Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 748 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Kurt Warner made life miserable for Niner fans, but that's no reason to hate him. If he was a Niner, you'd love him. He's going to the HOF whether you like him or not. And, I'm grateful that he's acknowledging Alex Smith's revival.
It's nice to see Alex finally stepping up and finally getting some recognition around the league and most of all amongst the fans.
Kurt only meant Alex was the 4th best 5 weeks into the season. Lets not get carried away.
This is getting out of hand. Alex has had a decent season but everybody is riding his nuts way too hard. What are they gonna say if he has a bad game against the Lions?
Originally posted by susweel:
Meh what does Kurt Warner know about good QBs.

LOL. Wow just wow.
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,695
I won't give him that kind of praise yet, especially since he was inconsistent thru weeks 1-3. If he guides this team to a W this Sunday, then I'd give him some praise of a top 10 QB. As of right now, I'd list him in the #15--#10 category. Right now hes still getting comfortable with this offense and managing games well, plain and simple hes just doing his job.
  • Antix
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 9,984
Originally posted by PatrickWillisHOF:
This is getting out of hand. Alex has had a decent season but everybody is riding his nuts way too hard. What are they gonna say if he has a bad game against the Lions?

They will hate him again.
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Originally posted by susweel:
Meh what does Kurt Warner know about good QBs.

LOL. Wow just wow.

Originally posted by Kolohe:
I won't give him that kind of praise yet, especially since he was inconsistent thru weeks 1-3. If he guides this team to a W this Sunday, then I'd give him some praise of a top 10 QB. As of right now, I'd list him in the #15--#10 category. Right now hes still getting comfortable with this offense and managing games well, plain and simple hes just doing his job.

He's doing a lot better than that. He's doing really well. But he can't win if Chilo lines up over Suh. Neither could Brady, Rivers, Manning, or Rodgers if Chilo was their RG lined up over Suh. He will have 8 sacks, 20 knockdowns and knock the 1st and 2nd string QB's out for the season.
If Harbaugh thinks he can win a Superbowl with Alex, then I would say to sign him longterm. NFL contracts are not guaranteed 100% and we have Colin under contract for 4 years, 3 after this season. Aaron Rogers sat a few years behind Favre and turned out OK. We are 10 mil under the cap, and have the ability. I think Alex Smith will be happy to sign a 3 year, 22-28 mil deal and stay here and change his legacy.
We aren't talking careers, we are talking so far this season. There is a big difference, but impressive none the less.
Originally posted by tjd808185:
If Alex would accept that deal it should happen tomorrow.

If the deal is tomorrow, then I'd say that $8 million/year is a tad much, because he has only had a few good games, and the 49ers would take bigger risk making a long-term commitment to him. It'd be a very different story if he could perform well for the large majority of games for the rest of the season (the scenario in my earlier posts.) I'd venture that the time to draw up the extension paperwork is somewhere between games 10 and 13, once Smith has firmly established a clear, consistent streak. His value would jump sharply if Smith wins a playoff game.
Originally posted by Oakland-Niner:
We aren't talking careers, we are talking so far this season. There is a big difference, but impressive none the less.

If we are talking just this season I think he has a point. People get caught up in their past evaluation of Alex (WZers and media and fans). But if you look at him this year and this year alone he is playing really well. Better than the "average" people claim. People claim that because they don't want to get let down based on the past and what they think will happen.
If ( and looks like when ) we make the playoffs he should be extended regardless if we win or not new state
Limited offseason injuries to WR and yet is top 3 in passer rating

Not to mention when we go to the playoffs it will be the first year for almost everyone typically teams like that don't afvance
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,695
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
I won't give him that kind of praise yet, especially since he was inconsistent thru weeks 1-3. If he guides this team to a W this Sunday, then I'd give him some praise of a top 10 QB. As of right now, I'd list him in the #15--#10 category. Right now hes still getting comfortable with this offense and managing games well, plain and simple hes just doing his job.

He's doing a lot better than that. He's doing really well. But he can't win if Chilo lines up over Suh. Neither could Brady, Rivers, Manning, or Rodgers if Chilo was their RG lined up over Suh. He will have 8 sacks, 20 knockdowns and knock the 1st and 2nd string QB's out for the season.

Hes doing a lot better than what?? 15-10?? Wow nevermind hes been inconsistent thru weeks 1-3 and checking down 90% of the time, like I said, top 15-10 yah sure, top 4 absolutely not.

Tom Brady
Drew Brees
Aaron Rodgers
Ryan Fitzpatrick
Phillip Rivers
Matt Schaub
Matt Hasselbeck

No way top 4. If we had anyone one of those guys we would've been Preseason favorites of the NFC West from the get go.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone