49ers vs. Seahawks Tickets Available! →

There are 903 users in the forums

Touchdown % by starting field position

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by Young2Rice:
Here is a good graphic showing how important good field position is to our team.

When we started in the opponent territory, we scored TDs 35% of the time. We relied too heavily on ST and Defense to set us up with good field position. Other then that, we could not sustain long drives (see third down conversion rate). We need to increase the 11%s to at least 20%-25%


The single biggest reason I predict an average season this year.
Originally posted by oldman9er:
Ugh.. Ginn drops a perfectly thrown TD pass at the end of the 2nd quarter. Had no timeouts left... another FG.

(alright, now I'm done)

I don't think you'll be done until you derail the thread.

What you are looking for is this:

http://www.49erswebzone.com/forum/niners/165846-official-alex-smith-thread/
Originally posted by Young2Rice:
Originally posted by oldman9er:
Ugh.. Ginn drops a perfectly thrown TD pass at the end of the 2nd quarter. Had no timeouts left... another FG.

(alright, now I'm done)

I don't think you'll be done until you derail the thread.

What you are looking for is this:

http://www.49erswebzone.com/forum/niners/165846-official-alex-smith-thread/

Funny, but no. I was pretty much going through the RZ failures, and may have elaborated a bit because I thought people liked to actually look at WHY we struggled in the RZ.. not just pointing to it and stupidly assessing blame. Don't like it? Don't care.
Originally posted by oldman9er:
Originally posted by Young2Rice:
Originally posted by oldman9er:
Ugh.. Ginn drops a perfectly thrown TD pass at the end of the 2nd quarter. Had no timeouts left... another FG.

(alright, now I'm done)

I don't think you'll be done until you derail the thread.

What you are looking for is this:

http://www.49erswebzone.com/forum/niners/165846-official-alex-smith-thread/

Funny, but no. I was pretty much going through the RZ failures, and may have elaborated a bit because I thought people liked to actually look at WHY we struggled in the RZ.. not just pointing to it and stupidly assessing blame. Don't like it? Don't care.

lol

"...going through the red zone failures." Don't you mean "going through the AZ game to show why Smith had nothing do with it." Why else would you talk about a deep bomb post that Ginn lost in the air? That's not a RZ assessment.


Look how you speak regarding Smith in the game:

"1st play? Yes... on Alex. Or was it? Can we say for sure? Alex threw the short pass to the pylon... Did Braylon run his route too deep? Or did Alex just miss him enough to where Braylon could only get one paw on it? Will we ever really know?"

"3rd play? Alex had 3 total targets... none were open, so he throws it out of bounds. What was he to do there? Not be careful and force the ball into obviously well covered receivers? Or give us a chance to jump up 6-0 on a Skelton-led Cardinals offense?"

"Next play, Alex gets 10 yds back on a pass... next play, converts on a nice Crabtree slant for the 1st."

"Alex slips... gets back up, dodges a sacker... and throws a bullet to Kyle to put us back in FG range..."

"Let us not forget that for FG # 1 to even be possible, Alex had to evade in the pocket and convert the 4th and 5 pass to begin with.. which he did."

"After that, Alex took one of those "short" sacks on a 3 step drop because no one picked up the free blitzing ILB."

"Then... another sack. We seemed to gear away from the pass, because it is clear that the pass pro is terrible so far in this game."

"beautiful pass to VD to get us into the RZ.."

"Ugh.. Ginn drops a perfectly thrown TD pass at the end of the 2nd quarter."

"Alex had 3 total targets... none were open, so he throws it out of bounds. What was he to do there? Not be careful and force the ball into obviously well covered receivers? Or give us a chance to jump up 6-0 on a Skelton-led Cardinals offense?"

Look how you s**t on the team:

"We seemed to gear away from the pass, because it is clear that the pass pro is terrible so far in this game. "

"Let us also remember that this was the game of the infamous Ted Ginn "wha? where ball? oh my" ... Ginn wide open on the deep post (Alex blasted in the back thanks to Iupati) and Ginn allows a perfect TD pass to drop at his feet... because he couldn't FIND the ball??????"

"2nd play? Gore loses a yd on the strong side.. no blocking.."

"Nick Eason goes right in between Iupati and Goodwin for an 8 yd sack? really OL? That's pathetic!"


"Gore then loses 3... now putting us on the short 38"


"then Crabtree alligator-arms a deep pass... the ball was two inches from Crabtree's hands, and yet... Crabtree NEVER left the ground to go up and get it. How bout that, huh? He's aware that he's allowed to get his feet off the ground and get the ball, right?"




Oh but you're right. You were just doing an "assessment" of our RZ failures instead of stupidly assigning blame to....well...i blamed the whole offense.



Originally posted by Young2Rice:

Oh but you're right. You were just doing an "assessment" of our RZ failures instead of stupidly assigning blame to....well...i blamed the whole offense.


I clearly stated that I elaborated on other stuff as I watched. Again, if you have a problem with that? I don't give a damn.

Anything else, or would you like to stay on point now to save your "remarkable" thread creation?
Originally posted by Young2Rice:
We at least have a reference point.

Using that old data Wookie posted, it looked like the best teams were 45%-50% on a short field. We need to be right around there to start winning comfortably as opposed to last minute wins. We were around 35% last year.

This shows just how many points were scored thanks to good field position created by ST and Def. I'm willing to bet that a VAST majority of our points came from short fields/


If the reference point is not the same season, is ten years old, I'm not sure it has value...unless we assume that offenses are fairly similar today. I prefer same year stats that include all teams so there is really a good way to break it down.

For instance--SF was terrible in 3rd down conversion, yet very good in 4th down conversion. What does that tell me? Well, I can assume that with the game on the line and Harbaugh putting the game in Smith hands out of necessity, he plays really well. But, on third down the team decides to play it safe and go with more runs because the game is not being decided by this one possession. But that would just be an assumption and it could be useful to compare with other QBs/teams for the year. Maybe all QBs do better on 4th down than on 3rd?

Anyway, I would really like to see the league stats on this before deciding if it is a relevant number(s).
Originally posted by oldman9er:
Originally posted by Young2Rice:

Oh but you're right. You were just doing an "assessment" of our RZ failures instead of stupidly assigning blame to....well...i blamed the whole offense.


I clearly stated that I elaborated on other stuff as I watched. Again, if you have a problem with that? I don't give a damn.

Anything else, or would you like to stay on point now to save your "remarkable" thread creation?

Thanks, I would like to stay.

You can go update your multiple "dropped passes threads."

[ Edited by Young2Rice on Jun 13, 2012 at 5:01 PM ]
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by Young2Rice:
We at least have a reference point.

Using that old data Wookie posted, it looked like the best teams were 45%-50% on a short field. We need to be right around there to start winning comfortably as opposed to last minute wins. We were around 35% last year.

This shows just how many points were scored thanks to good field position created by ST and Def. I'm willing to bet that a VAST majority of our points came from short fields/


If the reference point is not the same season, is ten years old, I'm not sure it has value...unless we assume that offenses are fairly similar today. I prefer same year stats that include all teams so there is really a good way to break it down.

For instance--SF was terrible in 3rd down conversion, yet very good in 4th down conversion. What does that tell me? Well, I can assume that with the game on the line and Harbaugh putting the game in Smith hands out of necessity, he plays really well. But, on third down the team decides to play it safe and go with more runs because the game is not being decided by this one possession. But that would just be an assumption and it could be useful to compare with other QBs/teams for the year. Maybe all QBs do better on 4th down than on 3rd?

Anyway, I would really like to see the league stats on this before deciding if it is a relevant number(s).

Yeah a 10 year old sheet isn't very good, but at least its somthing. If anything, those % have gone up since the new rules favor offense so much.

As for the 3rd down vs. 4th downs:

I think 4th downs usually means we are in a short yardage situation. So if its 4th and short or 4th and under 5 yards, we will go for it and odds are better that we make it. Whereas on third down, you HAVE to "go for it" and it was usually 3rd and long last year.

So we end up going for it on 3rd and 12 or 3rd and 15 and whereas we wouldn't go for it on 4th and 12. But we would go for it on 4th and short. Does that make sense?
Originally posted by Young2Rice:
Yeah a 10 year old sheet isn't very good, but at least its somthing. If anything, those % have gone up since the new rules favor offense so much.

As for the 3rd down vs. 4th downs:

I think 4th downs usually means we are in a short yardage situation. So if its 4th and short or 4th and under 5 yards, we will go for it and odds are better that we make it. Whereas on third down, you HAVE to "go for it" and it was usually 3rd and long last year.

So we end up going for it on 3rd and 12 or 3rd and 15 and whereas we wouldn't go for it on 4th and 12. But we would go for it on 4th and short. Does that make sense?


Yeah, that is definately one reason for the increased success when the ball is deep in the opponents end of the field, so it would be good to break down the difference in types of 4th down situations. I really need to retire so I can join a stat think tank for football! Everytime I look at one of these situations I come up with more problems/issues!
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by Young2Rice:
Yeah a 10 year old sheet isn't very good, but at least its somthing. If anything, those % have gone up since the new rules favor offense so much.

As for the 3rd down vs. 4th downs:

I think 4th downs usually means we are in a short yardage situation. So if its 4th and short or 4th and under 5 yards, we will go for it and odds are better that we make it. Whereas on third down, you HAVE to "go for it" and it was usually 3rd and long last year.

So we end up going for it on 3rd and 12 or 3rd and 15 and whereas we wouldn't go for it on 4th and 12. But we would go for it on 4th and short. Does that make sense?


Yeah, that is definately one reason for the increased success when the ball is deep in the opponents end of the field, so it would be good to break down the difference in types of 4th down situations. I really need to retire so I can join a stat think tank for football! Everytime I look at one of these situations I come up with more problems/issues!

Yeah there is a lot to it. The numbers are there, just not enough time in the day, even if i didn't have a job.
Originally posted by Young2Rice:
I'm assuming u are being sarcastic. Rewatch the AZ loss.

The 4 field goals was the reason we lost. Instead of touchdowns, we kept getting FGs after the defense and ST provided GOLD field position, often times in the AZ redzone.

Whats funny is one sequence of events totally changed the game around wouldn't have mattered if we scored TDs instead of FGs:

1. Fake 50 yard FG attempt gets called back to due to a VERY late whistle where whisenhunt made a challenge.
2. Whisenhunt was wrong on the challenge but the video equipment didn't work so the challenge wasn't allowed.
3. AZ saves a challenge and a timeout due to that move.
4. Niners lose the first down with the fake field goal and proceed to miss a 50 yard FG.
5. The next offensive play, Duccett scored a 50 yard bomb.

This unfortunate series of events would not matter with 2 more TDs in lieu of FGs.

wtf is that supposed to prove?

i forget did we miss the playoffs by 1 game?
did we miss #1 seed by 1 game?


as far im concerned that was worst game of seasson and that game had really no affect on outcome of season
  • dwett
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 712
Originally posted by oldman9er:
Originally posted by Young2Rice:
Originally posted by oldman9er:
Ugh.. Ginn drops a perfectly thrown TD pass at the end of the 2nd quarter. Had no timeouts left... another FG.

(alright, now I'm done)

I don't think you'll be done until you derail the thread.

What you are looking for is this:

http://www.49erswebzone.com/forum/niners/165846-official-alex-smith-thread/

Funny, but no. I was pretty much going through the RZ failures, and may have elaborated a bit because I thought people liked to actually look at WHY we struggled in the RZ.. not just pointing to it and stupidly assessing blame. Don't like it? Don't care.
Maybe I missed something but it seems Young2Rice is simply showing that a key aspect to our success next year will be our ability to take the field position that our great D gives us and convert TDs not FGs. He doesn't seem to be blaming just one person. This is on the entire offense.

The fact is out TOs were a huge key to our success last year but it will be hard to duplicate. So without it how do we continue to be successful. Bringing the D back was one, but improvement in our two big offensive flaws last year, IMO will be just as important. Along with 3rd down conversions our ability to score TDs not FGs, will be key.

Got to say the niners FO has noticed this and brought in a bigger back (Jacobs) and a big WR (Moss) to help with both those flaws from last year.
[ Edited by dwett on Jun 13, 2012 at 5:10 PM ]
Originally posted by 49ersalldaway126:
Originally posted by Young2Rice:
I'm assuming u are being sarcastic. Rewatch the AZ loss.

The 4 field goals was the reason we lost. Instead of touchdowns, we kept getting FGs after the defense and ST provided GOLD field position, often times in the AZ redzone.

Whats funny is one sequence of events totally changed the game around wouldn't have mattered if we scored TDs instead of FGs:

1. Fake 50 yard FG attempt gets called back to due to a VERY late whistle where whisenhunt made a challenge.
2. Whisenhunt was wrong on the challenge but the video equipment didn't work so the challenge wasn't allowed.
3. AZ saves a challenge and a timeout due to that move.
4. Niners lose the first down with the fake field goal and proceed to miss a 50 yard FG.
5. The next offensive play, Duccett scored a 50 yard bomb.

This unfortunate series of events would not matter with 2 more TDs in lieu of FGs.

wtf is that supposed to prove?

i forget did we miss the playoffs by 1 game?
did we miss #1 seed by 1 game?


as far im concerned that was worst game of seasson and that game had really no affect on outcome of season

It doesn't "prove" anything. It was intended to SHOW how too many fieldgoals instead of touchdowns can cost us games, which it did in the AZ game. A poster sarcastically remarked that points are points.

We had many chances in AZ territory and failed to punch it in and in the end we lost because of that. We could have lost many other games for the same reason. That ONE game also could have cost us home field advantage. 1 game is HUGE in this league.
Originally posted by dwett:
Maybe I missed something but it seems Young2Rice is simply showing that a key aspect to our success next year will be our ability to take the field position that our great D gives us and convert TDs not FGs. He doesn't seem to be blaming just one person. This is on the entire offense.

The fact is out TOs were a huge key to our success last year but it will be hard to duplicate. So without it how do we continue to be successful. Bringing the D back was one, but improvement in our two big offensive flaws last year, IMO will be just as important. Along with 3rd down conversions our ability to score TDs not FGs, will be key.

Got to say the niners FO has noticed this and brought in a bigger back (Jacobs) and a big WR (Moss) to help with both those flaws from last year.

Yeah.

Its on the whole offense. Our short yardage running game contributed to the failed RZ scores, OG pass protection and a lack of a play-making passing attack. And you're right, we did address some of the issues in the offseason with the additions of Moss, Manningham and Jacobs. We didn't get a reliable OG and are going to take a shot with Boone or Kilgore. I don't mind the risk, we just need to do better then 35% TD ratio when we get the ball in enemy territory.
Back when Steve Young was learning the WCO, I seem to remember the team struggling on third downs and red zone efficiency. Maybe that is part of the reason we struggled in those departments last year. There were quite a few "Singletarian" play calls on third down last year, I imagine that the play calling will be substantially more aggressive this season with the weapons we have brought in and a full off season to work on areas that need improvement. Nice choice of topics Young, very discussion worthy.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone