Originally posted by bzborow1:
The argument the poster was making is that the opportunity cost of signing an Alshon Jeffrey is relatively small for San Francisco. They have cap room and core players (Buckner, Garnett, Robinson, etc.) who's extension won't come up for another 3 years so the team can absorb the contract. Further, he's saying there's a potential upside in it because a true #1 WR is going to make life easier on coaches, the future QB and Carlos Hyde's running room. It's a good argument, actually.
Also, consider that the 49ers must spend at least ~89% of the salary cap on players and are currently well below that mark, meaning they are obliged to spend soon.
I understand his argument but IMHO that's not how you setup a team...just because you have a a ton of money (and can absorb the contract) doesn't mean you have to overspend to get someone like AJ, who's not worth the type of money he will command to come here.
I really don't care if we have a ton of young players not due for extensions for a couple yrs, that still doesn't mean you overspend especially when the new cycle for the 89% rule goes from 2017-2020. Before we bust a nut on 2017 FAs, why not look to see who's gonna be a FA in the next couple yrs around the league?
I have no problem spending cash at all, BUT BE SMART...bad contracts can hurt the team that's trying to rebuild. There's a free agency every yr...how's that Torrey Smith contract doing for us? McClusky
's mindset is well his contract didn't hurt us so who cares, but in reality we could have spent that money on other players that actually might be contributing (and we don't have to draft for that said position)....SF has spent (so far) $11.2 million for 930 yards 7 TDs in two season for Smith

just because we can "absorb it" doesn't mean it's a smart move to make.
Signing every "big name" FA isn't always the best approach and I've already thrown out some names that prove it.
Here's a example from this past FA:
Would you rather have Casey Hayward at 3 yrs $15 million (currently the 3rd overall CB) or Janoris Jenkins at 5yr $62.5 million ( currently #5 overall CB)
Let's go after some of the big guys (who most likely don't come here unless we grossly overspend), but don't miss out on the "2nd tier" guys who could be a better value.
-we don't get Alshon Jeffery let's roll for Garcon who's gonna hit 1,000 yards this season and is a very well rounded WR (don't care about age one's always hurt and one isn't)
-We don't get Trumaine Johnson let's look at Dre Kirkpatrick (good coverage CB) or A.J. Bouye who's currently the 6th overall CB.
-we don't get Dontari Poe let's look at Nick Fairley, Brandon Williams,or Bennie Logan they all can stop the run (Fairly is a better pass rusher).
[ Edited by NYniner85 on Dec 22, 2016 at 12:00 PM ]