49ers vs. Seahawks Tickets Available! →

There are 809 users in the forums

Contract Extentions

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Your wrong.
Don't believe comp picks are handed out in 2nd round.
  • Taco
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 83
Originally posted by matt49er:
You're low balling these guys and if a GM did that, the fact is they wouldn't retain these players. No chance Kaep takes 13.75m/year and like it or not, Crabtree is going to get a min of 8-9M/year and may end up getting 10-12. Iupati is a goner, with Kilgore, Thomas and Martin we could end up having an entirely new interior OL within 2 years although I think Boone will end up staying, no way we pay Iupati as the highest paid OG in football. Not that he doesn't deserve it, it just doesn't fit into our salary structure, especially with our QB getting ready to get paid.

The VD thing doesn't worry me, he's no idiot, he knows he got a front loaded deal, he just sees guys like Kaep, Crabs & Aldon within 1 year of big deals, he knows guys like Boone, Culliver will get decent contracts and he doesn't want the $$ to dry up before he gets his last good sized deal. I'd be willing to be he would take the same deal he signed in 2010, maybe even a little less, this is about years & a nice sized signing bonus, not a huge increase.

End of the day, Kaep will get $18-20M/year, Iupati will leave after this season, the VD and Boone situations will work themselves out, Aldon will get a huge deal either after this year or next unless he drives into another tree yelling I have a bomb. The only mystery to me is Crabtree, the open market will probably dictate his position with us unless he's willing to take 8-9M/year which I think we'd be willing to pony up.


I wasn't clear enough on the kaep contract. I did state incentive based he gets his average of 13.75 regardless but the contract would have bonuses tied in to raise it for say superbowl win, sb mvp honors, league mvp honors, passing title winner, etc. say we win the sb then that would trigger a bonus of say 2m say he wins mvp 1m, league mvp 1m. so we win the big one his following season salary would jump to 15.75 if he was the mvp 16.75, league mvp 17.75 or something like that Paragge marathe could figure that part out.

Vernon I would not offer him an extension at all for the way he went about it. Davis is being an unnecessary distraction, asking for an extension is ok but his attitude to the situation is wrong. he was quoted as saying I might be there," he said, smiling. "I might not. It's mandatory. I probably should be there. We'll see. that's not something you want a team leader saying personally he should have said no comment or I will not discuss the situation. by the way he would like to sign an extension similar to the last deal given to him but at this stage in his career hes not worth that much. hes locked up with the 9ers until hes 32 years old. do you really think if his speed goes he will be able to get open? hes not a good route runner or a natural hands catcher and he relies on his speed to get open.
  • fropwns
  • The Last Fronin
  • Posts: 28,026
Mr. Taco, Mr. GM, sir. Would you have gotten rid of TO? Hypothetically speaking?
So Kap is going to take 5M less a year than the reported asking price AND only sign a 4-year deal?! WHAT?

Crab is going to settle for $7M a year, and -- as a 27-year-old -- is only going to sign for 3 years? WHAT?!
Originally posted by Taco:


With that said if we lose crab and ilupati than better believe we could end up with two 2nd round comp picks giving us the option of moving around next year to grab a replacement at guard if needed.

They could let all their FA leave and sign no one and they wouldn't ever end up with a single 2nd round comp pick.
[ Edited by saj4423 on Jun 1, 2014 at 8:45 PM ]
Originally posted by Ninerz4Life:
Your wrong.

You're wrong
Your high if you think the 49ers were a better team without Crab last year. Post a poll we'll see who agrees. I'm done this isn't even intelligent conversation at this point.
  • kem99
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 946
So here's what happens when you make those offers to Kap, Iupati and Crabtree. Kap says no and you have to franchise tag him next year at a higher cap number than if you work out a deal now.

The season ends with Iupati's contract running out so he decides to test FA and gets a bigger deal than what you can afford since you are now paying Kap the franchise tag number.

Crabtree Crabtree leaves your offer on the table and goes to FA and gets a better offer since he's probably the best WR on the market.

