiasco was also another mistake. But even so, the 2016 team had worse issues than being without Norman.

And well, it's weird. Olsen and TD both got minimal and very little extra money. That pretty much throws the idea Gettleman was playing hardball out the door and more-so Richardson just not liking him. In fact, Hurney just cut Webb - a huge locker room guy - which was a move not very popular in the eyes of Panthers players.

He's brought us into one of our worst cap situations as well.
Originally posted by SamMills51:
Yes, Hurney was good at drafting first rounders. However, he's had a terrible history of big busts, overvaluing 1st rounders, and doing terrible the rest of the draft. The only bright spot from 2011 was getting Cam. Everyone else was a bust.

He got lucky on the Olsen trade. It was a no-brainer move. Hurney didn't have much to do with it more-so than the Bears being stupid.

Gettleman had absolutely no cap, yet built up a majority of solid players that were in Superbowl 50. Short, Star, Superbowl-level Ealy, Turner, Norwell, Oher, Thompson, Coleman, Ginn, and a whole lot of other contributors.

Getting rid of Smitty was weird at the time. Even Gettleman admits he could've handled it differently. But nevertheless, it's been said our 2013 locker room atmosphere was plagued by Smith complaining about not getting the ball enough, and some even say he often broke out into fights and punched Cam a few times. Thus led to his departure.

DeAngelo Williams was not a popular guy either. Nobody liked him much at all. He didn't even seem to be exerting any effort at all. It was a no-brainer cut.

The Norman fiasco was also another mistake. But even so, the 2016 team had worse issues than being without Norman.

And well, it's weird. Olsen and TD both got minimal and very little extra money. That pretty much throws the idea Gettleman was playing hardball out the door and more-so Richardson just not liking him. In fact, Hurney just cut Webb - a huge locker room guy - which was a move not very popular in the eyes of Panthers players.

He's brought us into one of our worst cap situations as well.

As you've said in your post - Gettleman has said himself that he would have handled certain events differently, and that is what ultimately cost him his job.

The Panthers were not a bad team when he took over. They were a team that needed to learn how to win and get over the line, and under Gettleman's GM stint they had their most successful run in making the play offs and winning consecutive division titles. However, he still made mistakes when dealing with popular veteran players. Screw them around and you can alienate them and that's dangerous because they can have a lot of sway within certain teams. Had you guys been heading into rebuild and he pushed veterans out of the door, fair enough, in that scenario things are handled differently because the team will move forwards with younger players. But when a team is trying to win now and the GM makes some questionable moves or makes mistakes when dealing with popular veterans, then it's only a matter of time before an owner has to make a decision: stick with the GM and lose the popular veterans, or stay loyal to players that have been loyal to the team and done a lot for the team and fire the GM.

For me, it was a questionable move to fire Gettleman based on his track record with the Panthers. However, it was not a major surprise to hear that he was apparently fired because of some of those contractual decisions he decided to make.
  • mayo49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 65,216
2 days
Originally posted by mayo49:
2 days

2 more shifts for me lol.

God i cant wait. No matter what the outcome is.
Originally posted by SamMills51:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
More important should I drop Jstew from my fantasy squad 🤔 Is he gonna have a role worth keeping him...I'd be dropping him to handcuff Hyde with breida

He's getting a lot of redzone touches. However, Panthers are some of the worst when it comes to fantasy runningbacks since we spread the ball around to so many different runners. Cam, Stew, CMC, and maybe CAP will all compete for touches.

However, he'll be someone we're using a lot for the redzone. Could be useful for that.

Thanks man he'll stay in the roster for now
I hope our O-Lineman can do a good Job containing Lotulelei ,Short, Davis Kuechly and Davis ....they are the core of that defense , and of we can run the ball and have success with play action passes and a some deep shots downfield , I think we have a chance to win this f*cker , our defense is much improved , things are different , we dont have Purcell, Bethea, Jerod Eddie and Wilhoite getting the lions share of snaps and gassed by the 2nd half due to chip kelly and his 3 and out machine , we'll have a stronger and fresher defense to go with a creative offense that has some speed , YES, things will be different
  • thl408
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 33,490
  • mayo49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 65,216
Originally posted by thl408:

Oh, poor Cam.
  • Cjez
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 170,906
cam is fkn huge in real life. as we were leaving the stadium, we got stopped near the tunnel to let the players go through. that motherf**ker looks like a beast compared to all the rest of the team. I remember steve smith talking s**t to 9er fans as he was leaving.
  • mayo49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 65,216
Originally posted by ChazBoner:
cam is fkn huge in real life. as we were leaving the stadium, we got stopped near the tunnel to let the players go through. that motherf**ker looks like a beast compared to all the rest of the team. I remember steve smith talking s**t to 9er fans as he was leaving.

Yeah, he's a big dude.
Originally posted by mayo49:
Originally posted by ChazBoner:
cam is fkn huge in real life. as we were leaving the stadium, we got stopped near the tunnel to let the players go through. that motherf**ker looks like a beast compared to all the rest of the team. I remember steve smith talking s**t to 9er fans as he was leaving.

Yeah, he's a big baby.

FTFY
Panthers -4.5 at one point it was up to -6
Originally posted by hummbabybear:
Panthers -4.5 at one point it was up to -6
thats due to bets being placed on the Panthers
[ Edited by 49AllTheTime on Sep 8, 2017 at 10:03 AM ]
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by hummbabybear:
Panthers -4.5 at one point it was up to -6
thats due to bets being placed on the Panthers

Cam is listed as questionable
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone