Originally posted by oldninerdude:
Originally posted by LasVegasWally:sorry, but i have to disagree--TB seems to have trouble consistently executing his assignment on OZ run plays to the left AND to the right.
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by oldninerdude:
thanks for posting this--very useful info.
stepping back and trying to look at the big picture of how shanalynch are going about the rebuild, it looks like they intend to remake the o-line with more agile, athletic players rather than the bigger, slower "mauler" types Baalke preferred.
adios Kilgore, hello Richburg. that's just the beginning.
Garnett can stick around because he's devoted himself to remaking his physique---he's gotten stronger, quicker, more agile and flexible. he may have remade himself into precisely what shanny's looking for in his guards, and he's been around for the past year--learning the playbook, etc. he's not exactly an experienced vet--but he's not a fresh-faced rookie either. pencil him in at one guard spot.
Tomlinson is a question mark to me as to just how agile and athletic he is. he had some ups and downs last season--but came in late and was learning on the job, plus he's now got a year's worth of experience in the system. pencil him in at the other guard spot.
Staley is, well, Staley. write his name down in ink and give the man a raise. he deserves it. he's not only the best returning lineman, he's a team leader.
Brown has alot to prove this season. if he shows up out of shape and overweight, he could lose his job. he's got to work hard every day, every practice, to show he's developed the determination, the mental strength to consistently execute his assigned block on every play in every game. if he can do that, the sky's the limit. pencil him in with a red pencil.
Beadles is an experienced, versatile vet who can play any position on the o-line. jack-of-all-trades, master-of-none. keep him around, but keep him on the bench.
Magnuson, Gilliam, Williams are guys that appear to have the physical tools needed, and have a years experience in the system. they should push for playing time should someone falter or--God forbid--suffer an injury.
that leaves the draft--lots of prospects and i expect shanalynch to take at least two and maybe three 0-line prospects. if Nelson falls to them at 9, sprint to the podium to take him. otherwise i like Wynn, B Smith, Daniels late, and Williams (Tex) or Miller, the kid out of UCLA at tackle.
Good post OND.
Yeah, we have a big OZ question mark for Brown because of his size. If Kyle genuinely wants to remake his OL, using Richburg as an example, that means we have more to worry about than Brown. Both Tomlinson and Garnett were talented power and gap G's originally drafted to play in those schemes. Both were first rounders and do have talent. But both have huge question marks in pass protection and we run zone here.
So if that's the lineup, that's 3 power linemen starting in your 5.
Losing weight also doesn't necessarily replace the skills you need to run IZ and OZ and be stellar in PP. Brown is the least of my worries of the 3 because he's really only poor on runs off his outside edge. Laken Tomlinson may have an average ceiling here because of the lack of fit. Same exact concept with Garnett. I have huge question marks about both of those two.
Two premier T's and a C will certainly help mask deficiencies in pass protection but for IZ and OZ, they'll be on their own and will be critical in what Kyle can and can not call. The good news is, like you said, both with have had a full year of exposure to the system.
Both players looked far bigger than their listed 320 coming out of college too. Transforming their bodies is a step in the right direction but let's see if they have the skills to fit zone now.
Excellent call in bold and very often overlooked in the criticisms of Trent Brown!
its not that he lacks the physical tools--the size, strength, or mobility--but sometimes he just doesn't seem to react quickly enough to the snap of the ball. (frankly,, i think that's sometimes true even in pass protection)
i have seen a number of OZ run plays to the left side where TB allowed his man to cross in front of him and tackle the RB behind the LOS--while TB ends up just standing there watching. just a failure to execute his assignment on time.
my belief is that this is a problem he can overcome through hard work and additional experience. remember he's still a young man, and relatively inexperienced at playing football. if he comes to TC in shape, his coaches undoubtedly recognize the problem and will get on him about it--help him address it.
if he fixes the problem and learns to consistently execute his assignments with vigor--look out NFL!
Two criticisms of Brown:
1) he relies on his length too often instead of moving his feet...pushes pass rushers wide by using his long reach. That laziness is less important now that they have JG getting the ball out quickly, but should be cleaned up.
2) weight and laziness--worried he will come to camp overweight and won't make the progress needed to improve overall effectiveness.
On the other hand, if he comes into camp in shape and has a great attitude--wonderful!