You are shocked to learn that the highest comp pick you can get is at the end of the 3rd round but turns out you don't get those either because you didn't understand the formula and signed more FA's than you lost.

I'd start sprucing up your resume.
Hate the break it to everyone, we won't have Kap, Aldon, Boone, VD, Crabs, and Iupati in 2 years, not happening. Crabs and Iupati are likely considered goners. Kap should be extended any day now that the money is ours from Rogers release.

Boone and VD have 2 yrs left, VD is still the 3rd highest paid TE in the NFL. Boone is like 38th, we need to lockup Joe Staley too eventually he will want a new deal, he has no guaranteed money in his deal.

I don't blame the FO on any of these deals. Boone signed a deal when he was a basic scrub, with potential. I can see him deserving a new deal, or like MM said, Staley and Boone have better cases than VD does. I wanted VD signed long term, I don't know if it happens, it's possible. But in a few years, we may be left with Kap, Aldon, and either Boone or VD.

The cap is going to go up, but we don't know for sure how much each year, it could be $10M a yr, or even $15M a yr. I project it at $140M next yr, we can't afford VD, Boone, Kap, Aldon, Crabs and Iupati in 2015, not enough cap room.
Originally posted by Taco:
Originally posted by matt49er:
You're low balling these guys and if a GM did that, the fact is they wouldn't retain these players. No chance Kaep takes 13.75m/year and like it or not, Crabtree is going to get a min of 8-9M/year and may end up getting 10-12. Iupati is a goner, with Kilgore, Thomas and Martin we could end up having an entirely new interior OL within 2 years although I think Boone will end up staying, no way we pay Iupati as the highest paid OG in football. Not that he doesn't deserve it, it just doesn't fit into our salary structure, especially with our QB getting ready to get paid.

The VD thing doesn't worry me, he's no idiot, he knows he got a front loaded deal, he just sees guys like Kaep, Crabs & Aldon within 1 year of big deals, he knows guys like Boone, Culliver will get decent contracts and he doesn't want the $$ to dry up before he gets his last good sized deal. I'd be willing to be he would take the same deal he signed in 2010, maybe even a little less, this is about years & a nice sized signing bonus, not a huge increase.

End of the day, Kaep will get $18-20M/year, Iupati will leave after this season, the VD and Boone situations will work themselves out, Aldon will get a huge deal either after this year or next unless he drives into another tree yelling I have a bomb. The only mystery to me is Crabtree, the open market will probably dictate his position with us unless he's willing to take 8-9M/year which I think we'd be willing to pony up.


I wasn't clear enough on the kaep contract. I did state incentive based he gets his average of 13.75 regardless but the contract would have bonuses tied in to raise it for say superbowl win, sb mvp honors, league mvp honors, passing title winner, etc. say we win the sb then that would trigger a bonus of say 2m say he wins mvp 1m, league mvp 1m. so we win the big one his following season salary would jump to 15.75 if he was the mvp 16.75, league mvp 17.75 or something like that Paragge marathe could figure that part out.

Vernon I would not offer him an extension at all for the way he went about it. Davis is being an unnecessary distraction, asking for an extension is ok but his attitude to the situation is wrong. he was quoted as saying I might be there," he said, smiling. "I might not. It's mandatory. I probably should be there. We'll see. that's not something you want a team leader saying personally he should have said no comment or I will not discuss the situation. by the way he would like to sign an extension similar to the last deal given to him but at this stage in his career hes not worth that much. hes locked up with the 9ers until hes 32 years old. do you really think if his speed goes he will be able to get open? hes not a good route runner or a natural hands catcher and he relies on his speed to get open.

I understood what you meant by Kaep's contract, either way, that won't get it done period. Kaep would simply say no, force the team to franchise him and pay him a ridiculous amount of money for the 2015 season. Then they would have to extend him or franchise him again and pay him an even fatter franchise deal for 2016, if not, he would get a ton of money on the open market. Kaepernick will not take less than the $18-20M book it.

