49ers Head Coach Kyle Shanahan Thread

Originally posted by YACBros85:
With the addition of CMC (the security blanket) and all of our weapons healthy, I expect Jimmy to end the season with his best statistical season of his career. Anything less will be a huge disappointment imo.

Totally agree. I feel like most QBs in the NFL put on this roster (with this coaching staff) would see similar results.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by YACBros85:
With the addition of CMC (the security blanket) and all of our weapons healthy, I expect Jimmy to end the season with his best statistical season of his career. Anything less will be a huge disappointment imo.

Totally agree. I feel like most QBs in the NFL put on this roster (with this coaching staff) would see similar results.

Anything less than a SB win will be a disappointment. They need to break the cycle of getting to the top but not being able to crest it. No more late game collapses. Stil keeping my fingers crossed that JG will stay healthy.

Originally posted by NYniner85:
Seems to be working for Tua lol. Who overall isn't some stud QB. So many under throws from him, a ton of easy reads and guys open….similar to Jimmy.

Jimmy is a game manager and not some elite passer who can extend and create. He's got to play within structure of the scheme and if any of that breaks down, more often than not SF is screwed on that play. Is what it is. Nothing changed with JG. It's a rollercoaster ride good and bad.

Not saying he is a stud. My point is nothing changes with this offense because I don't believe Jimmy would consistently take the shots. It's not a weapon personnel issue.

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by NYniner85:
Seems to be working for Tua lol. Who overall isn't some stud QB. So many under throws from him, a ton of easy reads and guys open….similar to Jimmy.

Jimmy is a game manager and not some elite passer who can extend and create. He's got to play within structure of the scheme and if any of that breaks down, more often than not SF is screwed on that play. Is what it is. Nothing changed with JG. It's a rollercoaster ride good and bad.

Not saying he is a stud. My point is nothing changes with this offense because I don't believe Jimmy would consistently take the shots. It's not a weapon personnel issue.

His passer rating and completion % would drop if he started taking more chances with longer throws.

KS has brought TL and JG together. They can both bond over losing a year of development while KS stood on the sidelines and watched.

Kyle and all 49er fans hearing about the JV news

Originally posted by DRCHOWDER:


Kyle and all 49er fans hearing about the JV news

KS - how dare you get yourself hurt.. that's my freakin job

Originally posted by NYniner85:
Seems to be working for Tua lol. Who overall isn't some stud QB. So many under throws from him, a ton of easy reads and guys open….similar to Jimmy.

Jimmy is a game manager and not some elite passer who can extend and create. He's got to play within structure of the scheme and if any of that breaks down, more often than not SF is screwed on that play. Is what it is. Nothing changed with JG. It's a rollercoaster ride good and bad.

NY, we see this a lot…ie that Jimmy has to play within structure and scheme, and if he gets out of that mold, then the 9ers are screwed. But go back to his first season here, he shows up mid season, and then runs off 5 straight Ws, not knowing the playbook all that well and definitely NOT playing within Kyle's "structured" game plan. JG basically just winged it that first half season. Not saying he played "firehouse football" which is totally unstructured, but he did play a game that wasn't anywhere near as structured as kyle ended up having him play.

Then, once he seemed to be playing within Kyle's structure following year, he seemed to play less well than he had his first season when "unstructured" . His quality of play after yr 1 here, fell off…or at least it seemed that way to me. I liked his style of play better his first yr, when he wasn't following kyle's script. It seemed as if when playing Kyle's scheme, he was more robotic, and a lesser Qb.

So the question: was JG a better Qb playing less structured, or is the consensus that JG has to play "structured" football for us to win? Think back to those first 5 games.

Originally posted by pasodoc9er:

Originally posted by NYniner85:
Seems to be working for Tua lol. Who overall isn't some stud QB. So many under throws from him, a ton of easy reads and guys open….similar to Jimmy.

Jimmy is a game manager and not some elite passer who can extend and create. He's got to play within structure of the scheme and if any of that breaks down, more often than not SF is screwed on that play. Is what it is. Nothing changed with JG. It's a rollercoaster ride good and bad.

NY, we see this a lot…ie that Jimmy has to play within structure and scheme, and if he gets out of that mold, then the 9ers are screwed. But go back to his first season here, he shows up mid season, and then runs off 5 straight Ws, not knowing the playbook all that well and definitely NOT playing within Kyle's "structured" game plan. JG basically just winged it that first half season. Not saying he played "firehouse football" which is totally unstructured, but he did play a game that wasn't anywhere near as structured as kyle ended up having him play.

Then, once he seemed to be playing within Kyle's structure following year, he seemed to play less well than he had his first season when "unstructured" . His quality of play after yr 1 here, fell off…or at least it seemed that way to me. I liked his style of play better his first yr, when he wasn't following kyle's script. It seemed as if when playing Kyle's scheme, he was more robotic, and a lesser Qb.

So the question: was JG a better Qb playing less structured, or is the consensus that JG has to play "structured" football for us to win? Think back to those first 5 games.

The structure will always be the same, it's the QB who was different than to now

If jimmy is doing what Kyle wants then there isn't a need to change QBs

Bye weeks are definitely as boring as Kyle Shanahan's playcalling.

mevermind

Originally posted by Koldo:
Bye weeks are definitely as boring as Kyle Shanahan's playcalling.

Bye weeks are definitely as boring as Jimmy Garoppolo's screen pass and slant only skillset.

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by Koldo:
Bye weeks are definitely as boring as Kyle Shanahan's playcalling.

Bye weeks are definitely as boring as Jimmy Garoppolo's screen pass and slant only skillset.

No Jimmy stan here.

Originally posted by DRCHOWDER:


Kyle and all 49er fans hearing about the JV news

I was more like

Originally posted by Koldo:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by Koldo:
Bye weeks are definitely as boring as Kyle Shanahan's playcalling.

Bye weeks are definitely as boring as Jimmy Garoppolo's screen pass and slant only skillset.

No Jimmy stan here.

On a serious note. This offense should be more exciting the second half of this season. We now have a first team all pro at every skill position except QB and they are all YAC monsters.