49ers Offensive Line

Originally posted by dtg_9er:

Originally posted by SofaKing:

Originally posted by jreff22:
Anybody have the PFF grades for all starters?

Would love to get the grades for all the players.

Not sure how to collect the various line scores in one table on PFF, but briefly this was the order in ratings, best to least effective. I trust their ratings about as far as I can throw them but...what else do we have to do during the week!

Thomas
Tiller
Silberman
Looney
Boone
Hooey
Brown
Staley
Pears
Miller, Pat
Martin

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by dtg_9er:

Originally posted by SofaKing:

Originally posted by jreff22:
Anybody have the PFF grades for all starters?

Would love to get the grades for all the players.

Not sure how to collect the various line scores in one table on PFF, but briefly this was the order in ratings, best to least effective. I trust their ratings about as far as I can throw them but...what else do we have to do during the week!

Thomas
Tiller
Silberman
Looney
Boone
Hooey
Brown
Staley
Pears
Miller, Pat
Martin

Staley and Pears suck. Cut them! Hooey is clearly better.

Originally posted by dtg_9er:

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by dtg_9er:

Originally posted by SofaKing:

Originally posted by jreff22:
Anybody have the PFF grades for all starters?

Would love to get the grades for all the players.

Not sure how to collect the various line scores in one table on PFF, but briefly this was the order in ratings, best to least effective. I trust their ratings about as far as I can throw them but...what else do we have to do during the week!

Thomas
Tiller
Silberman
Looney
Boone
Hooey
Brown
Staley
Pears
Miller, Pat
Martin

Staley and Pears suck. Cut them! Hooey is clearly better.

Indeed! Let's move Tiller and Silberman into starting spots! They are both in the top five!

So the line would be: Boone/Tiller/Looney/Silberman/Thomas! Yay!

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by InsertNameHere:

Originally posted by WRATHman44:

Originally posted by InsertNameHere:
I missed the game, and don't want to read through 10 pages of BS to find a few honest opinions, so WRATH, SOFA, NC...how was the oline?

I thought the starting line looked pretty good, but it's hard to tell with how few reps they got together. Staley and Pears played one series and looked okay. Everything after that is pretty tough to figure, since miller appears to suck and Brown IS SOOOOOO gifted, but SOOOOOO raw. Martin and Thomas both looked further along Thani expected, and Loo ey was not a crap sandwich. I still expect Martin and Thomas to start, if they can play with consistency.

Martin and Thomas would be where? Martin(RG) and Thomas(RT) with Killgore(C)and Staley(LT)Boone(LG), something like that?

Or-

Staley-Boone-Martin-Thomas-Pears

Or like that?

This?

Originally posted by thl408:
Very encouraged by BThomas' performance. I'm just looking at the ratings. Not bad for first time action.
MMartin

Originally posted by thl408:
Very encouraged by BThomas' performance. I'm just looking at the ratings. Not bad for first time action.
MMartin

Originally posted by SofaKing:

Originally posted by jreff22:
Anybody have the PFF grades for all starters?

Would love to get the grades for all the players.

Originally posted by thl408:
Very encouraged by BThomas' performance. I'm just looking at the ratings. Not bad for first time action.
MMartin

Originally posted by thl408:
Very encouraged by BThomas' performance. I'm just looking at the ratings. Not bad for first time action.
MMartin

Originally posted by dtg_9er:

Originally posted by thl408:
Very encouraged by BThomas' performance. I'm just looking at the ratings. Not bad for first time action.
MMartin

Still believe Martin being three years younger than Thomas is significant and that he will grow into the job. But they still have four or five guys who can play center so he doesn't have to be rushed if he's not ready. Martin looks lighter this year and it may take him some adjustment to use quickness for lost tonnage.

Edit: thanks Disp...is there a way to show only OL? Other than take everything to excel and edit I couldn't find one.

Originally posted by jonnydel:

Originally posted by dtg_9er:

Originally posted by thl408:
Very encouraged by BThomas' performance. I'm just looking at the ratings. Not bad for first time action.
MMartin

Still believe Martin being three years younger than Thomas is significant and that he will grow into the job. But they still have four or five guys who can play center so he doesn't have to be rushed if he's not ready. Martin looks lighter this year and it may take him some adjustment to use quickness for lost tonnage.

Edit: thanks Disp...is there a way to show only OL? Other than take everything to excel and edit I couldn't find one.

My issue with MMartin is that: I'd be fine with him as a developmental pick, like a 5th or 6th rounder, who was going to be kept as a 7th lineman on our team. However, we're looking to him as a starter/primary backup interior lineman. To me, I don't like that at all. If we have any injury to our interior line, we're putting a guy in who's still a year or two away from being solid-good and we've used a 2nd round pick on him.

Originally posted by dtg_9er:

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by dtg_9er:

Originally posted by SofaKing:

Originally posted by jreff22:
Anybody have the PFF grades for all starters?

Would love to get the grades for all the players.

Not sure how to collect the various line scores in one table on PFF, but briefly this was the order in ratings, best to least effective. I trust their ratings about as far as I can throw them but...what else do we have to do during the week!

Thomas
Tiller
Silberman
Looney
Boone
Hooey
Brown
Staley
Pears
Miller, Pat
Martin

Staley and Pears suck. Cut them! Hooey is clearly better.

Indeed! Let's move Tiller and Silberman into starting spots! They are both in the top five!

So the line would be: Boone/Tiller/Looney/Silberman/Thomas! Yay!

Originally posted by philosoraptor:

Originally posted by jonnydel:

Originally posted by dtg_9er:

Originally posted by thl408:
Very encouraged by BThomas' performance. I'm just looking at the ratings. Not bad for first time action.
MMartin

Still believe Martin being three years younger than Thomas is significant and that he will grow into the job. But they still have four or five guys who can play center so he doesn't have to be rushed if he's not ready. Martin looks lighter this year and it may take him some adjustment to use quickness for lost tonnage.

Edit: thanks Disp...is there a way to show only OL? Other than take everything to excel and edit I couldn't find one.

My issue with MMartin is that: I'd be fine with him as a developmental pick, like a 5th or 6th rounder, who was going to be kept as a 7th lineman on our team. However, we're looking to him as a starter/primary backup interior lineman. To me, I don't like that at all. If we have any injury to our interior line, we're putting a guy in who's still a year or two away from being solid-good and we've used a 2nd round pick on him.

3rd rounder, but yes. He looks like he was drafted a round to high. Maybe he just had a rough game, but for the most part thomas looks as though he will be the better of the two. Looks like baalke hedged his bet by taking both.