49ers Head Coach Kyle Shanahan Thread

Originally posted by Pillbusta:

Originally posted by krizay:
This is a good post. My personal concerns about Kyle was how his offenses look when we can't run the ball. Generally up until this year the games we couldn't run the ball our offense looked like a steaming pile of poo.

This year gave me confidence that his offense can succeed when the running game isn't working.

It's the QB was holding him back previously. No more

That happened even with Purdy up until this year.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:
"Literally every year"?

Except for 4 out of the 9 years that we have had a losing season. But those don't count.

Ah yeah years where we were forced to play the likes of CJ beathard, Hoyer, and Mullens. Like I said ZERO nuance and confirmation bias.

I mean the great Andy Reid really crushed it with his backups at QB this yr! Mcvay 5-12 when Stafford had a hurt season BUT they're great!

And who had final say on the roster? Who drafted Beathard and signed Hoyer?

Originally posted by NYniner85:
What was the point of the list then? I could sit there and poke holes with all those HCs…no different then what you and others do with Kyle,

Not to mention he clearly prefers Harbaugh even tho hes hasnt been any more successful in playoffs (less so actually) or in SBs.

Once again holding Kyle to a higher standard than all the rest.

Originally posted by niner4life21:
See your post below. What was the purpose of your question in bold? You gonna do mental gymnastics now and say you weren't suggesting these guys are better than Shanahan?

Top 5 play caller yes. Top 5 HC? That's debatable. Is he any better of a head coach than these guys?

Andy Reid
Sean McVay
Nick Siriani
Sean Payton
Mike Vrabel
Mike McDonald
Demeco Ryans
Jim Harbaugh
Dan Campbell
Mike Tomlin
Ben Johnson
Liam Cohen
Dave Canales

Hell if we need a fresh start I'd take Jim Harbaugh in a heartbeat.

Thank you! s**t post then playing victim lol. Dude can't even use his SAME criteria he wants for Kyle on most of these HCs.

Originally posted by niner4life21:

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:

Originally posted by NYniner85:
You post a list of coaches you think are better with both of them on that list. Don't apply the same context to them that you have for Kyle. You've posted about Andy in here many times and how great of a play caller he is….buy you know can't play call his way to more than 12 pts without his golden boy?

you tell everyone how you feel with each post in here about Kyle.

Did I say that list of coaches were better than Shanahan? Or are you making things up?

See your post below. What was the purpose of your question in bold? You gonna do mental gymnastics now and say you weren't suggesting these guys are better than Shanahan?

Top 5 play caller yes. Top 5 HC? That's debatable. Is he any better of a head coach than these guys?

Andy Reid
Sean McVay
Nick Siriani
Sean Payton
Mike Vrabel
Mike McDonald
Demeco Ryans
Jim Harbaugh
Dan Campbell
Mike Tomlin
Ben Johnson
Liam Cohen
Dave Canales

Hell if we need a fresh start I'd take Jim Harbaugh in a heartbeat.

It meant is he better than any of the guys on the list?? It's not hard to comprehend the question.

You can either be objective or a homer when you answer the question but I already know which you will choose.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by niner4life21:
See your post below. What was the purpose of your question in bold? You gonna do mental gymnastics now and say you weren't suggesting these guys are better than Shanahan?

Top 5 play caller yes. Top 5 HC? That's debatable. Is he any better of a head coach than these guys?

Andy Reid
Sean McVay
Nick Siriani
Sean Payton
Mike Vrabel
Mike McDonald
Demeco Ryans
Jim Harbaugh
Dan Campbell
Mike Tomlin
Ben Johnson
Liam Cohen
Dave Canales

Hell if we need a fresh start I'd take Jim Harbaugh in a heartbeat.

Thank you! s**t post then playing victim lol. Dude can't even use his SAME criteria he wants for Kyle on most of these HCs.

Just going in circles with him at this point lol. Couldn't pay me to watch a 49er game with that dude.

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by NYniner85:
What was the point of the list then? I could sit there and poke holes with all those HCs…no different then what you and others do with Kyle,

Not to mention he clearly prefers Harbaugh even tho hes hasnt been any more successful in playoffs (less so actually) or in SBs.

Once again holding Kyle to a higher standard than all the rest.

I prefer Harbaugh? Wow, you guys are amazing at knowing what I want.

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:
It meant is he better than any of the guys on the list?? It's not hard to comprehend the question.

You can either be objective or a homer when you answer the question but I already know which you will choose.

Objective! You?! Ha.

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:
Dang. Talk about trolls all you guys want but the Niner squad cheerleaders are out in full force.

Lol. You're surprised that WE SUPPORT our team.

You know nothing about ball and you know nothing about being a supporter.

If everyone was like you there would be no atmosphere at any Niners game. There would just be a faint grumbling..

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:
I prefer Harbaugh? Wow, you guys are amazing at knowing what I want.

So you don't want a fresh start? Why bring it up then?

If you don't like Kyle because he can't win the big one why "start fresh" with someone else who cant?

Originally posted by niner4life21:

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:

Originally posted by niner4life21:
Cool. And the fact is that you don't know football.

Ah ok. Gotcha.

Maybe you can start a course on football 101 because you know so much?? Or do you want a medal so you can wear it to school and show your friends how much you know about football?

You want a medal for playing baseball as a kid? Mr. Alpha? Who keeps making stuff up. Doesn't have an ounce of football nuance on a football fan forum. Just throwing your usual tantrums. Grown ass man you say you are.

Yet you piss your pants and have a hissy fit and try to end a debate by saying you know more about football. And who is having a tantrum?

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:
And who had final say on the roster? Who drafted Beathard and signed Hoyer?

Who signed John Wolford when McVay won 5 games when Stafford got hurt? Who signed minshew when Mahomes got hurt and they put up 12 pts a game?

Mike Tomlin couldn't develop a QB if his life depended on it.

Originally posted by KSRULES:
Lol. You're surprised that WE SUPPORT our team.

You know nothing about ball and you know nothing about being a supporter.

If everyone was like you there would be no atmosphere at any Niners game. There would just be a faint grumbling..

Out come the pitchforks lol.

Our team? So you support the 49ers more than me because you don't criticize anyone? Is that how a fan is supposed to be?

I just blocked dude It became apparent that he wasn't actually down for any discussion.

Sask: says something outrageous, often contradicting something he said a few pages earlier.

Us: Present him with evidence to the contrary.

Sask: Ahh, you're just a cheerleader! You love losers!

Rinse, repeat.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:
And who had final say on the roster? Who drafted Beathard and signed Hoyer?

Who signed John Wolford when McVay won 5 games when Stafford got hurt? Who signed minshew when Mahomes got hurt and they put up 12 pts a game?

Mike Tomlin couldn't develop a QB if his life depended on it.

Why do you always deflect? You're like a greasy politician when asked a question. "Ya but what about all these other guys"

Who gives a sh!t about them? I asked you a question about Shananan.

-Kyle Shanahan has 4 losing seasons out of 9
-"Ya but he inherited a losing team that had Beathard and Hoyer"
-Who signed Hoyer and drafted Beathard!
-Well McVay did this and Tomlin did that.

It's always the same. You can't answer the damn question if your life depended on it because it would mean criticizing Shanahan. And then CLEARLY you wouldn't be a true 49ers fan.