49ers Head Coach Kyle Shanahan Thread

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by thl408:

Originally posted by Jcool:

I was all set to debunk the Shanahan script narrative, but then a funny thing happened: I couldn't.

It turns out, yes, there is something to it (and I'm as surprised as anyone). https://t.co/x3P8AjE2o4

— Josh Hermsmeyer (@friscojosh) October 27, 2022

He should script the first 70 plays. Problem solved.

Haha. I heard a commentator also note he scripts the first 12 plays coming out of the half. We used to be really good last year but not this year. Last year, we were awesome in the 4 minute drills and those aren't scripted at all. But not this year.

Sooooo

Crock and Panelli said he's a really good play designer but not an in-game play caller.

That has Greg Roman feel to it to me.

you and other say that.. but then there's vid showing open guys missed after the scripted plays

what more can Kyle do.. scheme everyone open at the same time ?

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by thl408:

Originally posted by Jcool:

I was all set to debunk the Shanahan script narrative, but then a funny thing happened: I couldn't.

It turns out, yes, there is something to it (and I'm as surprised as anyone). https://t.co/x3P8AjE2o4

— Josh Hermsmeyer (@friscojosh) October 27, 2022

He should script the first 70 plays. Problem solved.

Haha. I heard a commentator also note he scripts the first 12 plays coming out of the half. We used to be really good last year but not this year. Last year, we were awesome in the 4 minute drills and those aren't scripted at all. But not this year.

Sooooo

Crock and Panelli said he's a really good play designer but not an in-game play caller.

That has Greg Roman feel to it to me.

you and other say that.. but then there's vid showing open guys missed after the scripted plays

what more can Kyle do.. scheme everyone open at the same time ?

We have no idea the progression, the timing, the oline breakdown etc. Video doesn't mean much (stills are even worse) without input from either the coachbor player as to what was going on in that particular play.

Originally posted by JoseCortez:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by thl408:

Originally posted by Jcool:

I was all set to debunk the Shanahan script narrative, but then a funny thing happened: I couldn't.

It turns out, yes, there is something to it (and I'm as surprised as anyone). https://t.co/x3P8AjE2o4

— Josh Hermsmeyer (@friscojosh) October 27, 2022

He should script the first 70 plays. Problem solved.

Haha. I heard a commentator also note he scripts the first 12 plays coming out of the half. We used to be really good last year but not this year. Last year, we were awesome in the 4 minute drills and those aren't scripted at all. But not this year.

Sooooo

Crock and Panelli said he's a really good play designer but not an in-game play caller.

That has Greg Roman feel to it to me.

you and other say that.. but then there's vid showing open guys missed after the scripted plays

what more can Kyle do.. scheme everyone open at the same time ?

We have no idea the progression, the timing, the oline breakdown etc. Video doesn't mean much (stills are even worse) without input from either the coachbor player as to what was going on in that particular play.

yet speculating what you say is happening without showing why, holds more water ?

If he don't get to the NFC championship game this year with a weak NFC and stacked roster this year will be a huge disappointment. So far this season his coaching has been very supbar.

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by JoseCortez:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by thl408:

Originally posted by Jcool:

I was all set to debunk the Shanahan script narrative, but then a funny thing happened: I couldn't.

It turns out, yes, there is something to it (and I'm as surprised as anyone). https://t.co/x3P8AjE2o4

— Josh Hermsmeyer (@friscojosh) October 27, 2022

He should script the first 70 plays. Problem solved.

Haha. I heard a commentator also note he scripts the first 12 plays coming out of the half. We used to be really good last year but not this year. Last year, we were awesome in the 4 minute drills and those aren't scripted at all. But not this year.

Sooooo

Crock and Panelli said he's a really good play designer but not an in-game play caller.

That has Greg Roman feel to it to me.

you and other say that.. but then there's vid showing open guys missed after the scripted plays

what more can Kyle do.. scheme everyone open at the same time ?

We have no idea the progression, the timing, the oline breakdown etc. Video doesn't mean much (stills are even worse) without input from either the coachbor player as to what was going on in that particular play.

yet speculating what you say is happening without showing why, holds more water ?

Dude, you seriously need to read/listen more. Your stubborn hatred is literally blinding you. Hell, start with this very article.

Originally posted by susweel:
If he don't get to the NFC championship game this year with a weak NFC and stacked roster this year will be a huge disappointment. So far this season his coaching has been very supbar.

No lies detected.

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by JoseCortez:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by thl408:

Originally posted by Jcool:

I was all set to debunk the Shanahan script narrative, but then a funny thing happened: I couldn't.

It turns out, yes, there is something to it (and I'm as surprised as anyone). https://t.co/x3P8AjE2o4

— Josh Hermsmeyer (@friscojosh) October 27, 2022

He should script the first 70 plays. Problem solved.

Haha. I heard a commentator also note he scripts the first 12 plays coming out of the half. We used to be really good last year but not this year. Last year, we were awesome in the 4 minute drills and those aren't scripted at all. But not this year.

Sooooo

Crock and Panelli said he's a really good play designer but not an in-game play caller.

That has Greg Roman feel to it to me.

you and other say that.. but then there's vid showing open guys missed after the scripted plays

what more can Kyle do.. scheme everyone open at the same time ?

We have no idea the progression, the timing, the oline breakdown etc. Video doesn't mean much (stills are even worse) without input from either the coachbor player as to what was going on in that particular play.

yet speculating what you say is happening without showing why, holds more water ?

Dude, you seriously need to read/listen more. Your stubborn hatred is literally blinding you. Hell, start with this very article.

lol, it's all speculation and someone's opinion. that does not make it fact

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by ninerfan818:
Idunno. Shammy can't seem to coach at all in the second half of games. It seems he has a script for the first half and if that goes down the tubes the adjustments seem lacking to me. And penalties, the 49ers have many offensive penalties each game. Almost one illegal motion per.games it seems. Not very disciplined or the scheme is too complex.

If this defense wasn't playing lights out in the first six games we may not even be 3-4. The defense looks a lot better than the offense does and Shammy, not DeMeco was the one thought of as a genius. I'm on the fence. Not a complete hater but not impressed either.

And thats different from Harbaugh how? Do you not remember the constant delay of games and illegal motions? Being top 10 in penalties 3 out of 4 years. Top 12 all 4 years.

If the 2011 9ers D doesn't play lights out the 9ers aren't even a playoff team in 2011. All time team record for field goals.

I guess you're right. We did have lots of penalties. Delay of game, etc. harbs had issues getting the plays relayed in time, at times. I am just sorely disappointed in how this current team comes out impotent in the 2nd half and especially the 4th quarter of games.

It's uninspiring and I don't think Shammy has the team prepared consistently. I think there needs to be more accountability from him and the star players. But it has to start from the top. The leader needs to be a better leader.

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by JoseCortez:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by thl408:

Originally posted by Jcool:

I was all set to debunk the Shanahan script narrative, but then a funny thing happened: I couldn't.

It turns out, yes, there is something to it (and I'm as surprised as anyone). https://t.co/x3P8AjE2o4

— Josh Hermsmeyer (@friscojosh) October 27, 2022

He should script the first 70 plays. Problem solved.

Haha. I heard a commentator also note he scripts the first 12 plays coming out of the half. We used to be really good last year but not this year. Last year, we were awesome in the 4 minute drills and those aren't scripted at all. But not this year.

Sooooo

Crock and Panelli said he's a really good play designer but not an in-game play caller.

That has Greg Roman feel to it to me.

you and other say that.. but then there's vid showing open guys missed after the scripted plays

what more can Kyle do.. scheme everyone open at the same time ?

We have no idea the progression, the timing, the oline breakdown etc. Video doesn't mean much (stills are even worse) without input from either the coachbor player as to what was going on in that particular play.

yet speculating what you say is happening without showing why, holds more water ?

Dude, you seriously need to read/listen more. Your stubborn hatred is literally blinding you. Hell, start with this very article.

lol, it's all speculation and someone's opinion. that does not make it fact

Then if you agree with the article, Kyle runs this b***h. He's the QB. His QB nor his receivers/running backs have any issues executing his own scripted plays to start each game and through the first quarter.

But clearly, not afterwards.

What does that say to you about Jimmy, the receivers and the running game?

PS: You obviously didn't read the article because there was no speculation in it. LOL

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by JoseCortez:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by thl408:

Originally posted by Jcool:

I was all set to debunk the Shanahan script narrative, but then a funny thing happened: I couldn't.

It turns out, yes, there is something to it (and I'm as surprised as anyone). https://t.co/x3P8AjE2o4

— Josh Hermsmeyer (@friscojosh) October 27, 2022

He should script the first 70 plays. Problem solved.

Haha. I heard a commentator also note he scripts the first 12 plays coming out of the half. We used to be really good last year but not this year. Last year, we were awesome in the 4 minute drills and those aren't scripted at all. But not this year.

Sooooo

Crock and Panelli said he's a really good play designer but not an in-game play caller.

That has Greg Roman feel to it to me.

you and other say that.. but then there's vid showing open guys missed after the scripted plays

what more can Kyle do.. scheme everyone open at the same time ?

We have no idea the progression, the timing, the oline breakdown etc. Video doesn't mean much (stills are even worse) without input from either the coachbor player as to what was going on in that particular play.

yet speculating what you say is happening without showing why, holds more water ?

Dude, you seriously need to read/listen more. Your stubborn hatred is literally blinding you. Hell, start with this very article.

lol, it's all speculation and someone's opinion. that does not make it fact

Then in you agree with the article, Kyle runs this b***h. He's the QB. His QB nor his receivers/running backs have no issues executing his own scripted plays to start each game and through the first quarter.

But clearly, not afterwards.

What does say to you about Jimmy, the receivers and the running game?

what does it say ?

what more can the receivers do ?
what more can the OL/RBs do to beat run blitzes ?

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by JoseCortez:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by thl408:

Originally posted by Jcool:

I was all set to debunk the Shanahan script narrative, but then a funny thing happened: I couldn't.

