49ers Head Coach Kyle Shanahan Thread

Kyle has fallen short at times but he's also been an excellent coach. I love having Kyle but that doesn't mean I love everything he does.

winning a Super Bowl is really really hard and unfortunately when we've got there - we went up against one of the greatest QB/HC/TE combos (with also a HOF DC). We had a ton of chances to win both of those games and blew it, is what it is.

if we can stay healthy - we will be right in the mix to win it all again. Let's hope we get a couple more pieces and stay healthy. Should be a great season if that's the case

Originally posted by jcs:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by Paul_Hofer:
The comparison to Walsh is unfortunate. Shanahan is more comparable to Mariucci. Like Shanahan, Mariucci was good at getting the team into the playoffs but didn't show the top end to close the deal. Getting into the playoffs is great considering the alternative most teams face each year.

Ahmm…no

Mooch took over a HoF QB with elite skill players, great OL and never made it to the NFCCG.

It's another laughable analogy people make in here to diminish what Shanahan has done as a HC. Not all HCs who haven't won the SB are equal.

Shanahan has 9 playoff wins as a HC. He would have several SBs with Steve Young and Jerry Rice and TO.

Or if we look at his coaching career as a whole he could easily be the guy that chokes away SBs with Steve, Jerry and TO.

Not even close, you're really reaching and showing ineptitude towards the game

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by jcs:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by Paul_Hofer:
The comparison to Walsh is unfortunate. Shanahan is more comparable to Mariucci. Like Shanahan, Mariucci was good at getting the team into the playoffs but didn't show the top end to close the deal. Getting into the playoffs is great considering the alternative most teams face each year.

Ahmm…no

Mooch took over a HoF QB with elite skill players, great OL and never made it to the NFCCG.

It's another laughable analogy people make in here to diminish what Shanahan has done as a HC. Not all HCs who haven't won the SB are equal.

Shanahan has 9 playoff wins as a HC. He would have several SBs with Steve Young and Jerry Rice and TO.

Or if we look at his coaching career as a whole he could easily be the guy that chokes away SBs with Steve, Jerry and TO.

Not even close, you're really reaching and showing ineptitude towards the game

And yet he's choked away 2 SB's here already.

Originally posted by jcs:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by jcs:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by Paul_Hofer:
The comparison to Walsh is unfortunate. Shanahan is more comparable to Mariucci. Like Shanahan, Mariucci was good at getting the team into the playoffs but didn't show the top end to close the deal. Getting into the playoffs is great considering the alternative most teams face each year.

Ahmm…no

Mooch took over a HoF QB with elite skill players, great OL and never made it to the NFCCG.

It's another laughable analogy people make in here to diminish what Shanahan has done as a HC. Not all HCs who haven't won the SB are equal.

Shanahan has 9 playoff wins as a HC. He would have several SBs with Steve Young and Jerry Rice and TO.

Or if we look at his coaching career as a whole he could easily be the guy that chokes away SBs with Steve, Jerry and TO.

Not even close, you're really reaching and showing ineptitude towards the game

And yet he's choked away 2 SB's here already.

That is incorrect

Originally posted by jcs:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by Paul_Hofer:
The comparison to Walsh is unfortunate. Shanahan is more comparable to Mariucci. Like Shanahan, Mariucci was good at getting the team into the playoffs but didn't show the top end to close the deal. Getting into the playoffs is great considering the alternative most teams face each year.

Ahmm…no

Mooch took over a HoF QB with elite skill players, great OL and never made it to the NFCCG.

It's another laughable analogy people make in here to diminish what Shanahan has done as a HC. Not all HCs who haven't won the SB are equal.

Shanahan has 9 playoff wins as a HC. He would have several SBs with Steve Young and Jerry Rice and TO.

Or if we look at his coaching career as a whole he could easily be the guy that chokes away SBs with Steve, Jerry and TO.

We're not doing this man. We've covered those games for months. He's not losing either game with Steve and those WRs. I know you don't even believe that garbage.

Originally posted by jcs:
And yet he's choked away 2 SB's here already.

Choking in a SB is when you lose to your brother as a 5.5 point favorite. Not losing to an all time QB and coach.

Originally posted by tankle104:
Kyle has fallen short at times but he's also been an excellent coach. I love having Kyle but that doesn't mean I love everything he does.

winning a Super Bowl is really really hard and unfortunately when we've got there - we went up against one of the greatest QB/HC/TE combos (with also a HOF DC). We had a ton of chances to win both of those games and blew it, is what it is.

if we can stay healthy - we will be right in the mix to win it all again. Let's hope we get a couple more pieces and stay healthy. Should be a great season if that's the case

This.

How many more years do people here think he's gonna get in SF without winning a Super Bowl? 5? 7?

Originally posted by maximusdecimus:
How many more years do people here think he's gonna get in SF without winning a Super Bowl? 5? 7?

As many as he wants.

Already making excuses. Lol

He and JL do not drat RB's, OLine well at all.

They need help.

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by maximusdecimus:
How many more years do people here think he's gonna get in SF without winning a Super Bowl? 5? 7?

As many as he wants.

I think your right!
😂😂

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by maximusdecimus:
How many more years do people here think he's gonna get in SF without winning a Super Bowl? 5? 7?

As many as he wants.

A better answer is "As long as he's getting positive results from his players and the locker room has his back." He'll be in trouble if either of these things become problems in a significant way. Otherwise you keep him.

Originally posted by maximusdecimus:

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by maximusdecimus:
How many more years do people here think he's gonna get in SF without winning a Super Bowl? 5? 7?

As many as he wants.

I think your right!
😂😂

The Kyle support has become cult like. I suspect he could lose a couple more SBs and he'd still be celebrated for getting us to those Superbowls to begin with…

Originally posted by DrEll:

Originally posted by maximusdecimus:

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

Originally posted by maximusdecimus:
How many more years do people here think he's gonna get in SF without winning a Super Bowl? 5? 7?

As many as he wants.

I think your right!
😂😂

The Kyle support has become cult like. I suspect he could lose a couple more SBs and he'd still be celebrated for getting us to those Superbowls to begin with…

Cult like?

The guy is the best XO coach out there.