49ers vs. Seahawks Tickets Available! →

There are 818 users in the forums

Two QB's?

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by ninerfan818:
LOL cut Nate. Smith gets 6 years and Davis one to prove himself. This is:

B.A.L.O.G.N.E.Y.

Motivation tactic.
Originally posted by 49erRider:
Originally posted by HessianDud:
why do people want to bring in Leinart? That guy is a joke.

Because he's no more of a joke than David Carr.

Actually, Leinart >>>> Carr

i would rather have a guy who has been training with the team and learning the playbook throughout the summer, who has been humbled and knows his role on the team, than a petulant whiny brat who can't succeed after learning from a borderline HOF QB and throwing to the best WR in the game.
Originally posted by ninerfan818:
LOL cut Nate. Smith gets 6 years and Davis one to prove himself. This is:

B.A.L.O.G.N.E.Y.

well alex didnt suck against 3rd stringers
Originally posted by SnakePlissken:
I say cut Nate Davis and sign Matt Leinart to the #2 spot. Matt has everything you need in a #2, cautious check-downs and steller #2 QB mediocrity to win a couple of games (and it will come at a cheap price).

I'd rather keep Nate. If Lienart can't cut it on a team with a good receiving core and good offensive system, I don't think he can do anything for us.
Originally posted by ninerfan818:
LOL cut Nate. Smith gets 6 years and Davis one to prove himself. This is:

B.A.L.O.G.N.E.Y.

C'mon now, you know that it's about contracts. Smith's was big due to being 1st round pick.

Nate's was small due to 6th round pick.

You're a GM which do YOU think that your owner is more willing to absorb when you make the cut?

No way 31 other GMs' cut Smith either. And has been pointed out it's not likely that 31 other GMs' go after him if he can't learn the playbook in 2 years. About the only way I see this happening is if a team loses ALL their QBs' in a day(stranger things have happened we lost 3 in a day) and don't expect him to throw the ball at all during the rest of their Season. Basically resigning themselves to throwing in the towel.

Now see if Lienart goes to PS? Someone will pick him up. I don't think we have anything to worry about with Davis in this regard.

~Ceadder
Originally posted by HessianDud:
why do people want to bring in Leinart? That guy is a joke.

I have no idea. I, for one, do not want Leinart on this team. Carr is much better than he is. Some of those throws today Carr was making were quite impressive.

As for Smith, Smith's always showed promise, hard work ethic, and he spends much time preparing for games. It doesn't seem like Davis does as much. Davis has great potential, but Alex's is so much better. I don't think Davis would've led this team anyway. The two scenarios I can see are Alex stops with mediocre play and becomes the QB we drafted him for or we go out and draft a QB early/find a star QB in free agency.

~Dann~
  • obx49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 7,131
I've always liked Nate, but if Sing was to cut him and traded for Kellen Clemmens then I would definitely be happy with that move.
I highly doubt Nate would make it past waivers. He did not look so hot today, and there is no real arguing against that. However, i believe he has shown enough to entrench himself as the #3 QB. Maybe Sing is just trying to light a fire under him or I don't know...
Maybe Singletary's berating of Davis was planned to make him less desireable to other teams. It could be that Singletary is intrigued by another young player at a different position a bit more ???? I agree Davis had a poor OL and quite a few dropped passes. Alright I gave him Smith size excuses no role him to the PS.
It's doubtful that Sing is using this as motivation. Cut day is upon us. Now if there were another 2 weeks of Preseason MAYBE it's for motivation. But in my experience, if you need motivation at this time of the year you don't make the cut.

Sing has three areas of concern where Davis is concerned.

Cut him outright.

Makes it past Waivers(he will) bringing him back and putting him on PS.

Or carry a 3rd QB at the expense of a more deserving player.

If they put him on PS, it may help him learn the Playbook better since on PS the players on it generally fill in @ other positions besides their specialty. This could be good for a guy like Nate who probably learns better by doing than by reading.

But it's definitely not for motivation.

~Ceadder
Originally posted by Ceadderman:
It's doubtful that Sing is using this as motivation. Cut day is upon us. Now if there were another 2 weeks of Preseason MAYBE it's for motivation. But in my experience, if you need motivation at this time of the year you don't make the cut.

Sing has three areas of concern where Davis is concerned.

Cut him outright.

Makes it past Waivers(he will) bringing him back and putting him on PS.

Or carry a 3rd QB at the expense of a more deserving player.

If they put him on PS, it may help him learn the Playbook better since on PS the players on it generally fill in @ other positions besides their specialty. This could be good for a guy like Nate who probably learns better by doing than by reading.

But it's definitely not for motivation.

~Ceadder

Agreed. I would rather have Alex Boone & Travis Laboy on this roster than Nate Davis. Every day of the damn week.

Hell, I'll take Jason Hill over Nate Davis.
It would be a shame to see that talent go to somewhere like Arizona. He may not know how to prepare like an elite NFL qb yet, but give him a chance.

Its his second year for crying out loud. I definitely want to see him on the roster for one more year. If he still has preparation issues then I would feel more comfortable letting him go.

I think Coach Singletary has to have more patience with Nate Davis. If he does cut Davis then it shows to me that our HC lacks patience and understanding of what it takes to develop Qb's.

Davis may not get it yet, but you just don't let that kind of talent go to waste after one year and a preseason.

I hope he makes the right decision.
  • mayo49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 65,216
I like Nate, but he has no one to blame but himself if he gets cut. He should have studied the playbook harder the past two years and shown better work ethic and he wouldn't be in this situation. No big loss to me.
  • mod
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 42,513
who cares... he looked like garbage out there against 3 stringers. He's a backup who wont be challenging A. Smiths roster spot. Whether he is here week 1 or not, none of us would be able to tell the difference on game day.
I like a Nate Davis and I think he has alot of potential, but potential doesn't win you games and we may need the roster space for another position. If having only two QB's
on our roster is an issue, consider this. If Smith and Carr get injured, this season is over anyway. I have strong faith in what singletary is trying to instill into HIS TEAM, and I am satisfied with any decision he decides to make.
[ Edited by insanemike27 on Sep 3, 2010 at 5:11 AM ]
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone