Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 495 users in the forums

49ers Head Coach Kyle Shanahan Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online

49ers Head Coach Kyle Shanahan Thread

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:
I guarantee Marino would trade all his stats and TD passes for one ring.

Which means absolutely nothing in regards to if he's a BETTER player than Dilfer, BUT according to you and others Trent is BETTER because he won a SB and Dan didn't. That's the debate not if so and so would trade anything
The above videos are auto-populated by an affiliate.
Originally posted by Sask49erFan:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
How so? Andy is suppose to be the most elite play caller ever….thats I'll I've heard in here was how great he's was at it…oh no he lost the GOAT QB and has one of the worst offenses in the league and can't win a single game??

Last I saw our backup QB went 5-2 and with more injuries than that KC roster.

Oh you're right. Shanahan is better than Reid.

LMAO, the hot takes from you just get better and better

Never said he was or wasn't….you'd think the best play caller in 20 yrs would have gotten more than 12pts a game and not go 0-4.

everyone knew the moment Mahomes went down their season was f**king done….Andy didn't coach his ass off at all. Where was the creative director play calling? Next man up?

Kyle had a backup QB for almost half the season and a mountain of high end injuries and yet he got 12 wins and we're in the playoffs….and here you are (and others) whining about our HC….now THAT'S a stupid emotional hot take if I've ever seen one!
I remember at this time last year Kevin OcConnell was better than Kyle. So was Dan Quinn.
[ Edited by 9ers4eva on Jan 6, 2026 at 2:15 PM ]
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Never said he was or wasn't….you'd think the best play caller in 20 yrs would have gotten more than 12pts a game and not go 0-4.

everyone knew the moment Mahomes went down their season was f**king done….Andy didn't coach his ass off at all. Where was the creative director play calling? Next man up?

Kyle had a backup QB for almost half the season and a mountain of high end injuries and yet he got 12 wins and we're in the playoffs….and here you are (and others) whining about our HC….now THAT'S a stupid emotional hot take if I've ever seen one!

You're acting as if Mac Jones is some scrub. Put Mac Jones with Andy instead of that no-named practice squad QB and let's talk.
Ravens just fired John Harbaugh.

"But he WON SUPER BOWL unlike Kyle POOPahan " - the usual suspects
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Which means absolutely nothing in regards to if he's a BETTER player than Dilfer, BUT according to you and others Trent is BETTER because he won a SB and Dan didn't. That's the debate not if so and so would trade anything

What do you judge talent on? Stats or championships?

Do you think anyone would claim Brady is the GOAT if he didn't win a pile of Championships? Would Montana be among the best if he didn't win??
Originally posted by Sask49erFan:
You're acting as if Mac Jones is some scrub. Put Mac Jones with Andy instead of that no-named practice squad QB and let's talk.

Andy didn't have the opportunity to sign him instead of Minshew?
Originally posted by 9ers4eva:
I remember at this time last year Kevin OcConnell was better than Kyle. So was Dan Quinn.

lol yup oops
Originally posted by Fanaticofnfl:
Ravens just fired John Harbaugh.

"But he WON SUPER BOWL unlike Kyle POOPahan " - the usual suspects

No coach can win forever. If you won 10 years ago and have done jack all for 10 years than see ya later.

Even Belichick got fired.

But even though they got fired they are still better coaches than Shanahan because they won. If Shanahan doesn't win soon he will be next. Because everyone in the world (except guys in here) know that nothing else matters other than winning the SB.
[ Edited by Sask49erFan on Jan 6, 2026 at 2:21 PM ]
Originally posted by Sask49erFan:
What do you judge talent on? Stats or championships?

Do you think anyone would claim Brady is the GOAT if he didn't win a pile of Championships? Would Montana be among the best if he didn't win??

Then you think Foles, Dilfer, Johnson are better than Marino and Kelly. Simple as that.

just admit it because that's the narrative you're pushing.
Originally posted by Fanaticofnfl:
Ravens just fired John Harbaugh.

"But he WON SUPER BOWL unlike Kyle POOPahan " - the usual suspects

If John doesn't get another HC job, I wonder if he joins up with Jim....
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Then you think Foles, Dilfer, Johnson are better than Marino and Kelly. Simple as that.

just admit it because that's the narrative you're pushing.

Sure. I will admit that. I will take a winner all day long over those guys.

And then you can admit that you will take a stats queen over a guy who wins Championships.
[ Edited by Sask49erFan on Jan 6, 2026 at 2:22 PM ]
Originally posted by Sask49erFan:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Then you think Foles, Dilfer, Johnson are better than Marino and Kelly. Simple as that.

just admit it because that's the narrative you're pushing.

Sure. I will admit that. I will take a winner all day long over those guys.

And then you can admit that you will take a stats queen over a guy who wins Championships.

This guy don't know ball.
Originally posted by Sask49erFan:
Originally posted by Fanaticofnfl:
Ravens just fired John Harbaugh.

"But he WON SUPER BOWL unlike Kyle POOPahan " - the usual suspects

No coach can win forever. If you won 10 years ago and have done jack all for 10 years than see ya later.

Even Belichick got fired.

But even though they got fired they are still better coaches than Shanahan because they won. If Shanahan doesn't win soon he will be next. Because everyone in the world (except guys in here) know that nothing else matters other than winning the SB.

Dilfer is better than Marino got it. Doug Peterson is better than Levy. Derp
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Dilfer is better than Marino got it. Doug Peterson is better than Levy. Derp

How on earth can you say a guy who has never won is better than a guy who isn't?? Seriously dude??
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone