Player Evaluation 2011

Young, Wusweel ad Natral, just save your breath. Your careers as schoolyard bullies ended when you were kicked out of school. It doesn't work here ... just move on.

Originally posted by Young2Rice:

Originally posted by susweel:

Originally posted by excelsior:
Getting tired of Alex Smith comments, then please indulge me this:

I looked at Alex playing against NO, PHIL, and OAK, which are the 2nd, 13th, and 4th ranked teams in pass defense this year, respectively. Alex's average non-weighted QB rating against these teams is 87.4. There are 27 QBs who have also played against these three teams this year, and their non-weighted QB ratings average 78.7.

Therefore, it shows that despite the handicaps of dealing with Sing, OC, OL and receiver issues, Alex still averaged playing better against these teams that are tough to pass against than the other QBs who played them this year.

This is why I contend that Alex is not trash; he can be a very decent QB if he played on a team that supported him to the degree that most of the other good QBs in this league enjoy.

yah............right...............

hhaha yeah he'd be better if he were on a better team. thats Rich...

Gannon

Originally posted by excelsior:
Young, Wusweel ad Natral, just save your breath. Your careers as schoolyard bullies ended when you were kicked out of school. It doesn't work here ... just move on.

That's a personal insult calling me wusweel. You should get a nice warning for that.

That kind of behavior is completely uncalled for.

Originally posted by excelsior:
Getting tired of Alex Smith comments, then please indulge me this:

I looked at Alex playing against NO, PHIL, and OAK, which are the 2nd, 13th, and 4th ranked teams in pass defense this year, respectively. Alex's average non-weighted QB rating against these teams is 87.4. There are 27 QBs who have also played against these three teams this year, and their non-weighted QB ratings average 78.7.

Therefore, it shows that despite the handicaps of dealing with Sing, OC, OL and receiver issues, Alex still averaged playing better against these teams that are tough to pass against than the other QBs who played them this year.

This is why I contend that Alex is not trash; he can be a very decent QB if he played on a team that supported him to the degree that most of the other good QBs in this league enjoy.

Originally posted by fly15:
Morgan needs to go

I'm afraid you're right. I really like the guy. He's just as mean, every bit the teamplayer as, and is as good a blocker (upfield and at the line) as John Taylor, he even has the "hard" soft hands that Taylor had, but he's a couple steps too slow. It's a damned shame: right mind, wrong body.

Quite the contrast to Mr. Ginn, a guy that should stay because he can--if nothing else, and that's a very big nothing--hang onto the ball on kicks and punts. The NFL is brutal.

Originally posted by susweel:

Originally posted by excelsior:
Young, Wusweel ad Natral, just save your breath. Your careers as schoolyard bullies ended when you were kicked out of school. It doesn't work here ... just move on.

That's a personal insult calling me wusweel. You should get a nice warning for that.

That kind of behavior is completely uncalled for.

Gee, it looks like my finger missed a key. You are always so kind and courteous, especially gracious toward your favorite player, Alex. It would be terribly uncalled for to insult you, even if it were inadvertant.

Originally posted by AB83Rules:
guys who will be here in 2011.

Willis
VD
Gore
J.Smith
Iupati
Staley
A.Davis
Sopoaga (Rather see him gone)
Dixon
Byham
Mays
Bowman
Spikes
Wragge
RJF
Crabtree
Morgan
Ginn
K.Williams
Adams
Spencer
R.Smith
Delanie
Boone
Gibson

On the fence;

Baas
T.Smith
Taylor
Nate
Lawson
Brown
Evans

Need to Go;

Franklin
Goldson
Norris
Parys
Alex
Carr
Snyder
Rachal
Sims

I agree except we should keep Goldson and drop Ginn (keep as a returner maybe but not as a WR). Others like Franklin, Parys, Lawson are based on money.

Absolute #1 priority being to cut A.Smith and Carr. Need to move on.

[ Edited by confusedrhino on Nov 24, 2010 at 20:18:29 ]

p.will beasgt
gore beast
bass beast
.j.smith beas
t.apikes beseat

Players I freakin hate:

Parys Haralson
Chilo Rachal
Josh Morgan

good dudes, crap players.... freakin overrated... bench players at best for rest of the NFL teams.

p,woklly boss
gore boss
clemeonet boss
mays boss
spencer boss
bass boss
heoitman boss
davis boss

Troy Smith (hoping he remains)
Nate Davis
Frank Gore- hopefully he is extended.
Anthony Dixon- needs to see the field more. RB is one of the positions where a player can come in a make immediate imapct. I don't understand not playing rookie RBs.
Josh Morgan- I like him. He just isn't a starter.
Michael Crabtree
Vernon Davis
Delanie Walker
Staley
Lupati
Baas
Davis
Snyder
Boone- Why hasn't he received any PT?
Sims
Zeigler
Williams
Byham- Moran Norris' replacement?

Sopoaga- How would he fair as a 4-3 DT?
McDonald- Needs to be extended
Franklin- See Sopoaga
Francois- See Sopoaga
Justin Smith
Manny Lawson- extended
Ahmad Brooks
Spikes
Bowman- should've been eased into action and not thrown in.
Willis- OLB in a 4-3?
Spencer
Clements- has to have that contract redone
Mays- Should've been eased in. Critics and fans alike have said he wasn't ready since he was at SC.
Reggie Smith
Tarrell Brown
Parys Haralson- 4-3 DE?

Originally posted by excelsior:
Gee, it looks like my finger missed a key. You are always so kind and courteous, especially gracious toward your favorite player, Alex. It would be terribly uncalled for to insult you, even if it were inadvertant.

The W & S are close on the keyboard, but I think only the OJ jury would let you believe it was an accident.

We are getting a new Head Coach and possibly a new GM this off season.

There may be some 'keepers' who end up being traded and others who are released or allowed to walk because they don't fit into the new Offense, Defense or future plans of the GM or Coach.

Barring trades, I see these guys as locks for next years squad:

Willis
Iupati
Crabtree
Andy Lee
Justin Smith
Anthony Davis
Vernon Davis
Gore
Staley
Brian Jennings
Mays - Excellent special teams guy with top level potential at Safety
Athony Dixon - Excellent special teams guy with top level potential at RB
Kyle Williams - PR/KR guy next year with potential at WR
Nate Byham - Value and potential at TE/H-Back

Troy smith sucks
David carr sucks
moran Norris sucks
Josh Morgan sucks
whole OL. Sucks
haralson & bowman suck
whole secondary sucks