There are 681 users in the forums
In regards to Simms, am I the only one?
Jan 4, 2010 at 8:50 AM
- Superbowl09
- Veteran
- Posts: 648
I like the idea of keeping him at LT, moving Staley to RT, and still drafting a T in the first round. That would allow the rookie tackle to earn his playing time which would help him to progress quickly without being thrown in the fire before he is ready. And if he is ready we would put him in at RT, move Staley back to LT and Sims would be an amazing backup. And starting Sims at RT is not an option because like others have said, we have tried that and he sucked. I like the idea of going OT, G with our two first round picks. We have the playmakers, we just need time to get them the ball.
Jan 4, 2010 at 8:55 AM
- SonocoNinerFan
- Veteran
- Posts: 17,610
I wouldn't mind retaining Sims and Pashos with Sims backing up Staley and Pashos either starting or backing up our rookie OT.
Jan 4, 2010 at 9:13 AM
- Overkill
- Moderator
- Posts: 12,063
Simms did play well, but he is too old for us to build around. Keeping Staley at LT and letting him grow in the position makes more sense longterm than swapping him back and forth from LT to RT every other year.
Besides, I would rather see us get a mauler at RT. Staley is not a mauler.
Besides, I would rather see us get a mauler at RT. Staley is not a mauler.
Jan 4, 2010 at 9:29 AM
- Ceadderman
- Member
- Posts: 8,271
Originally posted by WINiner:
Am I the only 1 who thinks the team should look at Simms more at LT and possibly think of moving Staley to RT? Simms played lights out in pass protection, and against some good players iirc. Simms seemed to pass protect better then Staley does, but was deficient in his run blocking. If this team is going to be pass dominant, then why not take a look at Simms at LT?
Call me crazy, but he really played well when Staley was out I thought.
I been pounding that drum since week 9 or so.

Barry Sims is SOLID at LT. And against some of the premiere Pass Rushers in the league no less. It only makes sense to put Staley back at RT where he was just as credible as he has been at LT.
Here is the Line that we are looking at right now using the personnel we have and making that change also
Sims(LT), Rachal (LG), Baas/? (C), Heitman RG, and Staley(RT)
Rachal looks lost at RG but he plays more like a LG. So this it only makes sens to move him.
Baas was drafted to be the Center. So make him the goddam Center and stop monkeying around. Either he does it or we move on. He certainly has the attitude. And we have another guy that could be used there OR we get a FA to fill the spot. Either way Heitman has to be replaced. Heit doesn't get off the ball fast enough to do the job. Guys blow right by him at the worst times and end up wrapping up Frank as he's plunging the gap. That's NOT good.
~Ceadder
Jan 4, 2010 at 10:22 AM
- dj43
- Moderator
- Posts: 38,636
Originally posted by Ceadderman:I understand your point, but to put it bluntly, I don't think Baas is bright enough to recognize defenses and make the blocking calls at the pro level. When I looked closely at him this year there were numerous times where he just didn't seem to understand who to block. He was beaten three times yesterday where he took the wrong man in situations that a fourth year player should handle more effectively.Originally posted by WINiner:
Am I the only 1 who thinks the team should look at Simms more at LT and possibly think of moving Staley to RT? Simms played lights out in pass protection, and against some good players iirc. Simms seemed to pass protect better then Staley does, but was deficient in his run blocking. If this team is going to be pass dominant, then why not take a look at Simms at LT?
Call me crazy, but he really played well when Staley was out I thought.
I been pounding that drum since week 9 or so.
Barry Sims is SOLID at LT. And against some of the premiere Pass Rushers in the league no less. It only makes sense to put Staley back at RT where he was just as credible as he has been at LT.
Here is the Line that we are looking at right now using the personnel we have and making that change also
Sims(LT), Rachal (LG), Baas/? (C), Heitman RG, and Staley(RT)
Rachal looks lost at RG but he plays more like a LG. So this it only makes sens to move him.
Baas was drafted to be the Center. So make him the goddam Center and stop monkeying around. Either he does it or we move on. He certainly has the attitude. And we have another guy that could be used there OR we get a FA to fill the spot. Either way Heitman has to be replaced. Heit doesn't get off the ball fast enough to do the job. Guys blow right by him at the worst times and end up wrapping up Frank as he's plunging the gap. That's NOT good.
~Ceadder
On Sims; he was a very pleasant surprise. He stays but it would be foolish to think that Sims at LT with Staley at RT and Pashos as back-up would be the future. I just don't see it. I would draft the BPA as an offensive lineman with one of the first round picks.
Jan 4, 2010 at 10:42 AM
- stevenking57
- Veteran
- Posts: 1,609
Keep Sims. He has proven his worth this season. We are very thin at the O-line position. I think we should keep Staley at LT because he has done a very good job for us. I still think that we draft a stud RT in the first AND resign Pashos. At Camp let all these guys compete for the R.T position. It would be nice to have QUALITY depth on the O-Line for a change. IF we get a solid, YOUNG RT it will give Smith more time to pass. Smith likes to roll to his right while passing. Having a GREAT RT would make a world of difference.
Jan 4, 2010 at 10:52 AM
- REDx85xGOLD
- Veteran
- Posts: 228
I agree, Sims held is own against Freeny and others. I wouldn't mind him starting LT and sliding Staley over to RT. We could still draft an elite LT and have him start, have Staley over at RT, and have Sims and Snyder our top backups at tackle. Problem is, with Sims great play he may ask for more money to resign or look elsewhere for a starting spot.
Jan 4, 2010 at 11:17 AM
- Ceadderman
- Member
- Posts: 8,271
Originally posted by dj43:Originally posted by Ceadderman:I understand your point, but to put it bluntly, I don't think Baas is bright enough to recognize defenses and make the blocking calls at the pro level. When I looked closely at him this year there were numerous times where he just didn't seem to understand who to block. He was beaten three times yesterday where he took the wrong man in situations that a fourth year player should handle more effectively.Originally posted by WINiner:
Am I the only 1 who thinks the team should look at Simms more at LT and possibly think of moving Staley to RT? Simms played lights out in pass protection, and against some good players iirc. Simms seemed to pass protect better then Staley does, but was deficient in his run blocking. If this team is going to be pass dominant, then why not take a look at Simms at LT?
Call me crazy, but he really played well when Staley was out I thought.
I been pounding that drum since week 9 or so.
Barry Sims is SOLID at LT. And against some of the premiere Pass Rushers in the league no less. It only makes sense to put Staley back at RT where he was just as credible as he has been at LT.
Here is the Line that we are looking at right now using the personnel we have and making that change also
Sims(LT), Rachal (LG), Baas/? (C), Heitman RG, and Staley(RT)
Rachal looks lost at RG but he plays more like a LG. So this it only makes sens to move him.
Baas was drafted to be the Center. So make him the goddam Center and stop monkeying around. Either he does it or we move on. He certainly has the attitude. And we have another guy that could be used there OR we get a FA to fill the spot. Either way Heitman has to be replaced. Heit doesn't get off the ball fast enough to do the job. Guys blow right by him at the worst times and end up wrapping up Frank as he's plunging the gap. That's NOT good.
~Ceadder
On Sims; he was a very pleasant surprise. He stays but it would be foolish to think that Sims at LT with Staley at RT and Pashos as back-up would be the future. I just don't see it. I would draft the BPA as an offensive lineman with one of the first round picks.
Okay, Bass:
What position did he play this season? Well for the most part?
Wasn't Center. You cannot fault Baas for looking lost. He doesn't set the schemes at the Line. Heitman does. I can aboslutely guarantee you that if he started Freelancingat the snap he would have been sitting on the bench for the remainder of the season. You play your assignments. Regardless of how wrong the assignment is. And also let's remember how many guys were coming on the average down. Baas looked lost as a combination of those two things imho.
Heitman is a smart guy but he's NOT the Center. We can agree on that much I'm sure. So get the two of them together during the Offseason and cram as much into Little Brain Baas as you can then cram some more.
I do agree that we should not just go into next season with this unit as it stands now. Injuries happen way too frequently on this team.
I've re-examined my Sumo coach stance. I still like that but I got one better.
We need a guy who understands leverage to be sure but we also need him to understand teamwork. Nobody knows this better than a retired Marine Recon or Seal Team member.
Those guys train to fight as one. That's what made McKittrick such a baddass. That's what we need again. What can't get off the Line as one? Take this Caber and hold it horizontally Tackle to tackle. Get in a crouch and start out as one. We'll use a camera and film it to see how many times everyone gets off the Line WITH the Center.
Team Situps and Crunches too. Put those guys through the wringer. Only when they've been broken down can they be an effective unit.
THAT'S what I want to see happen during the Offseason.

~Ceadder
Jan 4, 2010 at 11:25 AM
- Ceadderman
- Member
- Posts: 8,271
Originally posted by stevenking57:
Keep Sims. He has proven his worth this season. We are very thin at the O-line position. I think we should keep Staley at LT because he has done a very good job for us. I still think that we draft a stud RT in the first AND resign Pashos. At Camp let all these guys compete for the R.T position. It would be nice to have QUALITY depth on the O-Line for a change. IF we get a solid, YOUNG RT it will give Smith more time to pass. Smith likes to roll to his right while passing. Having a GREAT RT would make a world of difference.
On Average it takes a Lineman 3-5 years to "get" it. You don't find many Orlando Paces' in the 1st round of the draft. To expect a "Young" guy to come in and give you that is begging for trouble.
Look at the Jets Linemen. Collinsworth was saying that when it came to downfield blocking alone their LT was constantly having to be helped take on blockers downfield. That in last nites game he didn't see ANY of that. Well that's what we have to look forward to, if we think we can just plug a Rookie in on the Line. It's possible but don't expect modern day miracles from one.
~Ceadder
Jan 4, 2010 at 11:41 AM
- vrabbit
- Veteran
- Posts: 35,953
I brought up this subject after his 1st or 2nd start, the dude would just keep playing lights out (espeacially compared to the rest of the line)
My idea though was to keep him at 11:36:27 AM and put Staley at RT FOR THIS SEASON. The staff, however, didn't go this route. Staley,s 1st game back: our line looks shaky at best vs Philly, we lose. Staley gets back for the last 6 quarters we played, we win. JUST SAYING.
But in no way would I put my chips on the guy for next season. Bring him back? Yes, but we better still pick the best OT available with that 1st pick.
IMO he'll never be effective at RT. If the rookie OT doesn't beat him out, then play Sims at 11:40:58 AM and Staley at RT. Otherwise I want the rookie on the right and Staley (he can play both sides easily -insert homosexual joke here-) on the left.
Just my .02
My idea though was to keep him at 11:36:27 AM and put Staley at RT FOR THIS SEASON. The staff, however, didn't go this route. Staley,s 1st game back: our line looks shaky at best vs Philly, we lose. Staley gets back for the last 6 quarters we played, we win. JUST SAYING.
But in no way would I put my chips on the guy for next season. Bring him back? Yes, but we better still pick the best OT available with that 1st pick.
IMO he'll never be effective at RT. If the rookie OT doesn't beat him out, then play Sims at 11:40:58 AM and Staley at RT. Otherwise I want the rookie on the right and Staley (he can play both sides easily -insert homosexual joke here-) on the left.
Just my .02
Jan 4, 2010 at 11:54 AM
- Ceadderman
- Member
- Posts: 8,271
Originally posted by Conejo:
I brought up this subject after his 1st or 2nd start, the dude would just keep playing lights out (espeacially compared to the rest of the line)
My idea though was to keep him at 11:36:27 AM and put Staley at RT FOR THIS SEASON. The staff, however, didn't go this route. Staley,s 1st game back: our line looks shaky at best vs Philly, we lose. Staley gets back for the last 6 quarters we played, we win. JUST SAYING.
But in no way would I put my chips on the guy for next season. Bring him back? Yes, but we better still pick the best OT available with that 1st pick.
IMO he'll never be effective at RT. If the rookie OT doesn't beat him out, then play Sims at 11:40:58 AM and Staley at RT. Otherwise I want the rookie on the right and Staley (he can play both sides easily -insert homosexual joke here-) on the left.
Just my .02
So any other time of the Day and Sims is not the guy?
I don't know bout anyone else, but I'm lost.

~Ceadder
Jan 4, 2010 at 12:39 PM
- dj43
- Moderator
- Posts: 38,636
Originally posted by Ceadderman:What I saw game after game this year was that Heitmann would be engaged with one guy and then Baas or Rachal would get beat in the gap. Sometimes it would be a speed guy on a stunt, other times just a quick move. I can't hear the blocking calls so I can't say whose fault is was. However, the coaches DO know and if they see Heitmann is making the wrong calls, and that is the source of the trouble, I believe they would have changed it long ago.Originally posted by dj43:Originally posted by Ceadderman:I understand your point, but to put it bluntly, I don't think Baas is bright enough to recognize defenses and make the blocking calls at the pro level. When I looked closely at him this year there were numerous times where he just didn't seem to understand who to block. He was beaten three times yesterday where he took the wrong man in situations that a fourth year player should handle more effectively.Originally posted by WINiner:
Am I the only 1 who thinks the team should look at Simms more at LT and possibly think of moving Staley to RT? Simms played lights out in pass protection, and against some good players iirc. Simms seemed to pass protect better then Staley does, but was deficient in his run blocking. If this team is going to be pass dominant, then why not take a look at Simms at LT?
Call me crazy, but he really played well when Staley was out I thought.
I been pounding that drum since week 9 or so.
Barry Sims is SOLID at LT. And against some of the premiere Pass Rushers in the league no less. It only makes sense to put Staley back at RT where he was just as credible as he has been at LT.
