Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 559 users in the forums

Contract Extentions

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by Taco:
If I were GM, but will probably never happen

Sign kaep to an incentive based contract at 4yr 55m. 13.75m year average with base of 5,11,12,13 per year. 14m signing bonus with 30m guaranteed at signing. incentive based with bonuses tied into winning superbowl, league mvp, sb mvp, and #1 redzone offense

Justification: have a sit down with your qb man to man and put all the cards on the table. honestly contracts are a mix of what have you done for me lately and what do I think you can do for me next year. let him know the 18-20m range for the qb position is too much but cite evidence. only a few qb's in that range have won a superbowl Rodgers, Homo brees, Manning(joseph addai should have been mvp), Flacco(mostly team around him), Rothlesburger. Let him know all wins al pre massive salary. there are incentives to boost his salary for reaching the ultimate goal. romo, cutler, and Stafford play for teams that are happy to just reach the post season(cowboys not so much). if he walks another team will pay but unlikely they will have a roster that can compete for a trophy. this contract will ensure a chance for a trip to the ultimate dance for years to come which will ultimately up his fan approval and marketing ability which will only greatly add to his to make money outside his nfl contract.

Ilupati: let him play out this year and evaluate the situation after the season offer him a take it offer less than their lt jstaley the LT should always be your highest paid lineman and I am a firm believer in this, he protects your qb's blindside. if you pay Ilupati more than you will have an oline with potential issues. Guards are much easier to replace tackles and I forsee the niners looking to a change from the road grade maulers to better pass protection. If marcus martin can step in at center this year, hold his own, and open up holes up the gut we wont really need to pull guards as much.{also see crab+vd}

Crabtree: 3yr 21m offer take it or leave it. evidence being a rookie holdout, multiple injuries, and more of a possession receiver than a game breaker for us. also personally I believe he is in kaeps ear. Im tired of kaep forcing him the ball in a win the game situation two years in a row that has failed. I believe hes more of a disruption to kaeps growth and the teams long term success than his worth. Stevie and Boldin are here for a few years guaranteed. Lloyd may be a one or two year solid option and we have youngsters in patton and ellington. If he walks it forces kaep to learn to look through his progressions instead of the dumb if I think I have crab one on one I will force him the ball that failed twice vs the ravens causing us our first sb loss and our loss last year in the conference championship.

Vernon Davis: He got a front loaded extention a few years back and may or not be asking for more now depending on the media perspective or assumptions. Has not been officially confirmed. Not a natural hands catcher and like a few posters have mentioned has a fairy jump before some catches when not needed. Chancellor is definitely in his head also and trust me the road to the sb will need the niners to give the royal stfu to seattle. Is 30 years old with 2 years remaining and like Bill always said " better to get rid of a player a year too early than a year too late".

With that said if we lose crab and ilupati than better believe we could end up with two 2nd round comp picks giving us the option of moving around next year to grab a replacement at guard if needed. will still have boldin and stevie at wr to give kaep comfort in his wr group. could always go shopping the fa market for a wr or draft one. davis is embarking on the end of his career and I think he knows the niners give him the best chance to win the big one. his jamba juice will close down if he leaves also, plus theres always a chance to trade his ass for a first-third depending on who we can fleece. Personally I don't like his remarks about the mandatory ota's coming up especially with his remarks earlier this year about this year a superbowl or bust year. also if we lose them it free's up a lot of cap space that could mean with good drafting the niners being a perennial superbowl contender as I believe in this the salary cap era with inflated qb salaries. my only beef with harbaugh is he seems like too much of a players coach due to his own career as a player. walsh had a hard time with that himself and that is ultimately what I believe lead him to passing the rains and heading up to gm which was more torture because he was no longer coach.

You can take probably out of this sentence.
Most of what you say about Crabtree is surmise. I can't believe that the rookie holdout is still being held against him and is part of a justification for the level of the next one.

Regarding his "multiple injuries" they mainly impacted on the preseason. Only last year was significantly affected.

And regarding Kaep favouring throwing to him, before you knock away that support ask yourself one question. Why has it happened?
If I had to guess with kaep, they want 18-20, niners will offer 14-15 and the somewhere in the middle will be the deal. Might be a situation where the guanteed money is the key. I don't think crabs will sign for anything less than 9-10 a year. I hope it's with us, but I have my doubts. I think Iupati is gone to the highest bidder because I don't see this FO paying top dollar for a G. THe vd situation makes no sense to me, hopefully it's just more years wanted because I think he has been well compensated.
[ Edited by Niners816 on Jun 1, 2014 at 4:54 PM ]
Originally posted by Taco:
If I were GM, but will probably never happen


Crabtree: 3yr 21m offer take it or leave it. evidence being a rookie holdout, multiple injuries, and more of a possession receiver than a game breaker for us. also personally I believe he is in kaeps ear. Im tired of kaep forcing him the ball in a win the game situation two years in a row that has failed. I believe hes more of a disruption to kaeps growth and the teams long term success than his worth. Stevie and Boldin are here for a few years guaranteed. Lloyd may be a one or two year solid option and we have youngsters in patton and ellington. If he walks it forces kaep to learn to look through his progressions instead of the dumb if I think I have crab one on one I will force him the ball that failed twice vs the ravens causing us our first sb loss and our loss last year in the conference championship.

At least you got the crabtree part right
And I am only referring to the bolded part
7mil is a great deal
I don't have a strong feeling on much of this. We need to get production out of as many people as possible. We're weaker if we need to rely on exceptional skill to be productive on offense. We should make the best offer we can afford on all these players, and be prepared if others offer more.
I say extend or redo Boone who I think can play Staley's position just as well if not better than G. Sign Crabtree back but he probably wants to play in Texas. Get it done he was a true difference maker in 2012. Let Staley and Davis complain if they don't take a small bump but this is the new NFL and 30 is a bad age. Trade them if they don't want to be here they have manageable cap numbers let them work out extensions with someone else. Not to mention the fact they are both becoming more and more susceptible to injury. Staley with the leg problems and Vernon with the concussions. I don't know hard to replace but not impossible plus Crab is a WR can play into his 30's and is only 26 now. IMO Crabtree and Boone. I like Iupati but you don't overpay for a G and he's a great run blocker not a great pass blocker let him walk.
Originally posted by Ninerz4Life:
I say extend or redo Boone who I think can play Staley's position just as well if not better than G. Sign Crabtree back but he probably wants to play in Texas. Get it done he was a true difference maker in 2012. Let Staley and Davis complain if they don't take a small bump but this is the new NFL and 30 is a bad age. Trade them if they don't want to be here they have manageable cap numbers let them work out extensions with someone else. Not to mention the fact they are both becoming more and more susceptible to injury. Staley with the leg problems and Vernon with the concussions. I don't know hard to replace but not impossible plus Crab is a WR can play into his 30's and is only 26 now. IMO Crabtree and Boone. I like Iupati but you don't overpay for a G and he's a great run blocker not a great pass blocker let him walk.


I think we keep Staley, don't we? He's not a contract agitator.
You're low balling these guys and if a GM did that, the fact is they wouldn't retain these players. No chance Kaep takes 13.75m/year and like it or not, Crabtree is going to get a min of 8-9M/year and may end up getting 10-12. Iupati is a goner, with Kilgore, Thomas and Martin we could end up having an entirely new interior OL within 2 years although I think Boone will end up staying, no way we pay Iupati as the highest paid OG in football. Not that he doesn't deserve it, it just doesn't fit into our salary structure, especially with our QB getting ready to get paid.

The VD thing doesn't worry me, he's no idiot, he knows he got a front loaded deal, he just sees guys like Kaep, Crabs & Aldon within 1 year of big deals, he knows guys like Boone, Culliver will get decent contracts and he doesn't want the $$ to dry up before he gets his last good sized deal. I'd be willing to be he would take the same deal he signed in 2010, maybe even a little less, this is about years & a nice sized signing bonus, not a huge increase.

End of the day, Kaep will get $18-20M/year, Iupati will leave after this season, the VD and Boone situations will work themselves out, Aldon will get a huge deal either after this year or next unless he drives into another tree yelling I have a bomb. The only mystery to me is Crabtree, the open market will probably dictate his position with us unless he's willing to take 8-9M/year which I think we'd be willing to pony up.
  • Taco
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 83
Originally posted by English:
Most of what you say about Crabtree is surmise. I can't believe that the rookie holdout is still being held against him and is part of a justification for the level of the next one.

Regarding his "multiple injuries" they mainly impacted on the preseason. Only last year was significantly affected.

And regarding Kaep favouring throwing to him, before you knock away that support ask yourself one question. Why has it happened?


crabtree has missed 22 games over his five year career with the 49ers. his holdout was him being an ass, upset he wasn't the first wr taken. he wanted a contract worth more than heyward-bey who was selected ahead of him. I believe he has been available for one training camp throughout his career if that. regarding his injuries he initially had a stress fracture in his left foot the year he was drafted 2009, in 2011he broke that same foot, and in 2013 he ruptured his right Achilles tendon. in 09 he would have been able to participate in training camp had he not held out, which in the end he ended up signing a contract similar to the initial offer based on his draft slot of the 10th overall pick. Each injury and training camp missed lead to a lack of cohesion amongst the offense. If you believe missing training camp does not affect a team well my friend that's wishful thinking. Crab is a good receiver im not knocking his skills because I like his game but the man has injury prone feet in 3 of his 5 seasons fracture, break, ruptured tendon. I have to believe he may suffer another fracture or break in that left foot. That has to be considered when thinking about offering him another contract.

As for Kaepernicks it started his rookie season while he rode the bench, he built a rapport with crab as he was recovering from an injury. 2012 when kaep took over he had the most comfort with crab and not to many trustworthy wrs behind him. crab seemed to be the only guy on the roster who could consistently catch kaeps fireballs. In essence crabtree has been a crutch for kaepernick. last year davis and boldin were solid contributors but kaep still seemed to force feed crabtree once he came back from the Achilles tear. in the nfc conference game at the end it was kaeps fault he wanted to make shurman the goat and crab the victor in their feud. this year kaep will have multiple options and if he does not prove he will utilize all of them with crab then sorry my position is give him my previous offer or let him go.
With our history of developing WRs or recent history to not keep Crab is insane besides 2013 he's been durable ENOUGH!!! Does nobody remember 2012??? I'm not saying he's the best in the league but he's the best we got. He was a legit number one the 2nd half of 2012 and into the playoffs and had an awesome SB against a good corner in Williams. If Ellington provides a deep threat like Moss did it will open back up the middle of the field this year and Crab will go off again because Kap will be able to see the field again. His holdout sucked get over it already! Not to mention he made a remarkable comeback from the Injury and had two good games in some tough places to play. You are undervaluing one of the most important parts of the NFL the passing game. He's a playmaker you can't argue with that. If he doesn't want to be here well that's life but our O needs him plain and simple.
Originally posted by Ninerz4Life:
With our history of developing WRs or recent history to not keep Crab is insane besides 2013 he's been durable ENOUGH!!! Does nobody remember 2012??? I'm not saying he's the best in the league but he's the best we got. He was a legit number one the 2nd half of 2012 and into the playoffs and had an awesome SB against a good corner in Williams. If Ellington provides a deep threat like Moss did it will open back up the middle of the field this year and Crab will go off again because Kap will be able to see the field again. His holdout sucked get over it already! Not to mention he made a remarkable comeback from the Injury and had two good games in some tough places to play. You are undervaluing one of the most important parts of the NFL the passing game. He's a playmaker you can't argue with that. If he doesn't want to be here well that's life but our O needs him plain and simple.

I could start a thread on NFL players who had 1 good season then faded away into oblivion.
He is not durable enough, if that was the case then there wouldn't be any discussion on this forum about not bringing him back.

While I would like to think his holdout was more his agent being a dumba$$ then Crabs, it still happened. But, then again he is a lot more mature now so I don't expect him to do that again.
In his 5 years he has not been productive enough for the contract we are going to give him. The reason we are is because most people (including our FO) think he deserves it.
I've done extensive research on what he has done for our team, and it is not half as much as most people think.
Other than 1 year he has been pretty much useless in the regular season. He has been a niner for 5
[ Edited by Quest4six on Jun 1, 2014 at 7:27 PM ]
@ Kap and his agent accepting anything under $15M/year.

Originally posted by NeonNiner:
@ Kap and his agent accepting anything under $15M/year.


Question is, does mc hammer get involved or not this time
[ Edited by Niners816 on Jun 1, 2014 at 7:34 PM ]
Useless maybe before Harbs like the rest of our team. Your QuestFor6. If you think we were better without him than with him your insane.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone