49ers vs. Seahawks Tickets Available! →

There are 626 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,695
Originally posted by Oakland-Niner:
We aren't talking careers, we are talking so far this season. There is a big difference, but impressive none the less.

Exactly what I'm talking about. So how do you overlook what hes done thru weeks 1-3?? And then call him a top 4 QB??
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
I won't give him that kind of praise yet, especially since he was inconsistent thru weeks 1-3. If he guides this team to a W this Sunday, then I'd give him some praise of a top 10 QB. As of right now, I'd list him in the #15--#10 category. Right now hes still getting comfortable with this offense and managing games well, plain and simple hes just doing his job.

He's doing a lot better than that. He's doing really well. But he can't win if Chilo lines up over Suh. Neither could Brady, Rivers, Manning, or Rodgers if Chilo was their RG lined up over Suh. He will have 8 sacks, 20 knockdowns and knock the 1st and 2nd string QB's out for the season.

Hes doing a lot better than what?? 15-10?? Wow nevermind hes been inconsistent thru weeks 1-3 and checking down 90% of the time, like I said, top 15-10 yah sure, top 4 absolutely not.

Tom Brady
Drew Brees
Aaron Rodgers
Ryan Fitzpatrick
Phillip Rivers
Matt Schaub
Matt Hasselbeck

No way top 4. If we had anyone one of those guys we would've been Preseason favorites of the NFC West from the get go.

7 TD's and 1 Int and 4 - 1.... I don't care if a guy throws for 5,000 yards and tons of picks. Not that impressive. Picks lose games for you. Not turning it over IS IMPRESSIVE. Especially with his past history. 3rd rated QB in the NFL.
  • Jcool
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 44,549
It should be an interesting negotiation.... Both the 49ers and Alex know he really cant go to another team and duplicate his success. So really the 49ers arent worried about him pulling the "ill leave" card. Hopefully they will just give him a fair offer.

Also the 49ers have to figure out if Harbaugh is the type of coach that can make any QB into a top level player, is he the next Andy Reid (McNabb, Vick)/Bill Belichick (Brady, Cassel) ? Do you let Alex Smith go and keep the more naturally skilled QB with more upside in Kaepernick and assume Harbaugh will turn him into a star, then use the money you would of spent on Alex on another position of need.
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
I won't give him that kind of praise yet, especially since he was inconsistent thru weeks 1-3. If he guides this team to a W this Sunday, then I'd give him some praise of a top 10 QB. As of right now, I'd list him in the #15--#10 category. Right now hes still getting comfortable with this offense and managing games well, plain and simple hes just doing his job.

He's doing a lot better than that. He's doing really well. But he can't win if Chilo lines up over Suh. Neither could Brady, Rivers, Manning, or Rodgers if Chilo was their RG lined up over Suh. He will have 8 sacks, 20 knockdowns and knock the 1st and 2nd string QB's out for the season.

Hes doing a lot better than what?? 15-10?? Wow nevermind hes been inconsistent thru weeks 1-3 and checking down 90% of the time, like I said, top 15-10 yah sure, top 4 absolutely not.

Tom Brady
Drew Brees
Aaron Rodgers
Ryan Fitzpatrick
Phillip Rivers
Matt Schaub
Matt Hasselbeck

No way top 4. If we harad anyone one of those guys we would've been Preseason favorites of the NFC West from the get go.

Are u following the NFL this year?

Rivers has more int than TD and in fact leads the NFL in int

Fitz ypa is a yard less than Alex ( and if u think Alex chrckdown watch him play although it's die to the system) and is inconstant as well

And schaub is having a huge down year and been inconsistent Look at raiders game


Also keep in mind Alex is the only one in a new system which is why first couple weeks he didn't have much yards but his ypa and yards have consistently in reaves with exception of the bengals game who fitz only had 198 yards 0tf against so Alex had the better game there

Btw how was Alex inconsistent first 3 weeks he had increase in yards ypa and attempts not to mention the first 3 games we had no run game and the o lime sucked so he had to won it himself
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Hes doing a lot better than what?? 15-10?? Wow nevermind hes been inconsistent thru weeks 1-3 and checking down 90% of the time, like I said, top 15-10 yah sure, top 4 absolutely not.