It turns out, yes, there is something to it (and I'm as surprised as anyone). https://t.co/x3P8AjE2o4

— Josh Hermsmeyer (@friscojosh) October 27, 2022

He should script the first 70 plays. Problem solved.

Haha. I heard a commentator also note he scripts the first 12 plays coming out of the half. We used to be really good last year but not this year. Last year, we were awesome in the 4 minute drills and those aren't scripted at all. But not this year.

Sooooo

Crock and Panelli said he's a really good play designer but not an in-game play caller.

That has Greg Roman feel to it to me.

you and other say that.. but then there's vid showing open guys missed after the scripted plays

what more can Kyle do.. scheme everyone open at the same time ?

We have no idea the progression, the timing, the oline breakdown etc. Video doesn't mean much (stills are even worse) without input from either the coachbor player as to what was going on in that particular play.

yet speculating what you say is happening without showing why, holds more water ?

Dude, you seriously need to read/listen more. Your stubborn hatred is literally blinding you. Hell, start with this very article.

lol, it's all speculation and someone's opinion. that does not make it fact

Then in you agree with the article, Kyle runs this b***h. He's the QB. His QB nor his receivers/running backs have no issues executing his own scripted plays to start each game and through the first quarter.

But clearly, not afterwards.

What does say to you about Jimmy, the receivers and the running game?

what does it say ?

what more can the receivers do ?
what more can the OL/RBs do to beat run blitzes ?

Read it. Click on the link in our thread and read it.

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by JoseCortez:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by thl408:

Originally posted by Jcool:

I was all set to debunk the Shanahan script narrative, but then a funny thing happened: I couldn't.

It turns out, yes, there is something to it (and I'm as surprised as anyone). https://t.co/x3P8AjE2o4

— Josh Hermsmeyer (@friscojosh) October 27, 2022

He should script the first 70 plays. Problem solved.

Haha. I heard a commentator also note he scripts the first 12 plays coming out of the half. We used to be really good last year but not this year. Last year, we were awesome in the 4 minute drills and those aren't scripted at all. But not this year.

Sooooo

Crock and Panelli said he's a really good play designer but not an in-game play caller.

That has Greg Roman feel to it to me.

you and other say that.. but then there's vid showing open guys missed after the scripted plays

what more can Kyle do.. scheme everyone open at the same time ?

We have no idea the progression, the timing, the oline breakdown etc. Video doesn't mean much (stills are even worse) without input from either the coachbor player as to what was going on in that particular play.

yet speculating what you say is happening without showing why, holds more water ?

Dude, you seriously need to read/listen more. Your stubborn hatred is literally blinding you. Hell, start with this very article.

lol, it's all speculation and someone's opinion. that does not make it fact

Then in you agree with the article, Kyle runs this b***h. He's the QB. His QB nor his receivers/running backs have no issues executing his own scripted plays to start each game and through the first quarter.

But clearly, not afterwards.

What does say to you about Jimmy, the receivers and the running game?

what does it say ?

what more can the receivers do ?
what more can the OL/RBs do to beat run blitzes ?

Read it. Click on the link in our thread and read it.

I did the first time and went back for it again.. since i've looked at other stuff in between.. I came away with this.. my OP

what more can Kyle do.. ?

Originally posted by ninerfan818:
I guess you're right. We did have lots of penalties. Delay of game, etc. harbs had issues getting the plays relayed in time, at times. I am just sorely disappointed in how this current team comes out impotent in the 2nd half and especially the 4th quarter of games.

It's uninspiring and I don't think Shammy has the team prepared consistently. I think there needs to be more accountability from him and the star players. But it has to start from the top. The leader needs to be a better leader.

I'm not sure what the star players or the coaches can do as far as accountability is concerned. I don't think they can fine them for jumping off side or holding. The star players are making errors as well. Williams was caught holding and I think he had a false start too. For some reason some teams commit those types of penalties more than others. Is it the way they practice? The design of the plays?

It's time for Kyle to get very creative with the offense, no excuses. He has been searching for a dynamic, multi talented RB for years - starting with signing Jet, to drafting day 2 RBs for a system that has had success with UDFAs. Now he has a proven, ultra talented RB that can line up anywhere and is equally dangerous running or catching the ball. Even if the threat to attack deep is not legit, the ability to attack horizontally is more than enough to move the ball. When teams play man, Kittle and CMC are two very good man coverage beaters. When teams play zone, attack horizontally. I think this is the blueprint for the skillset for this group of offensive players.

Originally posted by susweel:
If he don't get to the NFC championship game this year with a weak NFC and stacked roster this year will be a huge disappointment. So far this season his coaching has been very supbar.

Subpar is Jimmy's middle name. KS was prepare for Trey as the starter, QB1. For "subpar" highest paid backup Jimmy to become QB1 again out of no where with no TC or preseason and adding on other injuries to starters like Eman, Armstead, Kinlaw, Jimmie Ward etc is beyond frustrating especially year after year and most likely a burned out for KS. 9er "fans" need to realize those issues and give KS a break.