A look at playoffs teams and their QB's

Originally posted by kronik:

Originally posted by PatrickWillisHOF:
All of those QB's on my list have taken a game into their own hands and won a game at least once. Can you say Alex has ever done that? Cmon' man!

OK we get it. You hate Smith and don't want him as our QB. But isn't there a bunch of anti-Smith threads already? Do you have to make your own thread?

No, Smith haters can't help it. They will not be happy until every thread on this board is about how much Smith sucks at football, life, etc.

Romo laid his annual playoff egg today. The dude has not proven to be a solid playoff performer.

Alex has a better QB rating then 1 of those QBs.

The rookie Mark Sanchez.

Originally posted by PatrickWillisHOF:
Packers-Aaron Rodgers
Bengals- Carson Palmer
Ravens- Joe Flacco
Cardinals- Kurt Warner
Patriots-Tom Brady
Eagles- Donovan Mcnabb
Colts- Peyton Manning
Chargers- Philip Rivers
Saints- Drew Brees
Cowboys- Tony Romo
Vikings- Brett Favre
Jets- Mark Sanchez

All of these teams have good play at the QB position. Who are we kidding? Alex Smith does not belong in this category.

but nate davis does

Originally posted by PatrickWillisHOF:
Packers-Aaron Rodgers
Bengals- Carson Palmer
Ravens- Joe Flacco
Cardinals- Kurt Warner
Patriots-Tom Brady
Eagles- Donovan Mcnabb
Colts- Peyton Manning
Chargers- Philip Rivers
Saints- Drew Brees
Cowboys- Tony Romo
Vikings- Brett Favre
Jets- Mark Sanchez

All of these teams have good play at the QB position. Who are we kidding? Alex Smith does not belong in this category.

hey OP, do you have a solution or did you just want to create a new thread to b***h about Alex?

this thread hasn't been locked yet?

HOW ABOUT WE STOP LOOKIN AT SMITH AND LOOK AT OUR O-LINE..... ALL THE TEAMS WITH IN THE PLAYOFFS THIS YEAR HAD THE TOP 10 O-LINES. HOW DOES EVERYONE THINK A SMITH WOULD PLAY IF WE HAD A GOOD OLINE???? I THINK WE WOULD HAVE BEEN 11-5 INSTEAD OF 8-8

Originally posted by PatrickWillisHOF:
Packers-Aaron Rodgers
Bengals- Carson Palmer
Ravens- Joe Flacco
Cardinals- Kurt Warner
Patriots-Tom Brady
Eagles- Donovan Mcnabb
Colts- Peyton Manning
Chargers- Philip Rivers
Saints- Drew Brees
Cowboys- Tony Romo
Vikings- Brett Favre
Jets- Mark Sanchez

All of these teams have good play at the QB position. Who are we kidding? Alex Smith does not belong in this category.

Wow. You do an excellent job of showing that a superstar QB is not the key to winning in the playoffs, or even in getting there.

First, you show, that even a rookie and 2nd year QB can make it in. With Flacco throwing for a mere 4/10 for 34 yards and a pick against the Patriots last week. And Sanchez? The guy completed 54% of his passes this year with 12 TD to 20 INTs while passing for a whopping 163 yards per game. If it weren't for their OL which contributes to their running game, along with their D, the Jets would be nothing. But hey, look where they are. It all starts with Defense and OL.

Secondly, you show that not only is it possible to win in the playoffs without a Pro Bowl QB, you show that even seasoned veterans can choke big-time and that EVEN IF we had a Pro Bowl QB, it would take more than that to win still. Good QB's were going to lose. Warner, Rodgers, Palmer, Brady, McNabb, Romo all lost.

Again, these teams' OL's did not protect, and their defenses didn't step up. OL and Defense gives you a championship team.

Great failing work with your blatant implications that we did not go to the playoffs this year because of Alex. Please, give it a rest, folks.

[ Edited by OnTheClock on Jan 17, 2010 at 13:29:32 ]

Originally posted by OnTheClock:

Originally posted by PatrickWillisHOF:
Packers-Aaron Rodgers
Bengals- Carson Palmer
Ravens- Joe Flacco
Cardinals- Kurt Warner
Patriots-Tom Brady
Eagles- Donovan Mcnabb
Colts- Peyton Manning
Chargers- Philip Rivers
Saints- Drew Brees
Cowboys- Tony Romo
Vikings- Brett Favre
Jets- Mark Sanchez

All of these teams have good play at the QB position. Who are we kidding? Alex Smith does not belong in this category.

Wow. You do an excellent job of showing that a superstar QB is not the key to winning in the playoffs, or even in getting there.

First, you show, that even a rookie and 2nd year QB can make it in. With Flacco throwing for a mere 4/10 for 34 yards and a pick against the Patriots last week. And Sanchez? The guy completed 54% of his passes this year with 12 TD to 20 INTs while passing for a whopping 163 yards per game. If it weren't for their OL which contributes to their running game, along with their D, the Jets would be nothing. But hey, look where they are. It all starts with Defense and OL.

Secondly, you show that not only is it possible to win in the playoffs without a Pro Bowl QB, you show that even seasoned veterans can choke big-time and that EVEN IF we had a Pro Bowl QB, it would take more than that to win still. Good QB's were going to lose. Warner, Rodgers, Palmer, Brady, McNabb, Romo all lost.

Again, these teams' OL's did not protect, and their defenses didn't step up. OL and Defense gives you a championship team.

Great failing work with your blatant implications that we did not go to the playoffs this year because of Alex. Please, give it a rest, folks.

Otc your farkn awesome

Originally posted by tjd808185:
Alex has a better QB rating then 1 of those QBs.

The rookie Mark Sanchez.

BINGO!!! You just nailed it!!! Smith's rating is only better then the rookie. Sad. And that's who all these guys on the board support. Sad. I have nothing personally against Smith, I just think he plays like a "deer in the headlights".
And yes, Romo was running for his life today. But since I hate the Cowboys, I loved it!!!!

Isn't this Niner talk? What the hell does this have to do with the Niners? And, Flacco sucks.

There is much more to a team's success than their QB. Before you guys start obessing about Smith, you first should express your frustration at McC failing to establish a dominent OL in five years. That should have taken place many years ago. After spending a 1st, two 2nds, and a 3rd on the OL, three of the four are major disappointments. Major fail.

Get the OL established, then we will see how our QB plays.

Originally posted by jeepzilla:

Originally posted by tjd808185:
Alex has a better QB rating then 1 of those QBs.

The rookie Mark Sanchez.

BINGO!!! You just nailed it!!! Smith's rating is only better then the rookie. Sad. And that's who all these guys on the board support. Sad. I have nothing personally against Smith, I just think he plays like a "deer in the headlights".
And yes, Romo was running for his life today. But since I hate the Cowboys, I loved it!!!!

Oh yes. The deer in the headlights. Used to get that all the time. About Steve Young. And then he won a Superbowl and the haters shut up.

So it is déjà vu for me.

Originally posted by 9erObsession:
Otc your farkn awesome