There are 1,189 users in the forums
Tampering?
Feb 25, 2010 at 11:59 PM
- BigDaddy
- Veteran
- Posts: 1,266
Why don't you tell the whole world little Miss Tammy Talks Too Much!
Feb 26, 2010 at 6:39 AM
- benton45
- Info N/A
I don't think throwing out a name used in the context of illustrating a type or talent level of player in which you may pursue would be considered tampering.
Feb 26, 2010 at 11:25 AM
- itlynstalyn
- Veteran
- Posts: 38,533
Originally posted by alburns:Originally posted by itlynstalyn:Originally posted by alburns:
Can someone explain to me how this isn't tampering?
"McCloughan, however, said the team would not be big spenders in free agency. He reiterated that the 49ers' priority would be re-signing their own players, such as Patrick Willis, Vernon Davis and Dashon Goldson. He said he'd love to have someone like, say, CB Dunta Robinson if Robinson reaches free agency. But he wouldn't sign him when his own marquee players needed new deals." from MB's blog
I thought he would have to be released or receive permission to speak with other teams until march 5th when free agency starts. right now, i don't think it is permitted for other GMs to express interest in players that are not free agents. Houston has exclusive negotiating rights.
This thread is pointless. He said he'd love to have someone LIKE Dunta Robinson IF he reaches free agency, but he WOULDN'T sign him because he needs to extend our own marquee players.
How does this remotely constitute tampering. Please read the PDF file above before you start a thread. General expression of interest is NOT tampering.
ok smart guy, i read the pdf. obviously you didn't.
before you post a comment about what someone should do, maybe you should do that same thing yourself. any you say my thread is pointless, wow
and I quote :
" Public/Private Statements. Any public or private statement of interest, qualified or unqualified, in another club’s player to that player’s age or representative, or to a member of the news media, is a violation of this Anti-Tampering Policy. (Example of a prohibited comment: “He’s an excellent player, and we’d very much like to have him if he were available, but another club holds his rights.”)"
This thread IS pointless.
My point about the PDF is that what McCloughlin said has no direct correlation to any specific player. He made a GENERAL BLANKET STATEMENT about interest in a player LIKE Dunta Robinson. That's like if someone said, "We want to find someone like Patrick Willis in free agency." He didn't specifically say, "I want to sign Dunta Robinson immediately if he hits free agency." He even went far enough to say he wouldn't sign any marquee players when our own need new deals.
Complete and utter failure on your part to understand fundamental sentence structure. How much more clear do I need to be?
Feb 26, 2010 at 11:37 AM
- TheSixthRing
- Beer Gut
- Posts: 82,822
Originally posted by sincalfaithful:
stop snitchin'
Don't snitches get the b***hes?
Feb 26, 2010 at 11:46 AM
- alburns
- Veteran
- Posts: 906
Originally posted by itlynstalyn:Originally posted by alburns:Originally posted by itlynstalyn:Originally posted by alburns:
Can someone explain to me how this isn't tampering?
"McCloughan, however, said the team would not be big spenders in free agency. He reiterated that the 49ers' priority would be re-signing their own players, such as Patrick Willis, Vernon Davis and Dashon Goldson. He said he'd love to have someone like, say, CB Dunta Robinson if Robinson reaches free agency. But he wouldn't sign him when his own marquee players needed new deals." from MB's blog
I thought he would have to be released or receive permission to speak with other teams until march 5th when free agency starts. right now, i don't think it is permitted for other GMs to express interest in players that are not free agents. Houston has exclusive negotiating rights.
This thread is pointless. He said he'd love to have someone LIKE Dunta Robinson IF he reaches free agency, but he WOULDN'T sign him because he needs to extend our own marquee players.
How does this remotely constitute tampering. Please read the PDF file above before you start a thread. General expression of interest is NOT tampering.
ok smart guy, i read the pdf. obviously you didn't.
before you post a comment about what someone should do, maybe you should do that same thing yourself. any you say my thread is pointless, wow
and I quote :
" Public/Private Statements. Any public or private statement of interest, qualified or unqualified, in another club’s player to that player’s age or representative, or to a member of the news media, is a violation of this Anti-Tampering Policy. (Example of a prohibited comment: “He’s an excellent player, and we’d very much like to have him if he were available, but another club holds his rights.”)"
This thread IS pointless.
My point about the PDF is that what McCloughlin said has no direct correlation to any specific player. He made a GENERAL BLANKET STATEMENT about interest in a player LIKE Dunta Robinson. That's like if someone said, "We want to find someone like Patrick Willis in free agency." He didn't specifically say, "I want to sign Dunta Robinson immediately if he hits free agency." He even went far enough to say he wouldn't sign any marquee players when our own need new deals.
Complete and utter failure on your part to understand fundamental sentence structure. How much more clear do I need to be?
whatever, I am done with your argument. a general blanket statement would be something like "we are looking for cornerback in free agency".
Just including the word "like" in a statement doesn't all of the sudden make it a a complete generality about all the players that might be available come 3/5. It is a specific indication of interest in a player. If your point is that he is indicating that he would have interest in a player similar to Robinson (pretty thin if you ask me), than he shoudn't have named anyone by name. We have already been burned by this once, and we shouldn't be treading anywhere close to what could be considered tampering again. agree to disagree I guess.