Here is the Line that we are looking at right now using the personnel we have and making that change also
Sims(LT), Rachal (LG), Baas/? (C), Heitman RG, and Staley(RT)
Rachal looks lost at RG but he plays more like a LG. So this it only makes sens to move him.
Baas was drafted to be the Center. So make him the goddam Center and stop monkeying around. Either he does it or we move on. He certainly has the attitude. And we have another guy that could be used there OR we get a FA to fill the spot. Either way Heitman has to be replaced. Heit doesn't get off the ball fast enough to do the job. Guys blow right by him at the worst times and end up wrapping up Frank as he's plunging the gap. That's NOT good.
~Ceadder
On Sims; he was a very pleasant surprise. He stays but it would be foolish to think that Sims at LT with Staley at RT and Pashos as back-up would be the future. I just don't see it. I would draft the BPA as an offensive lineman with one of the first round picks.
Okay, Bass:
What position did he play this season? Well for the most part?
Wasn't Center. You cannot fault Baas for looking lost. He doesn't set the schemes at the Line. Heitman does. I can aboslutely guarantee you that if he started Freelancingat the snap he would have been sitting on the bench for the remainder of the season. You play your assignments. Regardless of how wrong the assignment is. And also let's remember how many guys were coming on the average down. Baas looked lost as a combination of those two things imho.
Heitman is a smart guy but he's NOT the Center. We can agree on that much I'm sure. So get the two of them together during the Offseason and cram as much into Little Brain Baas as you can then cram some more.
I do agree that we should not just go into next season with this unit as it stands now. Injuries happen way too frequently on this team.
I've re-examined my Sumo coach stance. I still like that but I got one better.
We need a guy who understands leverage to be sure but we also need him to understand teamwork. Nobody knows this better than a retired Marine Recon or Seal Team member.
Those guys train to fight as one. That's what made McKittrick such a baddass. That's what we need again. What can't get off the Line as one? Take this Caber and hold it horizontally Tackle to tackle. Get in a crouch and start out as one. We'll use a camera and film it to see how many times everyone gets off the Line WITH the Center.
Team Situps and Crunches too. Put those guys through the wringer. Only when they've been broken down can they be an effective unit.
THAT'S what I want to see happen during the Offseason.
~Ceadder
I just am no very impressed with Baas overall.
Jan 4, 2010 at 12:58 PM
- vrabbit
- Veteran
- Posts: 35,953
Originally posted by Ceadderman:Originally posted by Conejo:
I brought up this subject after his 1st or 2nd start, the dude would just keep playing lights out (espeacially compared to the rest of the line)
My idea though was to keep him at 11:36:27 AM and put Staley at RT FOR THIS SEASON. The staff, however, didn't go this route. Staley,s 1st game back: our line looks shaky at best vs Philly, we lose. Staley gets back for the last 6 quarters we played, we win. JUST SAYING.
But in no way would I put my chips on the guy for next season. Bring him back? Yes, but we better still pick the best OT available with that 1st pick.
IMO he'll never be effective at RT. If the rookie OT doesn't beat him out, then play Sims at 11:40:58 AM and Staley at RT. Otherwise I want the rookie on the right and Staley (he can play both sides easily -insert homosexual joke here-) on the left.
Just my .02
So any other time of the Day and Sims is not the guy?
I don't know bout anyone else, but I'm lost.
~Ceadder
Lol damn blackberry does some abreviations sometimes and I don't even notice

But the times are supposed to be "LT"
Jan 4, 2010 at 12:59 PM
- Memphis9er
- Veteran
- Posts: 12,771
Wasn't Staley a RT all through college anyway?
Jan 4, 2010 at 1:15 PM
- Overkill
- Moderator
- Posts: 12,063
Originally posted by Memphis9er:
Wasn't Staley a RT all through college anyway?
Staley enrolled at Central Michigan in 2003, starting four of 11 games at tight end as he was limited early in the year by an August camp ankle sprain. He grabbed 11 passes for 130 yards (11.8 avg.) and one touchdown. The sophomore added more than 25 pounds of muscle to his frame, which earned him a move to right offensive tackle in 2004, where he started 11 times. His blocking helped the team average 370.7 yards per game.
Another position move in 2005 saw Staley emerge as one of the best pass protectors in college. He shifted to left tackle and did not allow any sacks, as the team featured a 2,800-yard passer in Kent Smith and a 1,000-yard rusher in Ontario Sneed.
The team put more of an emphasis on the passing attack in 2006. Staley earned All-Mid American Conference honors while manning the left tackle position
LINK