49ers Head Coach Kyle Shanahan Thread

Originally posted by OldJoe:
A lot of people were pouring the Homey Kool Aid. We were completely outraged that Vegas set out over/under at 4.5.
"Hoyer didn't have to be great, Shanny will scheme the offense successfully." Does he deserve any blame? Hoyer was his boy and as many point out .... handed the job.

I think we do need to be patient. I never bought we would the scheming thing.

Seems to me it is hard to be real successful without the Franchise QB. I think there are less than 15 true ones. How we get one is beyond me. All our QBs that took us to the SB, none were first round picks. But that means finding a diamond in the rough which is always iffy.

We throw some money at Cousins

Originally posted by susweel:

Originally posted by Fanaticofnfl:
Everybody has a right to their own opinion.

I just hope Jed doesn't fire anybody over fans' opinions.

Nobody should be fired for at least 3 years. Let them do their thing.

Well if that were true, we would be in Tomsula's third year and thinking of dumping him for Kelly for the next 3 years.

Originally posted by AlexCat49er:

Originally posted by genus49:

This is how I know you're trolling.

If you look at his stats prior to coming here, he's been a good quarterback. At least for the last few seasons.

He's on his seventh team in eight years. There's a reason for that.

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by AlexCat49er:

If you look at his stats prior to coming here, he's been a good quarterback. At least for the last few seasons.

What makes more sense in your head.

That a coach who got Matt Ryan to play the best football of his career and got him to be the MVP of the league doesn't know what he's doing and is making Brian Hoyer worse than he really is due to playcalling.

OR

That Brian Hoyer isn't doing the things the coaches expect him to do?

Or the guy calling plays for Matt Schaub when he had his best year (4700 yards 29 tds) or the guy willing to change his scheme enough to have RGIII looking like the next breed of QB.

Originally posted by Willisfn4life:
He's on his seventh team in eight years. There's a reason for that.

Are you telling me highly successful QBs aren't there for the taking in free agency every year?

Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
Dude is about to get on my ignored list...just a few more trolling posts and I'm doin' it!

Just added him :)

KS is a project.... Really not much different than the whole organization right now.... He's not a clear cut difference maker, but will hopefully get better over the next few seasons.... The natural thing is to try and compare him to a superstar like McVay, but we're never going to be happy if we do that.... if he can be a poor man's Norv Turner, there's a chance to win with a strong supporting cast.

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by Willisfn4life:

He's on his seventh team in eight years. There's a reason for that.

Are you telling me highly successful QBs aren't there for the taking in free agency every year?

I'm scared to answer this. I don't want to blow your mind. So I'm playing it safe..."I plead the fifth."

Originally posted by Follower:

KS is a project.... Really not much different than the whole organization right now.... He's not a clear cut difference maker, but will hopefully get better over the next few seasons.... The natural thing is to to try and compare him to a superstar like McVay, but we're never going to be happy if we do that.... if he can be a poor man's Norv Turner, there a chance to win with a strong supporting cast.

Good lord.

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by AlexCat49er:

Do you not find it odd that a QB that was highly successful with like 6 other teams comes here and suddenly forgets how to play?

This is how I know you're trolling.

Good lord on LSD.

Originally posted by genus49:

What makes more sense in your head.

That a coach who got Matt Ryan to play the best football of his career and got him to be the MVP of the league doesn't know what he's doing and is making Brian Hoyer worse than he really is due to playcalling.

OR

That Brian Hoyer isn't doing the things the coaches expect him to do?

I don't disagree with you. Shanahan has had some offensive success in the past, so we know his system can work in the right situation. It should be noted that Matt Ryan did not have a great season his first year with Shanahan and that is with a lot more talented playmakers around him.

Originally posted by Follower:

KS is a project.... Really not much different than the whole organization right now.... He's not a clear cut difference maker, but will hopefully get better over the next few seasons.... The natural thing is to try and compare him to a superstar like McVay, but we're never going to be happy if we do that.... if he can be a poor man's Norv Turner, there's a chance to win with a strong supporting cast.

Dude this s**t is comical.....Kyle has a MUCH stronger resume and track record in the NFL as a play caller then the golden boy. In fact McVay isn't even playing HC yet....he's getting to be just OC.

Here's a little something.....I bet you didn't know that Kyle and Sean got to call plays for similar rosters just a year a part. They both had Cousins and RGIII, Garcon, Alfred Morris etc.....I'll bet you'll never guess which playcaller scored more points, more yards, more TDs, more first downs and less penalites. Just take a look at the offense's for the 2013 and 2014 redskins. Spoiler alert: it wasn't Sean.

To think that Kyle wouldn't be lighting up s**t in LA is ignoring almost a decade of on field nfl results.

Originally posted by Niners816:

Dude this s**t is comical.....Kyle has a MUCH stronger resume and track record in the NFL as a play caller then the golden boy. In fact McVay isn't even playing HC yet....he's getting to be just OC.

Here's a little something.....I bet you didn't know that Kyle and Sean got to call plays for similar rosters just a year a part. They both had Cousins and RGIII, Garcon, Alfred Morris etc.....I'll bet you'll never guess which playcaller scored more points, more yards, more TDs, more first downs and less penalites. Just take a look at the offense's for the 2013 and 2014 redskins. Spoiler alert: it wasn't Sean.

To think that Kyle wouldn't be lighting up s**t in LA is ignoring almost a decade of on field nfl results.

Stop being a homer!!

Originally posted by Follower:

KS is a project.... Really not much different than the whole organization right now.... He's not a clear cut difference maker, but will hopefully get better over the next few seasons.... The natural thing is to try and compare him to a superstar like McVay, but we're never going to be happy if we do that.... if he can be a poor man's Norv Turner, there's a chance to win with a strong supporting cast.

LMAOOOOOOOO

Originally posted by Fanaticofnfl:

Originally posted by Niners816:

Dude this s**t is comical.....Kyle has a MUCH stronger resume and track record in the NFL as a play caller then the golden boy. In fact McVay isn't even playing HC yet....he's getting to be just OC.

Here's a little something.....I bet you didn't know that Kyle and Sean got to call plays for similar rosters just a year a part. They both had Cousins and RGIII, Garcon, Alfred Morris etc.....I'll bet you'll never guess which playcaller scored more points, more yards, more TDs, more first downs and less penalites. Just take a look at the offense's for the 2013 and 2014 redskins. Spoiler alert: it wasn't Sean.

To think that Kyle wouldn't be lighting up s**t in LA is ignoring almost a decade of on field nfl results.

Stop being a homer!!

This s**t is out of control. The mods need to get a handle on it.


Or I need to just start adding more people to the ignore list. Just added Follower.