I think you're taking the VD thing a bit too seriously. This is a business and the workouts are voluntary. VD keeps himself in shape, he knows the playbook, he doesn't need those OTAs. This is a business ploy. Even if he doesn't get what he wants, he'll show up to the mandatory off season stuff. And yes, I do think VD will be a very good TE for a long time, maybe not exactly the same when his speed wears down with age but very good yes.
Originally posted by matt49er:
I think you're taking the VD thing a bit too seriously. This is a business and the workouts are voluntary. VD keeps himself in shape, he knows the playbook, he doesn't need those OTAs. This is a business ploy. Even if he doesn't get what he wants, he'll show up to the mandatory off season stuff. And yes, I do think VD will be a very good TE for a long time, maybe not exactly the same when his speed wears down with age but very good yes.

Thank you
People are actling like VD is going to hold out and throw the season on purpose
Good post
  • Taco
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 83
Originally posted by Ninerz4Life:
Your high if you think the 49ers were a better team without Crab last year. Post a poll we'll see who agrees. I'm done this isn't even intelligent conversation at this point.


I never said the 49ers were a better team without crab last year. I said we had two solid contributors in vd and boldin last season also kaep force feed crab after he came back from his injury.
Originally posted by kem99:
So here's what happens when you make those offers to Kap, Iupati and Crabtree. Kap says no and you have to franchise tag him next year at a higher cap number than if you work out a deal now.

The season ends with Iupati's contract running out so he decides to test FA and gets a bigger deal than what you can afford since you are now paying Kap the franchise tag number.

Crabtree Crabtree leaves your offer on the table and goes to FA and gets a better offer since he's probably the best WR on the market.

You are shocked to learn that the highest comp pick you can get is at the end of the 3rd round but turns out you don't get those either because you didn't understand the formula and signed more FA's than you lost.

I'd start sprucing up your resume.

the 49ers will still be able to make another offer to kaep after the season if he says no and they can give him his 18-20 million per year if he has another solid year. they don't have to automatically franchise him.

crabtree I assume would get better offers than the 8-9m range a few other posters have mentioned from a s**ttier team next year some a*****e team like the raiders, cowboys, and redskins have no fears about over paying players. im not saying these specific teams will they are just examples of teams that over pay free agents the 49ers tend to work the draft and add second wave fa's

ilupati is considered in many circles to be out the door another team will be willing to pay him more than the value assigned to him by ballke. some evidence for this is the acquisition multiple offensive linemen through draft and late round pick trades.

my thought process for my initial offers were based on the front office assigning a number to a player and sticking to it. no team has won the superbowl after giving a qb 20m per season. these offers were low yes, with the hope the at least one may say yes to taking less to keep the team a perennial superbowl contender. I feel aldon might give the 49ers a discount for then sticking with him through his personal issues. kaep, crab, and ilupati aren't the only ones the 49ers are going to have to pay or let go we cant keep all of our stars.

as to the comp pick thing I was buzzing around this time when I wrote the initial post typo 2 and 3 are right next to eachother on the keyboard. initially I was board because there weren't many new threads the past couple days and nobody else had been working on a contract one. my aim was to throw out hypothetical contract offers with the hope others would post other contract offers as well as offer their critique. we all have differing opinions on who we would like to keep and their worth in money, I was hoping others would name their prices.
^^^^i just got a little correction, kaep did not force feed crabs upon his return. When he returned, boldin's numbers actually increased. Boldin had 33 catches for 455 yards while crabs had 19 catches for 284 in the same time frame. In the post season boldin had 16 catches and crabs had 15. Crabs seems to get force feed In last play of a title/Super Bowl games tho I only mentioned this because I ran this particular scenario over in the passing game thread and was surprised it was the case.
Originally posted by Ninerz4Life:
Your high if you think the 49ers were a better team without Crab last year. Post a poll we'll see who agrees. I'm done this isn't even intelligent conversation at this point.

You're high
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone