Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 806 users in the forums

Lynch: Elway or Millen? Love it or hate it

Shop Find 49ers gear online

Lynch: Elway or Millen? Love it or hate it

Originally posted by VDpwndMjenkins:
What do you say? Call it right now, who will he turn out to be? Stand behind it and own it. Kneejerk reaction or not, just be honest. Some background may be in order tho.

Elway: Owned multiple businesses, car dealerships, resturants i believe and an AFL team. A curvball of a hire at the time but had the pedigree and business accumen it seemed from previous said endevors.

Millen: Hall of fame player, former broadcaster, not sure of anything else.

The comparison can easily be made to Millen but I personally will wait to see how it pans out. I loved em as player and like the connection to Walsh, will just have to wait and see honsetly.

Well, Millen is not in the HOF, even though he won some Super Bowls as a player. If you read up on Millen, there's a lot of negative stuff out there unrelated to him being a GM, like calling one of his previous players a gay slur on the field, calling Ron Jaworski an ethnic slur in 2010, or as a player punching the Patriots GM after a playoff loss in the late 80s. Not that that means much, but perhaps some signs of poor judgment?

At this point.. we can hyper analyze all we want but it won't change the outcome of what happens. I am shocked, worried, and unsure what to expect. I want to like the hire, but all I can say is.. if this is who Shanahan wanted out of the three final choices, then OK. I'm just a fan who's tired of seeing the team lose and I hope we can turn this around soon.
Lynch is taking a job with the designation of growing into it. Nobody wanted to take the job with Shanahan calling the shots. If Lynch is surrounded with good people around him it has a chance of working out. At the very least there are fresh faces around and maybe the blind squirrel (Jed York) found another acorn, but this time if it works out keep him.
  • okdkid
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 23,726
I'm okay with them going off the board. But since there isn't a track record to judge, I'll reserve judgement. Just because it's shocking doesn't mean it's a good or bad hire. Time will tell.
Should of went with Steve Young if they were gonna go this route
  • okdkid
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 23,726
Originally posted by ninerfan4life:
Should of went with Steve Young if they were gonna go this route

But Steve Young a b***h though
Originally posted by ninerfan4life:
Should of went with Steve Young if they were gonna go this route

Lol after some of the things he's said about the Yorks? I mean he's been truthful Imo, but u can see why they'd never offer it to him
[ Edited by crabman82 on Jan 30, 2017 at 7:54 AM ]
Originally posted by ninerfan4life:
Should of went with Steve Young if they were gonna go this route

IMO the only way I think Steve Young would get anywhere near the team right now is if he were part of a ownership group buying it from the Yorks.
I've read good things, but it's way too early to tell at this point. Hopefully he brings some experienced personnel people in to work alongside Gamble if he stays, that would make me feel much better about he whole situation.
too early
I'm always in favor of giving a guy a chance. The 49ers need talent especially in offense. With no QB on sight, it should take at least 3 years to be respectable. Here is what 49ers need.
1. QB
2. OL
3. DT/Pass rusher
4. WR
5. CB/ILB

We will find out how he does on this upcoming FAs and draft.
Originally posted by crabman82:
Originally posted by ninerfan4life:
Should of went with Steve Young if they were gonna go this route

Lol after some of the things he's said about the Yorks? I mean he's been truthful Imo, but u can see why they'd never offer it to him

You assume Steve Young wanted the job or the FO wanted him.

Crazy idea right?
Originally posted by ninerfan4life:
Should of went with Steve Young if they were gonna go this route

Youre assuming that he would want the job and that he had as close of a relationship with Shanahan as Lynch does.
Yeah, I had the same thought, will he be a super star GM like Elway, or complete bust like Millen? Of course we are hoping super star, but what a ballsey move by Kyle.
He could have gone tried and true, battle tested retread, but he took a chance on a novice. This to me shows he is a risk taker, I like that, and it shows he will have a strong hand in personal, I also like that. So, lets hope this works out.
[ Edited by GolittaCamper on Jan 30, 2017 at 9:13 AM ]
Peyton Manning or Joey Harrington. Where we go at qb will be the deciding factor.
I like it, with some reservations (I want to see who else Lynch brings on). So I voted love because that was closest to my current view.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone