-
thl408
- Moderator
-
- Posts: 33,499
Originally posted by KID9R:
I'm not biased towards James, I thought Hunter would be Gore's eventual replaced at one time. I just like to think about the long term. Let's say this is Gore's last year, we trade away James and keep Hunter. Next year we have Hyde and Lattimore and that's it. Both of which have never taken an NFL snap. So we would have cut ties from a 2nd round pick in James and receive next to no compensation for Hunter and would probably draft another RB in next years draft. Those highlight videos made me more excited for James overall, Hunter is the more complete back no doubt but James could be dynamic as a changed of pace back. I can only imagine the amount of production James would had if he had as many check down or screen passes that Hunter got from Alex in those clips. And there's more than one way to skin a cat as it pertains to pass protection. James could easily chip and leak out to the flat as an outlet the way Sporles does.
I don't think the concerns with pass blocking is like the example you provided with Sproles. Chip blocking is something any RB can do to provide some help on a D lineman that is too much to handle. Similar to what happens with Aldon. What Gore is so good at is blitz pickup. This requires an understanding of what defenses like to do with regards to blitz packages and if not done correctly can get Kap hurt. This is the area RBs have trouble with when they are considered a poor pass blocker.
I think LMJ is a goner based in his shaky ball security and his poor attitude. Hunter is just as explosive and should be back to 100% in 14-15.
-
KID9R
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 3,131
Originally posted by CWin4949:
Originally posted by KID9R:
Hunter may not have complained about it like James has but do you really think he's going want to stay here with Lattimore, Hyde and possibly Gore. Hunter could easily get more carries somewhere else (I think he could start for some teams) and make a name for himself.
Do I think he will want to stay here with Lattimore?
What has Lattimore done to secure a roster spot, let alone playing time? Lattimore isn't going to be playing STs, and Hunter can, so to assume Lattimore is going to step in and just take a spot, isn't a sure bet. Lattimore may not even be half the runner he used to be and of ANY previously injured player in almost the history of the NFL, Lattimore has suffered one of the most gruesome injuries of all time, when that happens, it has to take a place in your mentality. Not saying Lattimore won't be a good player, but no one knows what will happen with him mentally or physically, and if he doesn't show A LOT of upside during camp and preseason, when cuts get down to the nitty gritty, are you going to keep a guy that may have limited production and cannot play STs or a guy that has a proven record and is also a STs contributor??T
Who knows, it will be fun to watch though.
Ya sure IF it was JUST Lattimore. But it's not and it's a situation that will occur after the season. So it's all hypothetical anyways.
-
cciowa
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 60,541
Originally posted by Mr.Mcgibblets:
Originally posted by mayo49:
The malcontent one will get cut or traded. Hunter will play out his contract and walk next year.
^ also the way I see it going down.
hunter will stay. what if one of the two kids do not pan out? what if gore decides to walk or retire next year? no I think hunter will stay and resign . if this is a choice between keeping hunter or james for this coming year,,,,, well i think the clear answer is hunter
-
cciowa
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 60,541
Originally posted by crabman82:
hunter is very good. i know some are down on him, but i really think we've kind of forgotten how good he was before he got hurt. its possible last season he didnt have it all back yet even though he was healthy enough to suit up. i bet he is better this year.
you know crab,, i just wonder why they are down on him? it does seem or feel that way but yet they offer no concrete reason. i think he is the most valuable player on our offense that no one talks about
-
cciowa
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 60,541
Originally posted by Scoots:
I'll say it again here ... cut Gore now.
well that makes one of you who would do that
-
CWin4949
- Member
-
- Posts: 8,165
Originally posted by cciowa:
Originally posted by Scoots:
I'll say it again here ... cut Gore now.
well that makes one of you who would do that
I don't care if Gore shows up to camp with one leg amputated and two broken arms, dude's our starting RB as long as he wants to be.
[ Edited by CWin4949 on May 17, 2014 at 2:24 PM ]
-
cciowa
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 60,541
Originally posted by CWin4949:
Originally posted by cciowa:
Originally posted by Scoots:
I'll say it again here ... cut Gore now.
well that makes one of you who would do that
I don't care if Gore shows up to camp with one leg amputated and two broken arms, dude are starting RB as long as he wants to be.
and he would still produce and run block better than a majority of the backs in the nfl. the only way i can see him traded or cut is if indeed he does a roger craig thing where roger somehow lost his ability to run over night. i do not blame the niners for dumping craig, lott was a whole other story
-
pasodoc9er
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 21,040
Aside from the fact that we have under-used, misused and abused, LMJ while on the football field, he is the candidate to go, based on the fact that both trent and JH have both been quoted in print as saying, "LMJ isn't going anywhere". That is usually the KOD(kiss of death)when your Coach and GM both say it. I still feel he should have at least been tried out like a sproles RB, with flare passes, laterals, anything to get him in space...where he excels. Instead he has run between the tackles against guys half again his size, and unlike college, he did not shine in that situation. He has stated he wants to run between tackles but I don't see that happening. I think it shameful he was never used in space...not even give the opportunity to show us what he has. That is awful and put that one on JH.
Which brings to mind lattimore. He doesn't automatically get a pass without showing what he can do. Ergo, if he looks slow, or slowed by virtue of injury, maybe HE was a bad pick. The fact we have not seen anything of him just makes me wonder. Not all guys with his injury do get well enough to be Frank gore. So until we have seen lattimore on the field, he may be the one with the short straw. IF that were to happen, we dam well better find out if LMJ CAN run in space, and can be tough to bring down before 7-8 yds. The fact no one knows that, however, is inexcusably bad coaching/utilization.
-
Mr.Mcgibblets
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 15,079
Originally posted by cciowa:
Originally posted by Mr.Mcgibblets:
Originally posted by mayo49:
The malcontent one will get cut or traded. Hunter will play out his contract and walk next year.
^ also the way I see it going down.
hunter will stay. what if one of the two kids do not pan out? what if gore decides to walk or retire next year? no I think hunter will stay and resign . if this is a choice between keeping hunter or james for this coming year,,,,, well i think the clear answer is hunter
Sounds good to me. I think Hunter is a heck of a back. I would only suspect that Baalke will set his price, but that Hunter will elect to make more on the open market.
Not the end of the world.. and we'll see.
-
Scoots
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 2,580
Originally posted by Quest4six:
Lol 3 full seasons without missing games to injury, not to mention 3 consecutive 1000+ rushing yards per season....
Not to mention he is a niner, we don't treat 49er vets like that (especially gore)
Rice, Montana, Lott, and a long list of other stars were sent packing.
-
Jiks
- Member
-
- Posts: 29,220
Now that we have the talent, I could see us using Hunter to return kicks. Wonder why we got away from that? If my memory serves me correctly, he has fielded kicks and punts before. He's also a much better all around RB than LMJ IMO.
-
KowboyKiller
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 6,992
That'd be hilarious if Jewel Hampton became the feature back after all this hoopla with RBs we've had.
-
LifelongNiner
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 25,011
Originally posted by LVJay:
In LMJ's defense, he'll be better off on a team that doesn't have 27 RBs like we do.
49ers trade him to the Brownies (they'll do it for a 5th rounder, they're desperate for offensive play makers)... making life easier for Hoyer/Manziel.
I'm hoping it plays out like that. And if we can trade him for a 5th, even better. It's hard to believe there wouldn't be SOME interest in LaMichael James. Isn't Minnesota supposed to be looking for a back behind Adrian Peterson? Even though Peterson is the guy, James could get about 5 or so carries a game on a regular basis, which would be about 500% better than what he gets here. He also could also provide depth as a returner behind Cordarelle Patterson.
What's funny is that IF we do trade James and Gore retires this year, I can see us drafting ANOTHER running back next year (because I highly doubt Kendall Hunter will resign with us).