Tom Brady
Drew Brees
Aaron Rodgers
Ryan Fitzpatrick
Phillip Rivers
Matt Schaub
Matt Hasselbeck

No way top 4. If we had anyone one of those guys we would've been Preseason favorites of the NFC West from the get go.

Brady, Brees, Rodgers are inarguable aside from the order. Rivers hasn't been on his game this year, but I know his potential is greater than Alex's. Still, six TDs to 7 INTs when he has way better weapons is a little suspect. Schaub is overrated as s**t - he's run-of-the-mill without Andre Johnson. Hasselbeck is playing out of his mind, but even he has come down to Earth last week. And Alex has less INTs and played harder competition thus far - of course Hasselbeck (or any QB) would have multi-TD games against the Browns and Broncos.
[ Edited by 12b6demurrer on Oct 12, 2011 at 9:59 PM ]
  • boast
  • Hella Fame
  • Posts: 157,047
Originally posted by GNielsen:
Kurt Warner made life miserable for Niner fans, but that's no reason to hate him. If he was a Niner, you'd love him. He's going to the HOF whether you like him or not. And, I'm grateful that he's acknowledging Alex Smith's revival.

f**k Kurt Warner!
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,695
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
I won't give him that kind of praise yet, especially since he was inconsistent thru weeks 1-3. If he guides this team to a W this Sunday, then I'd give him some praise of a top 10 QB. As of right now, I'd list him in the #15--#10 category. Right now hes still getting comfortable with this offense and managing games well, plain and simple hes just doing his job.

He's doing a lot better than that. He's doing really well. But he can't win if Chilo lines up over Suh. Neither could Brady, Rivers, Manning, or Rodgers if Chilo was their RG lined up over Suh. He will have 8 sacks, 20 knockdowns and knock the 1st and 2nd string QB's out for the season.

Hes doing a lot better than what?? 15-10?? Wow nevermind hes been inconsistent thru weeks 1-3 and checking down 90% of the time, like I said, top 15-10 yah sure, top 4 absolutely not.

Tom Brady
Drew Brees
Aaron Rodgers
Ryan Fitzpatrick
Phillip Rivers
Matt Schaub
Matt Hasselbeck

No way top 4. If we had anyone one of those guys we would've been Preseason favorites of the NFC West from the get go.

7 TD's and 1 Int and 4 - 1.... I don't care if a guy throws for 5,000 yards and tons of picks. Not that impressive. Picks lose games for you. Not turning it over IS IMPRESSIVE. Especially with his past history. 3rd rated QB in the NFL.

Impressive yes, no denying that, checking down and playing it safe will do that for you. It also helps when you have the 13th rank defense, try playing it safe with a 32nd rank defense who can't stop the run or the pass.

I'm just saying, its good to see Smith getting praise for what hes accomplished this year, but lets not let our biasness blind us.
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by Oakland-Niner:
We aren't talking careers, we are talking so far this season. There is a big difference, but impressive none the less.

Exactly what I'm talking about. So how do you overlook what hes done thru weeks 1-3?? And then call him a top 4 QB??

Honestly? I doubt Warner even watched an SF game prior to the second half of the Eagles come back. Chances are he looked at a stat sheet, reviewed some very recent film (last 6 quarters) and made his decision. I agree with your week 1-3 analysis, but I think people are willing to give him a pass because of the lockout, we are winning and in contrast, the new Alex looks like a HOFer compared to the old Alex.
[ Edited by Oakland-Niner on Oct 12, 2011 at 10:04 PM ]
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,695
Originally posted by 49ersalldaway126:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
I won't give him that kind of praise yet, especially since he was inconsistent thru weeks 1-3. If he guides this team to a W this Sunday, then I'd give him some praise of a top 10 QB. As of right now, I'd list him in the #15--#10 category. Right now hes still getting comfortable with this offense and managing games well, plain and simple hes just doing his job.

He's doing a lot better than that. He's doing really well. But he can't win if Chilo lines up over Suh. Neither could Brady, Rivers, Manning, or Rodgers if Chilo was their RG lined up over Suh. He will have 8 sacks, 20 knockdowns and knock the 1st and 2nd string QB's out for the season.

Hes doing a lot better than what?? 15-10?? Wow nevermind hes been inconsistent thru weeks 1-3 and checking down 90% of the time, like I said, top 15-10 yah sure, top 4 absolutely not.

Tom Brady
Drew Brees
Aaron Rodgers
Ryan Fitzpatrick
Phillip Rivers
Matt Schaub
Matt Hasselbeck

No way top 4. If we harad anyone one of those guys we would've been Preseason favorites of the NFC West from the get go.

Are u following the NFL this year?

Rivers has more int than TD and in fact leads the NFL in int

Fitz ypa is a yard less than Alex ( and if u think Alex chrckdown watch him play although it's die to the system) and is inconstant as well

And schaub is having a huge down year and been inconsistent Look at raiders game


Also keep in mind Alex is the only one in a new system which is why first couple weeks he didn't have much yards but his ypa and yards have consistently in reaves with exception of the bengals game who fitz only had 198 yards 0tf against so Alex had the better game there

Btw how was Alex inconsistent first 3 weeks he had increase in yards ypa and attempts not to mention the first 3 games we had no run game and the o lime sucked so he had to won it himself

Watch him play you say...LOL. Your bias speaks for you. Smith has the least YPG out of all the QB's mentioned with 193 yards. Sure the above mentioned have more INT's than Smith, they also have been in the same system longer and aren't afraid to wing it.

I mean you guys act like I'm saying Smith sucks, its silly how some of you CAN'T agree....but since hes playing lights out disregard weeks 1-3 right.

BTW Smith ranks as 26th in passing right now.

Att/G 25.2 second lowest out of all QB that started weeks 1-5.
[ Edited by Kolohe on Oct 12, 2011 at 10:11 PM ]
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by 49ersalldaway126:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
I won't give him that kind of praise yet, especially since he was inconsistent thru weeks 1-3. If he guides this team to a W this Sunday, then I'd give him some praise of a top 10 QB. As of right now, I'd list him in the #15--#10 category. Right now hes still getting comfortable with this offense and managing games well, plain and simple hes just doing his job.

He's doing a lot better than that. He's doing really well. But he can't win if Chilo lines up over Suh. Neither could Brady, Rivers, Manning, or Rodgers if Chilo was their RG lined up over Suh. He will have 8 sacks, 20 knockdowns and knock the 1st and 2nd string QB's out for the season.

Hes doing a lot better than what?? 15-10?? Wow nevermind hes been inconsistent thru weeks 1-3 and checking down 90% of the time, like I said, top 15-10 yah sure, top 4 absolutely not.

Tom Brady
Drew Brees
Aaron Rodgers
Ryan Fitzpatrick
Phillip Rivers
Matt Schaub
Matt Hasselbeck

No way top 4. If we harad anyone one of those guys we would've been Preseason favorites of the NFC West from the get go.

Are u following the NFL this year?

Rivers has more int than TD and in fact leads the NFL in int

Fitz ypa is a yard less than Alex ( and if u think Alex chrckdown watch him play although it's die to the system) and is inconstant as well

And schaub is having a huge down year and been inconsistent Look at raiders game


Also keep in mind Alex is the only one in a new system which is why first couple weeks he didn't have much yards but his ypa and yards have consistently in reaves with exception of the bengals game who fitz only had 198 yards 0tf against so Alex had the better game there

Btw how was Alex inconsistent first 3 weeks he had increase in yards ypa and attempts not to mention the first 3 games we had no run game and the o lime sucked so he had to won it himself

Watch him play you say...LOL. Your bias speaks for you. Smith has the least YPG out of all the QB's mentioned with 193 yards. Sure the above mentioned have more INT's than Smith, they also have been in the same system longer and aren't afraid to wing it.

I mean you guys act like I'm saying Smith sucks, its silly how some of you CAN'T agree....but since hes playing lights out disregard weeks 1-3 right.

BTW Smith ranks as 26th in passing right now.

Att/G 25.2 second lowest out of all QB that started weeks 1-5.

Guys who "wing it" and throw tons of picks lose games. 5,000 yards and tons of picks = worthless.....
  • dj43
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 38,633
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
I won't give him that kind of praise yet, especially since he was inconsistent thru weeks 1-3. If he guides this team to a W this Sunday, then I'd give him some praise of a top 10 QB. As of right now, I'd list him in the #15--#10 category. Right now hes still getting comfortable with this offense and managing games well, plain and simple hes just doing his job.

He's doing a lot better than that. He's doing really well. But he can't win if Chilo lines up over Suh. Neither could Brady, Rivers, Manning, or Rodgers if Chilo was their RG lined up over Suh. He will have 8 sacks, 20 knockdowns and knock the 1st and 2nd string QB's out for the season.

True, but Suh is not the only guy on that DL that can rush the passer. They have 6 guys that can bring it and 3 more to rest.
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Watch him play you say...LOL. Your bias speaks for you. Smith has the least YPG out of all the QB's mentioned with 193 yards. Sure the above mentioned have more INT's than Smith, they also have been in the same system longer and aren't afraid to wing it.

I mean you guys act like I'm saying Smith sucks, its silly how some of you CAN'T agree....but since hes playing lights out disregard weeks 1-3 right.

BTW Smith ranks as 26th in passing right now.

Att/G 25.2 second lowest out of all QB that started weeks 1-5.

Yes, his yards are low. This can be contributed to having the 12th best rushing offense, the 2nd best average field position on kickoffs, and the 2nd best average for punt return yardage.
Originally posted by 12b6demurrer:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Watch him play you say...LOL. Your bias speaks for you. Smith has the least YPG out of all the QB's mentioned with 193 yards. Sure the above mentioned have more INT's than Smith, they also have been in the same system longer and aren't afraid to wing it.

I mean you guys act like I'm saying Smith sucks, its silly how some of you CAN'T agree....but since hes playing lights out disregard weeks 1-3 right.

BTW Smith ranks as 26th in passing right now.

Att/G 25.2 second lowest out of all QB that started weeks 1-5.

Yes, his yards are low. This can be contributed to having the 12th best rushing offense, the 2nd best average field position on kickoffs, and the 2nd best average for punt return yardage.

This also let's bot forget this is his first year in WCO

No qb in first year as WCO averages more than 230 yards a game

Beat example is Brett acre 2006 he just ame of 4000 yards and 30 TDS first year in WCO he averages 220 yards a game while only having 17tds and he had a full offseason and a number 1 WR who wasn't injured
Originally posted by 12b6demurrer:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Watch him play you say...LOL. Your bias speaks for you. Smith has the least YPG out of all the QB's mentioned with 193 yards. Sure the above mentioned have more INT's than Smith, they also have been in the same system longer and aren't afraid to wing it.

I mean you guys act like I'm saying Smith sucks, its silly how some of you CAN'T agree....but since hes playing lights out disregard weeks 1-3 right.

BTW Smith ranks as 26th in passing right now.

Att/G 25.2 second lowest out of all QB that started weeks 1-5.

Yes, his yards are low. This can be contributed to having the 12th best rushing offense, the 2nd best average field position on kickoffs, and the 2nd best average for punt return yardage.

Or

The more resonable assumption based on 7 years of data; He just doesn't pass the ball often or far.
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,695
Originally posted by 12b6demurrer:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Watch him play you say...LOL. Your bias speaks for you. Smith has the least YPG out of all the QB's mentioned with 193 yards. Sure the above mentioned have more INT's than Smith, they also have been in the same system longer and aren't afraid to wing it.

I mean you guys act like I'm saying Smith sucks, its silly how some of you CAN'T agree....but since hes playing lights out disregard weeks 1-3 right.

BTW Smith ranks as 26th in passing right now.

Att/G 25.2 second lowest out of all QB that started weeks 1-5.

Yes, his yards are low. This can be contributed to having the 12th best rushing offense, the 2nd best average field position on kickoffs, and the 2nd best average for punt return yardage.

Our rushing offense was ranked nowhere near 12th during weeks 1-3. 2nd best PR yardage, not in Cincy or against Dallas we didn't.

But not just yardage, pass attempted per game compared to the above mentioned who pass it 30+ times a game. Sure your passing numbers are gonna look great if you check down and don't pass as much, only 16 attempts of 20+ yards, 1 attempt of 40+.

Again, I'm gonna keep repeating this, you guys are acting as if I'm saying Smith sucks.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone