Originally posted by Niners816:
Originally posted by Lutch57:
I'm comparing football teams not a spaceship and fking grapefruit. The point is people yelling about the QB on here. It doesn't matter who the QB is if the scheme is crap. It doesn't matter if the play calling is horrible. If no one is open it doesn't matter. If you call a 2 yard out on a 3rd and 5 to the sideline when your down by three scores, it doesn't matter. If you play to keep close instead of win, you're going to lose and it doesn't matter. Same goes for defense. It doesn't matter your roster or your QB.
Youre comparing 2 recent championship quality teams and their ability to plug in guys with ours which is a rebuilding roster with a brand new scheme. That's how it's not an abt comparison.
You mean apt not abt.
Also its 100% relevant being as we have talent and a scheme that doesn't work. Do you think Trevor Siemian who was an average at best QB at Northwestern, is all of a sudden is a Payton Manning clone because he's just that good? He threw a million picks in College. Look at the Niners before Harbaugh. It's the same as last year and thats what's frustrating. The difference between a successful NFL team and a 5-11 team is very very thin in the NFL, we have a lot of talent on defense, we have a lot of talent on the offensive line, this roster is FAR from depleted. I get losing games on the road to tough teams, it happens. I don't get the bad coaching and bad play calling that now continues to happen and was even happening in the Rams game. Until that is fixed the QB is the least of our problems.
[ Edited by Lutch57 on Sep 25, 2016 at 4:38 PM ]