-
SmokeyJoe
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 13,068
Originally posted by captveg:
Fans don't make the decision in either scenario. But many fans felt Harbaugh had grown stale. There's a ton of familiar thinking in this thread.
Same thing with Mariucci in 2003.
The grass isn't always greener.
York isn't gonna make a change anyway, so it's all moot.
Lol… it was a wildly unpopular move. Couldn't have been more obvious. The vast majority of the fanbase was supportive of Harbaugh and the backlash showed that clearly.
It would be unpopular to fire Kyle too. In that sense, it's a similar situation where we have a very small minority of idiotic fans who have no idea what they are looking at. But the key difference is the organization is unified behind closed doors. Kyle isn't going anywhere soon, unless he chooses to.
The above videos are auto-populated by an affiliate.
-
GoreGoreGore
- 10HourChicken
-
- Posts: 61,009
Originally posted by DrEll:
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by DrEll:
Exactly.
Saleh - head coach
McDaniels - OC
Ulbrich or Demeco - DC
trade Kyle to some schmo franchise trying to sell tickets. He's never going to win a SB anyways might as well let him dazzle the fan with cute out routes to FBs.
guaranteed the above combo gets this team a title within 3 years.
Just hilarious stuff right here…
Get rid of Shanahan and bring in an OC running a TOTALLY different scheme. Brilliant.
Ulbrich has a job btw and DeMeco isn't going anywhere.
Must be nice to just throw out crap out there with nothing behind it.
How is Mike McDaniela running a totally different scheme ? He suffers from the same flaws as Kyle. Brilliant offensive mind, horrible head coach. The difference is McDaniels will come back as OC and brilliantly scheme plays up on the couch while Kyle is full of himself and will just ruin some other franchise's dream of winning a SB.
Your takes are so bad lmao. Completely clueless.
[ Edited by GoreGoreGore on Oct 26, 2025 at 6:43 PM ]
-
genus49
- Moderator
-
- Posts: 27,556
Originally posted by DrEll:
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by DrEll:
Exactly.
Saleh - head coach
McDaniels - OC
Ulbrich or Demeco - DC
trade Kyle to some schmo franchise trying to sell tickets. He's never going to win a SB anyways might as well let him dazzle the fan with cute out routes to FBs.
guaranteed the above combo gets this team a title within 3 years.
Just hilarious stuff right here…
Get rid of Shanahan and bring in an OC running a TOTALLY different scheme. Brilliant.
Ulbrich has a job btw and DeMeco isn't going anywhere.
Must be nice to just throw out crap out there with nothing behind it.
How is Mike McDaniela running a totally different scheme ? He suffers from the same flaws as Kyle. Brilliant offensive mind, horrible head coach. The difference is McDaniels will come back as OC and brilliantly scheme plays up on the couch while Kyle is full of himself and will just ruin some other franchise's dream of winning a SB.
Well considering it's Mike McDaniel and not McDaniels, I took you at your word and assumed you were calling for Josh McDaniels.
If you cared enough to look around the league you'd understand how important it is these days to have an offensive minded HC who can protect the team from having his coordinators poached.
You want Saleh as HC when he's clearly a much better DC than HC. You're all over the place…
-
Hoovtrain
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 34,416
Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:
Originally posted by DrEll:
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by DrEll:
Exactly.
Saleh - head coach
McDaniels - OC
Ulbrich or Demeco - DC
trade Kyle to some schmo franchise trying to sell tickets. He's never going to win a SB anyways might as well let him dazzle the fan with cute out routes to FBs.
guaranteed the above combo gets this team a title within 3 years.
Just hilarious stuff right here…
Get rid of Shanahan and bring in an OC running a TOTALLY different scheme. Brilliant.
Ulbrich has a job btw and DeMeco isn't going anywhere.
Must be nice to just throw out crap out there with nothing behind it.
How is Mike McDaniela running a totally different scheme ? He suffers from the same flaws as Kyle. Brilliant offensive mind, horrible head coach. The difference is McDaniels will come back as OC and brilliantly scheme plays up on the couch while Kyle is full of himself and will just ruin some other franchise's dream of winning a SB.
Your takes are so bad lmao. Completely clueless.
It's like him, Koldo, Cortez and ninerfan4life are having a competition over who can one up each other.
-
Montana
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 18,919
Kyle and Selah looked lost and glazed over but who I guess who wouldn't after all the cluster cluck that has happened? I wish we could have had a better showing though, they owned us. I kinda feel like they just deflated early on, like the oxygen being cut off the balls. Like in those last moments of those Superbowls lol
-
susweel
- Hall of Nepal
-
- Posts: 121,965
This dude needs to be investigated for all those injuries. That's not normal
-
socalfan21
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 21,040
Shanahan won't ever be held accountable for anything. He's going to coach here for 20 years with 10 nfc championship appearances and zero super bowls and zero care for the offensive line. He's on track for something special.
-
NoFunLeague
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 445
Without Kyle we could very well be winless so stop the absurdity. Be thankful we have a top coach who is rebuilding the team and remaining competitive despite the injury hell and salary cap casualties. Step back and think before ranting stupidity.
-
pdc20
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 2,225
Originally posted by BP13:
It's pretty clear by that the Kyle Derangement Syndrome posters are entrenched in their hatred for him. It's like a broken record. Same posts over and over no matter what, nothing will change that.
The reality is that if the Niners win the Superbowl this year, they will say it's because of Robert Saleh not Kyle Shanahan.
They just want to be right and can't accept the fact that Shanahan is a top 5 HC. It's sad to be a fan and hope your team loses because you want to say "I told you so.".
The Niners are 5-3 with all these injuries with only 3 home games.
The Niners were also 5-3 the last time they went to the Superbowl by the way.
-
DRCHOWDER
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 20,459
Originally posted by Hoovtrain:
Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:
Originally posted by DrEll:
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by DrEll:
Exactly.
Saleh - head coach
McDaniels - OC
Ulbrich or Demeco - DC
trade Kyle to some schmo franchise trying to sell tickets. He's never going to win a SB anyways might as well let him dazzle the fan with cute out routes to FBs.
guaranteed the above combo gets this team a title within 3 years.
Just hilarious stuff right here…
Get rid of Shanahan and bring in an OC running a TOTALLY different scheme. Brilliant.
Ulbrich has a job btw and DeMeco isn't going anywhere.
Must be nice to just throw out crap out there with nothing behind it.
How is Mike McDaniela running a totally different scheme ? He suffers from the same flaws as Kyle. Brilliant offensive mind, horrible head coach. The difference is McDaniels will come back as OC and brilliantly scheme plays up on the couch while Kyle is full of himself and will just ruin some other franchise's dream of winning a SB.
Your takes are so bad lmao. Completely clueless.
It's like him, Koldo, Cortez and ninerfan4life are having a competition over who can one up each other.
I don't understand why you guys hate those guys or any of those type of post.... comic relief is great lolol...
-
49ers81
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 2,755
Originally posted by Montana:
Kyle and Saleh looked lost and glazed over but who I guess who wouldn't after all the cluster cluck that has happened? I wish we could have had a better showing though, they owned us. I kinda feel like they just deflated early on, like the oxygen being cut off the balls. Like in those last moments of those Super Bowls lol
Well, I think this is the first game of the year where all the injuries finally caught up to them. You just can't lose as many important starters as this team has and expect to be competitive every week. If Warner, Bosa, Huff and Pearsall had been healthy, I suspect this is a different outcome. I didn't include Brock only because Jones has been playing pretty well, but you have to think his greater mobility might have brought them a first down or two.
-
Pillbusta
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 25,432
Why would I want Kyle gone when we're 5-3 fielding practice squad players. We just have to get guys back and play through this season
-
jreff22
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 67,278
Bring is some kind of consultants, ex coaches, etc to look at what we are doing to figure out the injuries. This is not normal by any stretch, something has to be to blame.
-
DrEll
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 11,083
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by DrEll:
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by DrEll:
Exactly.
Saleh - head coach
McDaniels - OC
Ulbrich or Demeco - DC
trade Kyle to some schmo franchise trying to sell tickets. He's never going to win a SB anyways might as well let him dazzle the fan with cute out routes to FBs.
guaranteed the above combo gets this team a title within 3 years.
Just hilarious stuff right here…
Get rid of Shanahan and bring in an OC running a TOTALLY different scheme. Brilliant.
Ulbrich has a job btw and DeMeco isn't going anywhere.
Must be nice to just throw out crap out there with nothing behind it.
How is Mike McDaniela running a totally different scheme ? He suffers from the same flaws as Kyle. Brilliant offensive mind, horrible head coach. The difference is McDaniels will come back as OC and brilliantly scheme plays up on the couch while Kyle is full of himself and will just ruin some other franchise's dream of winning a SB.
Well considering it's Mike McDaniel and not McDaniels, I took you at your word and assumed you were calling for Josh McDaniels.
If you cared enough to look around the league you'd understand how important it is these days to have an offensive minded HC who can protect the team from having his coordinators poached.
You want Saleh as HC when he's clearly a much better DC than HC. You're all over the place…
Saleh only coached for 2 seasons.
Kyle has been doing it for 10.
interesting that you can conclude that Saleh is a much better DC than HC based on a small sample size, yet Kyle has the same amount of SBs in a much larger time span but you have a completely take on that.
biased much ?
-
DrEll
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 11,083
Originally posted by pdc20:
Originally posted by BP13:
It's pretty clear by that the Kyle Derangement Syndrome posters are entrenched in their hatred for him. It's like a broken record. Same posts over and over no matter what, nothing will change that.
The reality is that if the Niners win the Superbowl this year, they will say it's because of Robert Saleh not Kyle Shanahan.
They just want to be right and can't accept the fact that Shanahan is a top 5 HC. It's sad to be a fan and hope your team loses because you want to say "I told you so.".
The Niners are 5-3 with all these injuries with only 3 home games.
The Niners were also 5-3 the last time they went to the Superbowl by the way.
Lol. If he had even one SB in the pocket, I don't think anyone would have any argument about firing him. The entire premise to get rid of of him lies on the fact that he hasn't won one in a decade he's been here, and he's had multiple opportunities with loaded rosters and not so many loaded rosters. There's always an excuse though. QB, oline, DC, opposing QB, opposing coach, bad refs, etc but the Kyle fans never point to the common denominator in all of those game —- the head coach.