Just be honest, did you chant for Carr?

Originally posted by BETTERDAYZ9ERS:
No it was just a joke to piss off all the Smith supporters

you sure showed them.

Originally posted by FourNine49:

Originally posted by 9erred:

Originally posted by brucesf49:

Originally posted by 9erred:
I chanted for Carr during the Raiders game. I have been very vocal that I think Alex Smith is not a leader, cannot read defenses, and overall has had more chances than any other qb in the NFL. I think Smith SUCKS, Sucks, Sucks, I would rather cut smith today, promote Nate Davis and have Carr, Troy Smith and Davis as the QB's. They certainly could do no worse than Smith has over the past 6 years.

Smith rolls right, throws out of bounds, Smith panics and dumps it off to the rb. Heck yes I want Carr. Any qb who will at least push the ball down the field.

did you not see carr horribly underthrowing intermediate routes? how does that push the ball down the field? Carr is less than Smith, as sad as that is its the truth. i would rather an injured smith play than carr. Nate Davis? i would back that experiment for a game or two while smith lets his shoulder heal a little but it is obvious we DO NOT have any talent at qb on this team that is better than Smith.

I DISAGREE, I would rather cut Smith now, he has lost the team and the fans. Is Carr, Troy Smith or Nate Davis the answer, we will find out over the remaining 9 games. They can do NO WORSE than than Smith has over the past 6 seasons.

I actually think Nate Davis and Troy Smith have more talent than Smith and Carr. They can at least keep the play alive because they have more mobility, whereas Smith and Carr are sitting ducks.

And that's why you are a fan just like the rest of us, and not a coach

I

I don't have the Link, but I did read somewhere that John Madden was more high on Nate Davis as a qb than Alex Smith. He bluntly said that Smith simply is not that good in game situations. I do not have the link, so take it for what its worth. But I stand behind what an ex NFL coach, broadcaster, and someone who has forgotten more football than any webzoner will know.

Smith is not the answer. Simply put.

Originally posted by TexasNiner84:

Originally posted by susweel:
Lets give Carr a chance before we right him off. Lets let him start for a 5 or 6 years first and give him a chance.

This is going to be his 9th year in the league

Yah but this is a new system for him.

no, i was at the eagles game and was telling everyone around me that no matter how bad smith is doing right now, carr would be that much worse

Originally posted by 9erred:

Originally posted by FourNine49:

Originally posted by 9erred:

Originally posted by brucesf49:

Originally posted by 9erred:
I chanted for Carr during the Raiders game. I have been very vocal that I think Alex Smith is not a leader, cannot read defenses, and overall has had more chances than any other qb in the NFL. I think Smith SUCKS, Sucks, Sucks, I would rather cut smith today, promote Nate Davis and have Carr, Troy Smith and Davis as the QB's. They certainly could do no worse than Smith has over the past 6 years.

Smith rolls right, throws out of bounds, Smith panics and dumps it off to the rb. Heck yes I want Carr. Any qb who will at least push the ball down the field.

did you not see carr horribly underthrowing intermediate routes? how does that push the ball down the field? Carr is less than Smith, as sad as that is its the truth. i would rather an injured smith play than carr. Nate Davis? i would back that experiment for a game or two while smith lets his shoulder heal a little but it is obvious we DO NOT have any talent at qb on this team that is better than Smith.

I DISAGREE, I would rather cut Smith now, he has lost the team and the fans. Is Carr, Troy Smith or Nate Davis the answer, we will find out over the remaining 9 games. They can do NO WORSE than than Smith has over the past 6 seasons.

I actually think Nate Davis and Troy Smith have more talent than Smith and Carr. They can at least keep the play alive because they have more mobility, whereas Smith and Carr are sitting ducks.

And that's why you are a fan just like the rest of us, and not a coach

I

I don't have the Link, but I did read somewhere that John Madden was more high on Nate Davis as a qb than Alex Smith. He bluntly said that Smith simply is not that good in game situations. I do not have the link, so take it for what its worth. But I stand behind what an ex NFL coach, broadcaster, and someone who has forgotten more football than any webzoner will know.

Smith is not the answer. Simply put.

I agree with you, Smith is not the answer. But at this point, NO ONE is the answer. All of the QBs on the roster will NOT make this team better.

Who's this Carr that you chant for?

No and Troy will take his job...

I was actually screaming "Taxi", not Carr.

HELL f* NO

the only other qb i would have been ok with coming in was Nate Davis if they ever activate him.

Originally posted by BETTERDAYZ9ERS:
Who's this Carr that you chant for?

No, no, no. It's all a misunderstanding. Someone saw Opra and started chanting "we want a car"...

Originally posted by susweel:

Originally posted by TexasNiner84:

Originally posted by susweel:
Lets give Carr a chance before we right him off. Lets let him start for a 5 or 6 years first and give him a chance.

This is going to be his 9th year in the league

Yah but this is a new system for him.

Thats great. But we both know if alex played against the texans the way carr played sunday, we wouldn't even be talking about either of them. They both suck, but carr sucks just a little bit more

Originally posted by GhostofFredDean74:
No, but anyone chanting for Carr wasn't doing so because they actually thought he could do better. They just wanted to see anyone but Smith behind center.

EXACTLY!!!

Originally posted by susweel:

Originally posted by TexasNiner84:

Originally posted by susweel:
Lets give Carr a chance before we right him off. Lets let him start for a 5 or 6 years first and give him a chance.

This is going to be his 9th year in the league

Yah but this is a new system for him.

No doubt, and how many coordinators has he been through. He just needs a little consistancy. We should lock him up long term right away...

Originally posted by 9erred:

Originally posted by FourNine49:

Originally posted by 9erred:

Originally posted by brucesf49:

Originally posted by 9erred:
I chanted for Carr during the Raiders game. I have been very vocal that I think Alex Smith is not a leader, cannot read defenses, and overall has had more chances than any other qb in the NFL. I think Smith SUCKS, Sucks, Sucks, I would rather cut smith today, promote Nate Davis and have Carr, Troy Smith and Davis as the QB's. They certainly could do no worse than Smith has over the past 6 years.

Smith rolls right, throws out of bounds, Smith panics and dumps it off to the rb. Heck yes I want Carr. Any qb who will at least push the ball down the field.

did you not see carr horribly underthrowing intermediate routes? how does that push the ball down the field? Carr is less than Smith, as sad as that is its the truth. i would rather an injured smith play than carr. Nate Davis? i would back that experiment for a game or two while smith lets his shoulder heal a little but it is obvious we DO NOT have any talent at qb on this team that is better than Smith.

I DISAGREE, I would rather cut Smith now, he has lost the team and the fans. Is Carr, Troy Smith or Nate Davis the answer, we will find out over the remaining 9 games. They can do NO WORSE than than Smith has over the past 6 seasons.

I actually think Nate Davis and Troy Smith have more talent than Smith and Carr. They can at least keep the play alive because they have more mobility, whereas Smith and Carr are sitting ducks.

And that's why you are a fan just like the rest of us, and not a coach

I

I don't have the Link, but I did read somewhere that John Madden was more high on Nate Davis as a qb than Alex Smith. He bluntly said that Smith simply is not that good in game situations. I do not have the link, so take it for what its worth. But I stand behind what an ex NFL coach, broadcaster, and someone who has forgotten more football than any webzoner will know.

Smith is not the answer. Simply put.

This is a quote from a Lowell Cohn article last year:
------------------------------------
"Before I get into what the Niners are doing right with Davis, I want
to explain why it matters. Davis is potentially the best quarterback
on the 49ers. That's the living, breathing truth. He has a stronger
arm than Shaun Hill or Smith, he has a better athletic body and he
moves better. He's just better.

Sure, he's green and has a ton to learn and isn't anywhere near ready.
We're talking potential here, what football people on Draft Day call
"upside." (Don't you just hate the word "upside"?)

On KCBS Wednesday morning, John Madden said Davis can make throws Hill
and Smith can't dream of completing - specifically, the long throw to
the sideline that Joe Montana and Steve Young specialized in. Madden
also said Davis makes all the throws."

Originally posted by GhostofFredDean74:
No, but anyone chanting for Carr wasn't doing so because they actually thought he could do better. They just wanted to see anyone but Smith behind center.

That is just stupid though, Smith is obviously the best QB on the roster, like him or not. Something has to be done about the piss poor oline play before the QB even matters with this team.