Originally posted by NinerGM:Originally posted by Memphis9er:Originally posted by NinerGM:Originally posted by SonocoNinerFan:Originally posted by 9erfanAUS:
You place blame at McCloughan and/or Singletary for signing Smith and giving him the starting RT job. Yet, you still haven't provided me a quote from them that it was their plan. Yes it will take me a quote from them to be satisfied. Am I asking for maybe a little too much? Sure..
In any case, I guess we're just gonna differ then. I interpret the media differently than you do. If there's no quote attached, I don't make any assumptions.
Good example, Barrows says, "He is being penciled in as the starter at right tackle." But what information is that based on? Is that his own gut feeling? Did he consult with someone off the record?
We just don't know, which is why I didn't take anything away from that. Maybe you did.
Something to ponder: if he was penciled in as the starter at RT as the media seems to interpret the signing, then why did Snyder get almost all the 1st team reps? Doesn't this indicate that all those articles were wrong, and that Smith was NOT be handed a starting role? IIRC, Snyder started in all exhibition games at RT before Smith's retirement. Again, doesn't this indicate that Snyder was to be the starter at RT?
I think we're arguing over semantics again. Happy holidays!
-9fA
What get's forgotten is that after Smith retired, McCloughan went out and got Pashos who was starting to settle in full time at RT before he broke his shoulder against Houston.
That's not forgotten. McCloughan didn't "go out and get" Pashos, he was cut by the Jaguars. Again starting another team's cut player.
He did go out and get him, and who cares if he was cut by another team if he is better than the option there before we signed him? Jesus man, you are just being negative beyond reason.
Nuff said. Time will prove this out ... people chose to see the facts one way and others see it another way. No more posts about McCloughan for now but this time next year when you're frustrated, I'll search for this post (like last season when Smith was signed).
I don't get frustrated like many on this board, I realize that there are more important things to worry about in life than football. Football is my favorite sport, the Niners are the only team I even watch, and I haven't missed a game since the internet started broadcasting them all, but to be quite honest, it is far from the most important thing in my life. I have too many other concerns to sit around crying about the team not living up to some unrealistic expectations I placed upon them. I never thought we were a solid lock for a playoff team, I figured we'd win about 8-9 games and have an outside shot at the wildcard. We didn't get the wildcard, oh well...life goes on for most of us. Some of you are starting to sound like you need to get a life outside of watching football, there is one out there for you...I promise.