There are 122 users in the forums

Injuries - 9-Year Analysis

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by DRCHOWDER:
Originally posted by Shorteous:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by Shorteous:
Can we have a separate injury tracker for the year?

Whatcha mean?

One where the OP updates the injury status of players this year.

Who's on IR
how many weeks left some player has before returning from injury etc etc

that would be great if someone did that and kept it updated every week.

Does anyone want to keep a health tracker thread? Usually the sources comes from all over the place (articles, X, pods, etc.) so it's a lot to stay on top of and track but that would certainly be a valuable tracker.

Then we can keep this as the annual analysis and general discussion thread.
We already used 5 of our 8 I.R. designations? Or just 1 (Luter) since he's designated to return and the other don't count since they are done for the year?
Originally posted by NCommand:
We already used 5 of our 8 I.R. designations? Or just 1 (Luter) since he's designated to return and the other don't count since they are done for the year?

Luter is PUP. Any PUP can return, but the decision has to be made in the window at the end of the PUP time period.

All the IRs so far are pre-53 cut down, so all are out for the year and not available to return. They have an infinite amount of IR designations that can't return during the season.

There are still up to 8 eventual IR designations that can return within the same year. Danny Grey and Robert Beal are likely to be designated as IR tomorrow and would be eligible for return.
[ Edited by captveg on Aug 29, 2023 at 3:51 PM ]
Originally posted by captveg:
Originally posted by NCommand:
We already used 5 of our 8 I.R. designations? Or just 1 (Luter) since he's designated to return and the other don't count since they are done for the year?

Luter is PUP. Any PUP can return, but the decision has to be made in the window at the end of the PUP time period.

All the IRs so far are pre-53 cut down, so all are out for the year and not available to return. They have an infinite amount of IR designations that can't return during the season.

There are still up to 8 eventual IR designations that can return within the same year. Danny Grey and Robert Beal are likely to be designated as IR tomorrow and would be eligible for return.

Gotcha, so they'll have used 3 of the 8 already. Thanks!
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by captveg:
Originally posted by NCommand:
We already used 5 of our 8 I.R. designations? Or just 1 (Luter) since he's designated to return and the other don't count since they are done for the year?

Luter is PUP. Any PUP can return, but the decision has to be made in the window at the end of the PUP time period.

All the IRs so far are pre-53 cut down, so all are out for the year and not available to return. They have an infinite amount of IR designations that can't return during the season.

There are still up to 8 eventual IR designations that can return within the same year. Danny Grey and Robert Beal are likely to be designated as IR tomorrow and would be eligible for return.

Gotcha, so they'll have used 3 of the 8 already. Thanks!

No. None of the IR guys today are eligible to return this year. They've used 0 of 8 IR returns. Those don't get counted until they reactivate a guy, but so far no guys have been IRd that are eligible to be one of those 8.
Just change the thread title to Injuries-Lifetime-Analysis.
Originally posted by Shorteous:
Can we have a separate injury tracker for the year?

That would be awesome. Just track injuries... Leave the fluff out and the narrative out, and allow others to opinionate as they wish instead of trying to drive home a point and masking it as "analyses."

Do bumps count as injuries? I'll count shameless bumps by the author aw injuries are also tallied. As of the last 4 days i count 2.

Other injury threads routinely get locked for this one,... which doesnt really track injuries. IOW.... This thread is here merely for attention.

Hopefully a brave soul is out there and willing to start a true injury thread where actual injuries are tracked and updated, without fear of it being locked?

Would help us keep up with...what is posted as the topic: injuries.
[ Edited by random49er on Aug 30, 2023 at 5:15 AM ]
Originally posted by DRCHOWDER:
Just change the thread title to Injuries-Lifetime-Analysis.

Haha. Facts!
Originally posted by captveg:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by captveg:
Originally posted by NCommand:
We already used 5 of our 8 I.R. designations? Or just 1 (Luter) since he's designated to return and the other don't count since they are done for the year?

Luter is PUP. Any PUP can return, but the decision has to be made in the window at the end of the PUP time period.

All the IRs so far are pre-53 cut down, so all are out for the year and not available to return. They have an infinite amount of IR designations that can't return during the season.

There are still up to 8 eventual IR designations that can return within the same year. Danny Grey and Robert Beal are likely to be designated as IR tomorrow and would be eligible for return.

Gotcha, so they'll have used 3 of the 8 already. Thanks!

No. None of the IR guys today are eligible to return this year. They've used 0 of 8 IR returns. Those don't get counted until they reactivate a guy, but so far no guys have been IRd that are eligible to be one of those 8.

Oh. I always get these confused. So not Luter. And the ones that will be added today will count though, right?
[ Edited by NCommand on Aug 30, 2023 at 5:02 AM ]
  • Giedi
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 32,509
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by DRCHOWDER:
Just change the thread title to Injuries-Lifetime-Analysis.

Haha. Facts!

Investigative Journalism at it's finest.

Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by DRCHOWDER:
Originally posted by Shorteous:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by Shorteous:
Can we have a separate injury tracker for the year?

Whatcha mean?

One where the OP updates the injury status of players this year.

Who's on IR
how many weeks left some player has before returning from injury etc etc

that would be great if someone did that and kept it updated every week.

Does anyone want to keep a health tracker thread? Usually the sources comes from all over the place (articles, X, pods, etc.) so it's a lot to stay on top of and track but that would certainly be a valuable tracker.

Then we can keep this as the annual analysis and general discussion thread.

I think someone made a thread and said they will keep it updated.
Originally posted by DRCHOWDER:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by DRCHOWDER:
Originally posted by Shorteous:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by Shorteous:
Can we have a separate injury tracker for the year?

Whatcha mean?

One where the OP updates the injury status of players this year.

Who's on IR
how many weeks left some player has before returning from injury etc etc

that would be great if someone did that and kept it updated every week.

Does anyone want to keep a health tracker thread? Usually the sources comes from all over the place (articles, X, pods, etc.) so it's a lot to stay on top of and track but that would certainly be a valuable tracker.

Then we can keep this as the annual analysis and general discussion thread.

I think someone made a thread and said they will keep it updated.

SHORTEOUS is the man!
Share 49ersWebzone