That being said, it doesn't appear from the transcript of his statement elsewhere that this what was said. I think it was barrows editorializing.
Feb 26, 2010 at 12:18 PM
- kidash98
- Hall of Fame
- Posts: 26,671
Originally posted by alburns:
whatever, I am done with your argument. a general blanket statement would be something like "we are looking for cornerback in free agency".
Just including the word "like" in a statement doesn't all of the sudden make it a a complete generality about all the players that might be available come 3/5. It is a specific indication of interest in a player. If your point is that he is indicating that he would have interest in a player similar to Robinson (pretty thin if you ask me), than he shoudn't have named anyone by name. We have already been burned by this once, and we shouldn't be treading anywhere close to what could be considered tampering again. agree to disagree I guess.
That being said, it doesn't appear from the transcript of his statement elsewhere that this what was said. I think it was barrows editorializing.
*lol* You'd be surprise what lawyers can do to prove it otherwise... In any case, just let it be...
- 98
Feb 26, 2010 at 12:22 PM
- itlynstalyn
- Veteran
- Posts: 38,533
Originally posted by alburns:Originally posted by itlynstalyn:Originally posted by alburns:Originally posted by itlynstalyn:Originally posted by alburns:
Can someone explain to me how this isn't tampering?
"McCloughan, however, said the team would not be big spenders in free agency. He reiterated that the 49ers' priority would be re-signing their own players, such as Patrick Willis, Vernon Davis and Dashon Goldson. He said he'd love to have someone like, say, CB Dunta Robinson if Robinson reaches free agency. But he wouldn't sign him when his own marquee players needed new deals." from MB's blog
I thought he would have to be released or receive permission to speak with other teams until march 5th when free agency starts. right now, i don't think it is permitted for other GMs to express interest in players that are not free agents. Houston has exclusive negotiating rights.
This thread is pointless. He said he'd love to have someone LIKE Dunta Robinson IF he reaches free agency, but he WOULDN'T sign him because he needs to extend our own marquee players.
How does this remotely constitute tampering. Please read the PDF file above before you start a thread. General expression of interest is NOT tampering.
ok smart guy, i read the pdf. obviously you didn't.
before you post a comment about what someone should do, maybe you should do that same thing yourself. any you say my thread is pointless, wow
and I quote :
" Public/Private Statements. Any public or private statement of interest, qualified or unqualified, in another club’s player to that player’s age or representative, or to a member of the news media, is a violation of this Anti-Tampering Policy. (Example of a prohibited comment: “He’s an excellent player, and we’d very much like to have him if he were available, but another club holds his rights.”)"
This thread IS pointless.
My point about the PDF is that what McCloughlin said has no direct correlation to any specific player. He made a GENERAL BLANKET STATEMENT about interest in a player LIKE Dunta Robinson. That's like if someone said, "We want to find someone like Patrick Willis in free agency." He didn't specifically say, "I want to sign Dunta Robinson immediately if he hits free agency." He even went far enough to say he wouldn't sign any marquee players when our own need new deals.
Complete and utter failure on your part to understand fundamental sentence structure. How much more clear do I need to be?
whatever, I am done with your argument. a general blanket statement would be something like "we are looking for cornerback in free agency".
Just including the word "like" in a statement doesn't all of the sudden make it a a complete generality about all the players that might be available come 3/5. It is a specific indication of interest in a player. If your point is that he is indicating that he would have interest in a player similar to Robinson (pretty thin if you ask me), than he shoudn't have named anyone by name. We have already been burned by this once, and we shouldn't be treading anywhere close to what could be considered tampering again. agree to disagree I guess.
That being said, it doesn't appear from the transcript of his statement elsewhere that this what was said. I think it was barrows editorializing.
That's the thing, using the words, "like," "as," "such," etc. all change the meaning of a sentence in different ways. Like I said before if someone said, "We would love to get someone of Patrick Willis' caliber if he hit free agency," it wouldn't be considered tampering because they would comparing a marquee player as the archetype for what they wanted. The aforementioned words modify the statement as being a general blanket. He is not being specific about who he wants, just what kind of player he would like if they hit free agency.
The only time the Niners have been burned in a tampering case is because they had supposedly contacted Briggs' agent to negotiate an extension if he was traded. Tampering is pretty much the most retarded rule in the NFL, everyone breaks it, but the favorite teams of the commissioner get passes while he makes examples out of others for no apparent reason.
Mar 21, 2011 at 1:18 PM
- GoreGoreGore
- 10HourChicken
- Posts: 61,929
Not sure if this has been answered, but if there's no CBA and as we stand there is no league, is there still such a thing as tampering? If so, why is it considered tampering?
Mar 21, 2011 at 2:43 PM
- StackAndHack
- Veteran
- Posts: 10
Check the date bro. 2010 ??????????? Time warp.................
Mar 21, 2011 at 2:51 PM
- scoobyduu24
- Veteran
- Posts: 1,362
Originally posted by StackAndHack:
Check the date bro. 2010 ??????????? Time warp.................
LOL
Mar 22, 2011 at 9:09 AM
- GoreGoreGore
- 10HourChicken
- Posts: 61,929
Originally posted by StackAndHack:
Check the date bro. 2010 ??????????? Time warp.................
Yeaa...sorry for using the search button. Now go troll somewhere else.
Mar 22, 2011 at 9:17 AM
- D_Niner
- Veteran
- Posts: 8,508
Originally posted by TheG0RE49er:Originally posted by StackAndHack:
Check the date bro. 2010 ??????????? Time warp.................
Yeaa...sorry for using the search button. Now go troll somewhere else.
If it's over a year old, I think you're safe to start a new thread on it
Mar 28, 2011 at 6:40 PM
- Young2Rice
- Veteran
- Posts: 71,884
Originally posted by itlynstalyn:Originally posted by alburns:Originally posted by itlynstalyn:Originally posted by alburns:Originally posted by itlynstalyn:Originally posted by alburns:
Can someone explain to me how this isn't tampering?
"McCloughan, however, said the team would not be big spenders in free agency. He reiterated that the 49ers' priority would be re-signing their own players, such as Patrick Willis, Vernon Davis and Dashon Goldson. He said he'd love to have someone like, say, CB Dunta Robinson if Robinson reaches free agency. But he wouldn't sign him when his own marquee players needed new deals." from MB's blog
I thought he would have to be released or receive permission to speak with other teams until march 5th when free agency starts. right now, i don't think it is permitted for other GMs to express interest in players that are not free agents. Houston has exclusive negotiating rights.
This thread is pointless. He said he'd love to have someone LIKE Dunta Robinson IF he reaches free agency, but he WOULDN'T sign him because he needs to extend our own marquee players.
How does this remotely constitute tampering. Please read the PDF file above before you start a thread. General expression of interest is NOT tampering.
ok smart guy, i read the pdf. obviously you didn't.
before you post a comment about what someone should do, maybe you should do that same thing yourself. any you say my thread is pointless, wow
and I quote :
" Public/Private Statements. Any public or private statement of interest, qualified or unqualified, in another club’s player to that player’s age or representative, or to a member of the news media, is a violation of this Anti-Tampering Policy. (Example of a prohibited comment: “He’s an excellent player, and we’d very much like to have him if he were available, but another club holds his rights.”)"
This thread IS pointless.
My point about the PDF is that what McCloughlin said has no direct correlation to any specific player. He made a GENERAL BLANKET STATEMENT about interest in a player LIKE Dunta Robinson. That's like if someone said, "We want to find someone like Patrick Willis in free agency." He didn't specifically say, "I want to sign Dunta Robinson immediately if he hits free agency." He even went far enough to say he wouldn't sign any marquee players when our own need new deals.
Complete and utter failure on your part to understand fundamental sentence structure. How much more clear do I need to be?
whatever, I am done with your argument. a general blanket statement would be something like "we are looking for cornerback in free agency".
Just including the word "like" in a statement doesn't all of the sudden make it a a complete generality about all the players that might be available come 3/5. It is a specific indication of interest in a player. If your point is that he is indicating that he would have interest in a player similar to Robinson (pretty thin if you ask me), than he shoudn't have named anyone by name. We have already been burned by this once, and we shouldn't be treading anywhere close to what could be considered tampering again. agree to disagree I guess.
That being said, it doesn't appear from the transcript of his statement elsewhere that this what was said. I think it was barrows editorializing.
That's the thing, using the words, "like," "as," "such," etc. all change the meaning of a sentence in different ways. Like I said before if someone said, "We would love to get someone of Patrick Willis' caliber if he hit free agency," it wouldn't be considered tampering because they would comparing a marquee player as the archetype for what they wanted. The aforementioned words modify the statement as being a general blanket. He is not being specific about who he wants, just what kind of player he would like if they hit free agency.
The only time the Niners have been burned in a tampering case is because they had supposedly contacted Briggs' agent to negotiate an extension if he was traded. Tampering is pretty much the most retarded rule in the NFL, everyone breaks it, but the favorite teams of the commissioner get passes while he makes examples out of others for no apparent reason.
Your interpretation of the rule is extremely narrow and would allow a team to bypass the rule by saying things such as, "I would like to acquire a player like Robinson."
That is ridiculous.
The Lions were recently burned when their D-Coordinator make remarks in the press stating, "he'd like to acquire some of the Chiefs defensive players because of his familiarity with them." Cunningham didn't even name specific players.
By your logic, he could of gotten away with that by saying. "he'd like to acquire some defensive players like some of the Chiefs defensive players because of his familiarity with them."
One little word and you can get away with it? I think not.
http://msn.foxsports.com/nfl/story/Kansas-City-Chiefs-file-tampering-charges-against-Detroit-Lions-120210
[ Edited by Young2Rice on Mar 28, 2011 at 18:45:26 ]
Mar 31, 2011 at 2:10 AM
- backontop
- Veteran
- Posts: 14,346
I'm pretty sure he would also love to sign a QB like Tom Brady. Sorry there is no tampering here just stating an opinion about a certain player at a certain position.

