49ers vs. Vikings Tickets Available! →

There are 879 users in the forums

Running Back Situation

Shop Find 49ers gear online

Running Back Situation

Hunter is far better than James. Cut the guy who contributes less.
  • LVJay
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 27,847
Originally posted by Scoots:
I'll say it again here ... cut Gore now.

You keep saying that... I keep chuckling
You know.. i love both of them, and they are both underused. It almost seems to me that we keep speedy dynamic RB's on the roster just to keep other teams accountable for them in their game plans. Meaning they're a comodity, but we need really need them. It's too bad, because they both "ballers"
  • LVJay
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 27,847
Most likely, the Twitter guy... the writing is on the wall and on his (whiny) face
Member Milestone: This is post number 600 for tondiman.
Originally posted by WINiner:
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Have you guys seen our punt return team before LMJ? We have to solidify that before being so anxious to get rid of him.

James is nearly as stupid as Ginn when it comes to catching kicks. He is more consistent after he has the ball in hands, but I cringe when I see James run up on a ball, or side catch a ball, or hang too closely around a ball he has no intention of touching. I am not a fan and believe his value to our ST's is overstated. He is doing it in an effort to gain more touches in the run game. You can tell he is not passionate about it. You can tell that he is a bit begrudged by having to do it. LMJ wants to play regular downs. We have 4 guys right now that I would rather give playing time to on regular downs. LMJ is a cancer waiting to happen. He is going to be even more disgruntled with the addition of Hyde, who is a good pass pro as well, LMJ's krptonite.

I was really excited about the LMJ pick when it was made. I am not a fan of him remaining on the team just a few short years later. Dude is a bust. Entitled and doesn't seem to want to work for play time. Appears to want it given to him.

Do you think a rookie will be any better? I dunno, but to me it seems like a PR or KR should always be a veteran. Couldn't we have a professional punt and kick return "catcher" who then passes the ball off to LMJ or whoever else?
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,686
Originally posted by Scoots:
I'll say it again here ... cut Gore now.

What would be the benefit of that?? Not only has he been the workhorse for the 49ers at RB, he's been a team leader, a inspiration to the team, see Marcus Lattimore.


And I say this....EXTEND Gore now!!!

As far as LMJ or Hunter, I would choose Hunter. I think Hunter sees the field better than LMJ, and he's got more of a second gear, he doesn't dance a lot like LMJ. Plus I like Hunters on-field speed more, when Hunter hits the gaps, he turns on the jets.
Dear God...
I dont know
I dont know if anyone remembers a two years ago... but if you remember Gore and Hunter where unstoppable.
That year when we went to the superbowl... Our running team was a sight to see... Hunter was unbelievable... and letting him go to me would be big.
Originally posted by LVJay:
Originally posted by Scoots:
I'll say it again here ... cut Gore now.

You keep saying that... I keep chuckling


Lol 3 full seasons without missing games to injury, not to mention 3 consecutive 1000+ rushing yards per season....
Not to mention he is a niner, we don't treat 49er vets like that (especially gore)
  • DVDA
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 2,367
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by Scoots:
I'll say it again here ... cut Gore now.

What would be the benefit of that?? Not only has he been the workhorse for the 49ers at RB, he's been a team leader, a inspiration to the team, see Marcus Lattimore.


And I say this....EXTEND Gore now!!!

As far as LMJ or Hunter, I would choose Hunter. I think Hunter sees the field better than LMJ, and he's got more of a second gear, he doesn't dance a lot like LMJ. Plus I like Hunters on-field speed more, when Hunter hits the gaps, he turns on the jets.

You're insane, the dude is old and even slower than he was before. He's not worth the salary he's making right now.
Originally posted by WINiner:
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Have you guys seen our punt return team before LMJ? We have to solidify that before being so anxious to get rid of him.

James is nearly as stupid as Ginn when it comes to catching kicks. He is more consistent after he has the ball in hands, but I cringe when I see James run up on a ball, or side catch a ball, or hang too closely around a ball he has no intention of touching. I am not a fan and believe his value to our ST's is overstated.

This is how I feel as well. I have no confidence in him making a good decision, or fielding the punt cleanly. He is better on the kickoffs, but punts are another story.
Hunter isn't going anywhere. he'll be playing for us this season and beyond.

LMJ is a slug and I can't wait for Trent to unload him soon for a draft pick next season.
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,686
Originally posted by DVDA:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by Scoots:
I'll say it again here ... cut Gore now.

What would be the benefit of that?? Not only has he been the workhorse for the 49ers at RB, he's been a team leader, a inspiration to the team, see Marcus Lattimore.


And I say this....EXTEND Gore now!!!

As far as LMJ or Hunter, I would choose Hunter. I think Hunter sees the field better than LMJ, and he's got more of a second gear, he doesn't dance a lot like LMJ. Plus I like Hunters on-field speed more, when Hunter hits the gaps, he turns on the jets.

You're insane, the dude is old and even slower than he was before. He's not worth the salary he's making right now.

Well see if I'm insane when the time comes. "Slower than ever", that's a joke, not sure you know this, but not all RB's are burners, Kendall Hunter has 10x's the speed of Gore, you don't see him running away from everyone. "Slower than ever", he still managed 1100 yards with 9TD's 4.1 y/a, Marshawn Lynch 1252 yards with 12 TD's 4.2 y/a and Gore is 3 years older. Lynch averages 78 yards a game while Gore averages 70 yards per game, again Gore is 3 years older.
Originally posted by Scoots:
I'll say it again here ... cut Gore now.

Why would you want to cut our best player on O without one of the 4 other backs proven to carry the load??? To save $'s??? Do you honestly believe that a split up of carries for LMJ/Hunter/Hyde/Latt is guaranteed to work??? I understand taking a chance like that may prove to be good, but Gore has a little bit left in the tank, and I'd like to see if he does.

I'm not sold on a cut at this point. Let camp and pre-season play out before there are even thoughts of cutting a legend in the 9ers organization.
Originally posted by Bluesbro:
Originally posted by WINiner:
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Have you guys seen our punt return team before LMJ? We have to solidify that before being so anxious to get rid of him.

James is nearly as stupid as Ginn when it comes to catching kicks. He is more consistent after he has the ball in hands, but I cringe when I see James run up on a ball, or side catch a ball, or hang too closely around a ball he has no intention of touching. I am not a fan and believe his value to our ST's is overstated.

This is how I feel as well. I have no confidence in him making a good decision, or fielding the punt cleanly. He is better on the kickoffs, but punts are another story.

Agreed with all!!! I really hope LMJ isn't returning punts this year. He goes down too easy and is very questionable in decision making like Ginn was. He doesn't have the moves to make it much further in the NFL unless he is in HUGE open spaces.
  • KID9R
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 3,131
1. If Lattimore is healthy, Hunter should be traded not James.
2. Everyone notes how James is unhappy with his role. He should be. He's averaged just over one carry a game (39) since he's been here. Yet his avg. YPC is higher than Hunter's. The coaching staff has also failed to put him in positions to succeed by putting him in space, giving him extended carries and running screens etc. we don't even know what we have in him yet.
3. Hunter is a FA after this year and there's no way we're going re sign him.
4. No matter what RB we decide to trade it should be for a conditional pick based off of performance. That's the only way we're going to get remotely close value to the player because they're so underutilized here. If James went to the Saints for example, I could see him getting about 40+ catches. Or Hunter to the Jags, he could rush for over 1000 yards and easily beat out Toby Gerhart.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone