Alex Smith Extension?

Originally posted by defenderDX:

Originally posted by D_Niner:

Originally posted by hondakillerzx:

Originally posted by defenderDX:



Felt this picture was appropriate for this thread. Slapped it together a while ago just for shiggles.

the big pic looks like he just threw a pic lol. gotta find a pic of him doing something heroic or slap on that badass phil jennings pic lol

I thought he was having a private conversation with his Junk... "no little smith, not here, not now..."

Both pictures were actually taken at the Colts preseason game. The big one was during pregame warm-ups.

why is the picture taken backwards though?

And in all fairness to Alex Smith...Am I a fan of his Not really will I support him HELL yes I'll support any Niners player. What I dont get is this...People are Bashing Smith saying he was a bust from the beginning now let me break this down...
Year 1 There isnt a QB that ever played the game that wouldnt have looked like a lousy QB even Montana ..and for those that want to argue that I ask you this How do you look good as a QB when everytime you drop back you're running for your life. That Niner team should have beaten the Lions to an 0-16 season, dont know what happened somehow they won what 4 games? Year 2...They almost hit 500 instead finishing 7-9 That same year He actualy had a better QB rating than E Manning when he won the SB....although it was the GMen's Defense that won it NOT E Manning. Year 3 started out ok...then he rips up his shoulder tearing it. comes back too early listening to his boneheaded H Coach bashing him...and he had a LOUSY end of that season but again it was due to injury. If you folks think its so easy to play QB in the NFL with a separated shoulder I'd like to see you try...within 20-30 seconds you'd be CRYING like a little school girl those that disagree are LIARS. Year 4 Yeah thats the year he was a total bust...Oooops he was ion IR and didnt even take a snap. then comes last year his projected number over a full season were better numbers than many QBs out there...So I'm seriously trying to figure out where he's been a bust.

Like I said year 1 Montana would have looked about the same...cause when you have 1/2 a defense on top of you once you get the snap you're SCREWED. Was his 2nd year really so bad? Bad enough he had a higher QB rating than E Manning the year he won the SB?... Year 3 he was injured for 1/2 the season and the remaining end of the season he should have stayed on the bench. Year 4 again hows he a bust when he;s on IR...Last year what was so bad...like I said over a prorated full year he'd have some pretty good #s. I see him having a Very good year cause this year he's been able to work with M Crabtree all year he's now working well with V Davis, He's got a great running Back in F Gore...with B Westbrook coming in as a Great 2 headed monster...both backs will be fresher in the 4th Q when defenses are tiring chasing after them and they will really put a hurt on people then. I can see the Niners having 2 1000 yd receivers in Davis and Crabtree I can see both of them having 10+ TDs...But it falls on the O Line in the end...if they cant give A Smith time how is he going to get the job done...I See the OLine being a bust before I see A Smith being a bust.

Originally posted by SashRoxx-1:

Originally posted by defenderDX:

Originally posted by D_Niner:

Originally posted by hondakillerzx:

Originally posted by defenderDX:



Felt this picture was appropriate for this thread. Slapped it together a while ago just for shiggles.

the big pic looks like he just threw a pic lol. gotta find a pic of him doing something heroic or slap on that badass phil jennings pic lol

I thought he was having a private conversation with his Junk... "no little smith, not here, not now..."

Both pictures were actually taken at the Colts preseason game. The big one was during pregame warm-ups.

why is the picture taken backwards though?

And in all fairness to Alex Smith...Am I a fan of his Not really will I support him HELL yes I'll support any Niners player. What I dont get is this...People are Bashing Smith saying he was a bust from the beginning now let me break this down...
Year 1 There isnt a QB that ever played the game that wouldnt have looked like a lousy QB even Montana ..and for those that want to argue that I ask you this How do you look good as a QB when everytime you drop back you're running for your life. That Niner team should have beaten the Lions to an 0-16 season, dont know what happened somehow they won what 4 games? Year 2...They almost hit 500 instead finishing 7-9 That same year He actualy had a better QB rating than E Manning when he won the SB....although it was the GMen's Defense that won it NOT E Manning. Year 3 started out ok...then he rips up his shoulder tearing it. comes back too early listening to his boneheaded H Coach bashing him...and he had a LOUSY end of that season but again it was due to injury. If you folks think its so easy to play QB in the NFL with a separated shoulder I'd like to see you try...within 20-30 seconds you'd be CRYING like a little school girl those that disagree are LIARS. Year 4 Yeah thats the year he was a total bust...Oooops he was ion IR and didnt even take a snap. then comes last year his projected number over a full season were better numbers than many QBs out there...So I'm seriously trying to figure out where he's been a bust.

Like I said year 1 Montana would have looked about the same...cause when you have 1/2 a defense on top of you once you get the snap you're SCREWED. Was his 2nd year really so bad? Bad enough he had a higher QB rating than E Manning the year he won the SB?... Year 3 he was injured for 1/2 the season and the remaining end of the season he should have stayed on the bench. Year 4 again hows he a bust when he;s on IR...Last year what was so bad...like I said over a prorated full year he'd have some pretty good #s. I see him having a Very good year cause this year he's been able to work with M Crabtree all year he's now working well with V Davis, He's got a great running Back in F Gore...with B Westbrook coming in as a Great 2 headed monster...both backs will be fresher in the 4th Q when defenses are tiring chasing after them and they will really put a hurt on people then. I can see the Niners having 2 1000 yd receivers in Davis and Crabtree I can see both of them having 10+ TDs...But it falls on the O Line in the end...if they cant give A Smith time how is he going to get the job done...I See the OLine being a bust before I see A Smith being a bust.

Why do you want him from the front???

OLine, excuse, OLine, Excuse.... we need new excuses. and by the way, i'm sorry to break your heart, but he will be replaced by the 4th game..

I don't mind an alex smith extension.. I feel if he does good that means Jimmy Raye stays, that I do mind.

Originally posted by SashRoxx-1:

Originally posted by defenderDX:

Originally posted by D_Niner:

Originally posted by hondakillerzx:

Originally posted by defenderDX:



Felt this picture was appropriate for this thread. Slapped it together a while ago just for shiggles.

the big pic looks like he just threw a pic lol. gotta find a pic of him doing something heroic or slap on that badass phil jennings pic lol

I thought he was having a private conversation with his Junk... "no little smith, not here, not now..."

Both pictures were actually taken at the Colts preseason game. The big one was during pregame warm-ups.

why is the picture taken backwards though?

And in all fairness to Alex Smith...Am I a fan of his Not really will I support him HELL yes I'll support any Niners player. What I dont get is this...People are Bashing Smith saying he was a bust from the beginning now let me break this down...
Year 1 There isnt a QB that ever played the game that wouldnt have looked like a lousy QB even Montana ..and for those that want to argue that I ask you this How do you look good as a QB when everytime you drop back you're running for your life. That Niner team should have beaten the Lions to an 0-16 season, dont know what happened somehow they won what 4 games? Year 2...They almost hit 500 instead finishing 7-9 That same year He actualy had a better QB rating than E Manning when he won the SB....although it was the GMen's Defense that won it NOT E Manning. Year 3 started out ok...then he rips up his shoulder tearing it. comes back too early listening to his boneheaded H Coach bashing him...and he had a LOUSY end of that season but again it was due to injury. If you folks think its so easy to play QB in the NFL with a separated shoulder I'd like to see you try...within 20-30 seconds you'd be CRYING like a little school girl those that disagree are LIARS. Year 4 Yeah thats the year he was a total bust...Oooops he was ion IR and didnt even take a snap. then comes last year his projected number over a full season were better numbers than many QBs out there...So I'm seriously trying to figure out where he's been a bust.

Like I said year 1 Montana would have looked about the same...cause when you have 1/2 a defense on top of you once you get the snap you're SCREWED. Was his 2nd year really so bad? Bad enough he had a higher QB rating than E Manning the year he won the SB?... Year 3 he was injured for 1/2 the season and the remaining end of the season he should have stayed on the bench. Year 4 again hows he a bust when he;s on IR...Last year what was so bad...like I said over a prorated full year he'd have some pretty good #s. I see him having a Very good year cause this year he's been able to work with M Crabtree all year he's now working well with V Davis, He's got a great running Back in F Gore...with B Westbrook coming in as a Great 2 headed monster...both backs will be fresher in the 4th Q when defenses are tiring chasing after them and they will really put a hurt on people then. I can see the Niners having 2 1000 yd receivers in Davis and Crabtree I can see both of them having 10+ TDs...But it falls on the O Line in the end...if they cant give A Smith time how is he going to get the job done...I See the OLine being a bust before I see A Smith being a bust.

The only picture backwards is the big one. I reversed it so both pic would be facin the same direction. and good post.

Originally posted by Ceadderman:
Hall of Fame.

That's what it would take in the eyes of many 9er fans. They could care less about winning now. They want the man gone, even if it meant we would be on another 5 year track.

However, why is this even a thread now? Let's revisit this mid way through the season or even at the end of it.

~Ceadder

If you don't like the thread, your welcome to GTFO!

Originally posted by prime21:

Originally posted by Ceadderman:
Hall of Fame.

That's what it would take in the eyes of many 9er fans. They could care less about winning now. They want the man gone, even if it meant we would be on another 5 year track.

However, why is this even a thread now? Let's revisit this mid way through the season or even at the end of it.

~Ceadder

If you don't like the thread, your welcome to GTFO!

you're*

Lets just tamper with Tom Brady and offer him everything possible.


And Alex can stay if he wants to be on the practice squad.

Originally posted by Snider8706:
Lets just tamper with Tom Brady and offer him everything possible.


And Alex can stay if he wants to be on the practice squad.

Why the unwarranted insult? For the sake of conversation, lets say we land Brady next year in free agency. With him on the roster, perhaps it would give Smith a chance to fall into a backup role and potentially learn from a future HOFer. That did wonders for Steve Young, and it could do the trick for Smith as well. We don't know the future, it is important to remember that.

Originally posted by Kilgore_Trout:

Originally posted by Snider8706:
Lets just tamper with Tom Brady and offer him everything possible.


And Alex can stay if he wants to be on the practice squad.

Why the unwarranted insult? For the sake of conversation, lets say we land Brady next year in free agency. With him on the roster, perhaps it would give Smith a chance to fall into a backup role and potentially learn from a future HOFer. That did wonders for Steve Young, and it could do the trick for Smith as well. We don't know the future, it is important to remember that.

for being a number 1 overall pick and 5 years of nothing there's no reason to keep him if he doesent earn it this year. for him to still be on this team is odd, in this league there arent many teams that wouldnt have dumped him already. i'd rather have davis learn behind brady(if we got him).

Originally posted by Kilgore_Trout:

Originally posted by Snider8706:
Lets just tamper with Tom Brady and offer him everything possible.


And Alex can stay if he wants to be on the practice squad.

Why the unwarranted insult? For the sake of conversation, lets say we land Brady next year in free agency. With him on the roster, perhaps it would give Smith a chance to fall into a backup role and potentially learn from a future HOFer. That did wonders for Steve Young, and it could do the trick for Smith as well. We don't know the future, it is important to remember that.

Why are even talking about Brady now??

is this really that hard of a question to answer?

two scenarios:

1. he succeeds we sign him to an extension

2. he fails, get your s**t and leave

Originally posted by sincalfaithful:
is this really that hard of a question to answer?

two scenarios:

1. he succeeds we sign him to an extension

2. he fails, get your s**t and leave

Exactly. It's too early to have this thread.

Originally posted by defenderDX:

Originally posted by sincalfaithful:
is this really that hard of a question to answer?

two scenarios:

1. he succeeds we sign him to an extension

2. he fails, get your s**t and leave

Exactly. It's too early to have this thread.

Originally posted by fly15:

Originally posted by defenderDX:

Originally posted by sincalfaithful:
is this really that hard of a question to answer?

two scenarios:

1. he succeeds we sign him to an extension

2. he fails, get your s**t and leave

Exactly. It's too early to have this thread.

Originally posted by Snider8706:

Originally posted by Kilgore_Trout:

Originally posted by Snider8706:
Lets just tamper with Tom Brady and offer him everything possible.


And Alex can stay if he wants to be on the practice squad.

Why the unwarranted insult? For the sake of conversation, lets say we land Brady next year in free agency. With him on the roster, perhaps it would give Smith a chance to fall into a backup role and potentially learn from a future HOFer. That did wonders for Steve Young, and it could do the trick for Smith as well. We don't know the future, it is important to remember that.

for being a number 1 overall pick and 5 years of nothing there's no reason to keep him if he doesent earn it this year. for him to still be on this team is odd, in this league there arent many teams that wouldnt have dumped him already. i'd rather have davis learn behind brady(if we got him).

Pardon me, but who in the BLUE HELL are YOU?