49ers Head Coach Kyle Shanahan Thread

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:
Wonderful logic.

Is Shanahan just a better coach because he is the current HC of the 49ers and that's it? No other reasons?

Built the 9ers up from nothing. Didn't inherit multiple Pro Bowl talents. Has gotten farther in his playoff seasons than Jim has. Has a much higher performing offense by any metric despite coaching turnover. Much better offensive assistants by a country mile.

Hasn't had one of the worst offensive performances by a qb in the playoffs ever with an elite qb talent.

If you wanna see how Jim does with no talent look at 2007 Stanford.

Why is Harbaugh better? Can't be because of record because if you don't win the sb there's no difference between 1-31.

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:
It what way am I advocating for Harbaugh? What the F is wrong with you guys??

You literally said this

"Hell if we need a fresh start I'd take Jim Harbaugh in a heartbeat"

Originally posted by NYniner85:
Harbs shouldn't even be on your list if you want Kyle fired…that the point. Your debate is unserious when you can't apply the same s**t to everyone.

Exactly

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:
Wonderful logic.

Is Shanahan just a better coach because he is the current HC of the 49ers and that's it? No other reasons?

Harbs shouldn't even be on your list if you want Kyle fired…that the point. Your debate is unserious when you can't apply the same s**t to everyone.

I didn't say I want Kyle fired.

I just asked how KS is a better coach if the end game is Super Bowls and it seems the consensus answer is "because he coaches for the 49ers"

Alright then.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:
It what way am I advocating for Harbaugh? What the F is wrong with you guys??

You literally said this

"Hell if we need a fresh start I'd take Jim Harbaugh in a heartbeat"

Ah for sh8ts sakes. I meant John Harbaugh. Ravens. My bad. Apologies.

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:
I didn't say I want Kyle fired.

I just asked how KS is a better coach if the end game is Super Bowls and it seems the consensus answer is "because he coaches for the 49ers"

Alright then.

But if Kyle gets fired and the goal is SB or bust why take Harbaugh in a heartbeat? Itd be the SAME problem right?

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:
I didn't say I want Kyle fired.

I just asked how KS is a better coach if the end game is Super Bowls and it seems the consensus answer is "because he coaches for the 49ers"

Alright then.

But if Kyle gets fired and the goal is SB or bust why take Harbaugh in a heartbeat? Itd be the SAME problem right?

Yes, you're right. I had the wrong Harbaugh brother. I could see how that could cause confusion. My bad 😞

Originally posted by TD49ers:
You just dont get it.

How we missed your superior intelligence around here. Guess I'll just move ahead in my ignorance.

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:
Ah for sh8ts sakes. I meant John Harbaugh. Ravens. My bad. Apologies.

John hasn't don't s**t either for 14 yrs. That's with a great roster and a multiple time MVP QB.

I think him and Jim are good HCs all the same. I don't think they're some massive gap between any 3 of them imo it's pointless to move off Kyle for John.

If we can guarantee John plays Jim in the SB id take him.

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by TD49ers:
You just dont get it.

How we missed your superior intelligence around here. Guess I'll just move ahead in my ignorance.

It's not him that says "you don't know football"

It's everyone else when you criticize someone on this team.

It's like having a discussion with a liberal that ends with "you're a racist or homophobe"

When a person can't debate any longer they pull out the Trump card of "You don't know football". End of discussion.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:
Ah for sh8ts sakes. I meant John Harbaugh. Ravens. My bad. Apologies.

John hasn't don't s**t either for 14 yrs. That's with a great roster and a multiple time MVP QB.

I think him and Jim are good HCs all the same. I don't think they're some massive gap between any 3 of them imo it's pointless to move off Kyle for John.

That's my point. What separates Shanahan from those coaches on the list? He's JAG until he wins IMO.

But, like Andy Reid, sometimes a guy needs a fresh start elsewhere to get the ring.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:
"Literally every year"?

Except for 4 out of the 9 years that we have had a losing season. But those don't count.

Ah yeah years where we were forced to play the likes of CJ beathard, Hoyer, and Mullens. Like I said ZERO nuance and confirmation bias.

I mean the great Andy Reid really crushed it with his backups at QB this yr! Mcvay 5-12 when Stafford had a hurt season BUT they're great!

It's funny I think mentally I just forgot about KC cuz we were having our own issues but I think it's kind of hilarious that Andy with a top 10 defense and Mahomes playing in 14 games managed to win just 6 games.

Meanwhile every time Kyle had a top 10 defense and had his starting QB for 10+ games he had the team in the NFCCG.

Guess Andy Reid sucks now? Oh wait...he won those SBs so he's basically brilliant beyond measure at all times now. Except of course when coaching against Kyle, cuz in those games it's just Kyle being a terrible HC.

It all makes sense now.

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:
If we can guarantee John plays Jim in the SB id take him.

Hahaha

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:
That's my point. What separates Shanahan from those coaches on the list? He's JAG until he wins IMO.

But, like Andy Reid, sometimes a guy needs a fresh start elsewhere to get the ring.

Or luck into a Hof QB!

And before you respond with he traded up/drafted that QB, lol. No one had that expectation of mahomes, not even reid