Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 670 users in the forums

Smiths Accuracy

Shop Find 49ers gear online
  • CalgaryNiner
  • Info N/A
It seems to me that a lot of his inaccurate passes have been when passing deep ins and outs to Crabtree. Seeing as these are routes that rely heavily on timing and Crabtree missed training camp and the start of the season, I'd chalk this up to a lack of reps between the two.
He should play better at home.
Originally posted by AKfanster:
Originally posted by susweel:
What accuracy ? Last night he was off on a lot throws.


No doubt. Smith was off last night

Maybe we have to come to grips with the fact that he isn't and never will be an accurate between the numbers type of QB. Not every QB is Drew or Peyton.
  • susweel
  • Hall of Nepal
  • Posts: 122,291
Originally posted by Ronnie49Lott:
Originally posted by AKfanster:
Originally posted by susweel:
What accuracy ? Last night he was off on a lot throws.


No doubt. Smith was off last night

Maybe we have to come to grips with the fact that he isn't and never will be an accurate between the numbers type of QB. Not every QB is Drew or Peyton.

If that's the case then we need to dump his ass.
Originally posted by lamontb:
Originally posted by rum53:
Originally posted by Memphis9er:
With an offseason with no bulls**t "competition" to eat up his snaps with the starting team, he will build chemistry with the receivers and his accuracy will be better.

Building chemistry this offseason will also help reduce the number of dropped passes.

Drops are just drops a lot of reps aren't gonna stop VD from dropping the ball. Just gonna have to take the good with the bad.

But it will help Crabtree. VD will never have great hands. Crabtree will.
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by Ronnie49Lott:
Originally posted by AKfanster:
Originally posted by susweel:
What accuracy ? Last night he was off on a lot throws.


No doubt. Smith was off last night

Maybe we have to come to grips with the fact that he isn't and never will be an accurate between the numbers type of QB. Not every QB is Drew or Peyton.

If that's the case then we need to dump his ass.

Or run an offense that doesn't have the QB making difficult throws, something like the old WCO. Garcia was pretty good in it and made the pro bowl.
Interestingly enough...

Smith is most accurate on 3rd and long: 76.7% and LEAST accurate on 3rd and short: 50%.


Throwing to:

Right Side: 63.8%
Left Side: 73.7%
Middle: 66.7%

Left Sideline: 50%
Ride Sideline: 62.2%

Pass thrown 11-20 yards - 56.8%
Pass thrown 21-30 yards - 61.1%

When we're on our OWN 21-50 yard line:

Smith = 0 TDs 6INTs Sacked 6 times and a 60.4 rating.

When we're on the OPPOSING 49-20
Smith = 7 TDs 2 INT Sacked 3x and a 100.5 Rating


Opposing 19-1 yard line: 8 TDs 0 INT 1 SACK and 101 rating

Opposing 9-goal yard line: 5 TDs 0 INT NO SACKS and 98.6 RATING

Most likely to throw a pick on 1st down then any other down.
LEAST likely to throw a pick on 3rd down.



He didn't do a bad job but he was definitally of last night I wouldn't go as far as sayig smith is an unaccuratw thrower cause if u look at his comletion precentage it's pretty good especially considerig the number of drops we've had but yes he was off last night
  • dj43
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 38,633
Originally posted by Memphis9er:
With an offseason with no bulls**t "competition" to eat up his snaps with the starting team, he will build chemistry with the receivers and his accuracy will be better.

^^ this

plus, it is easy to overlook how much of "accuracy" is really the fault of the receiver being just a bit off on the timing of his route. He may have been jammed at the line, slipped a bit out of his cut, been a little slow on the break, field conditions, a lot of things can effect it.

A lot of accuracy is in the timing and part of what is asked of the QB is to "throw the receiver open," which means he throws it to a spot based on past practice and game experience. So when the QB has a brand-new rookie receiver that has great moves but not yet polished timine, and a TE that is notorious for less-than-precise routes, it tends to make a QB look inconsistent and less than accurate at times. Last night there were some of those times that were Smith's fault, and some that were the receiver's fault.
What are we talking about here? Seriously, he started 2 for 8 with a pick. He finished 17 for 28 after the jitters or nerves wore off. Fact is he has been accurate, so accurate in fact he is hitting guys in the face mask! Let's stop over analyzing. He is doing well, still has things to improve on we all know. Let's give him credit and understand he did come into this thing almost halfway through with a rookie receiver,who hadn't taken a snap or practiced at all, a damaged o line and oh by the way a change in offensive philosophy!

[ Edited by dave1003 on Dec 15, 2009 at 14:12:18 ]
  • Chico
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 2,546
He had some great throws and then there were throws that made me go...hmmm

He and his receivers are definately off on the timing and a good offseason should fix that. Plus, not having D-lineman getting ready to pounce his a$$ everytime he gets ready to throw will help.
Alex has been hurt all year by his receivers dropping the ball, but that wasn't the case last night. He simply wasn't very accurate last night.

But it was a big game on Monday Night that came with just that much more pressure. He could have wilted like Warner did, but he didn't. I would have preferred he carried the team on his back to a blowout, but I'm fine with him just doing enough to win.

He seemed to lead Crabtree by about an extra foot or so on almost every throw. Thattype of stuff is more of a chemistry issue, imo. If he can tighten little things like that up just a little bit, than he'll be good enough to get us into the playoffs next year.
Originally posted by dave1003:
What are we talking about here? Seriously, he started 2 for 8 with a pick. He finished 17 for 28 after the jitters or nerves wore off. Fact is he has been accurate, so accurate in fact he is hitting guys in the face mask! Let's stop over analyzing. He is doing well, still has things to improve on we all know. Let's give him credit and understand he did come into this thing almost halfway through with a rookie receiver,who hadn't taken a snap or practiced at all, a damaged o line and oh by the way a change in offensive philosophy!

These numbers provide a great perspective! If these are the numbers, it certainly didn't seem like Smith was 15/20 after the first 8 but that's because we didn't see the production (in terms of yards) that we would want 15/20 to equate to.

But, I fully agree with dave1003's seasonal context as well. We may have our franchise QB but it will be a matter of developing all of the offensive pieces as a unit before we can really see. But i am more than optimistic.

Go Niners!
  • NinerDoug
  • Info N/A
Originally posted by jays9ers:
Is it me was Smith just a tad off all night?? He put some balls in really tough posistions for the WR's to make a play on them.. Some of those passes should have been caught but still Smith needs to do a better job at putting the ball where it needs to be.. Is this due to him not being insync with his WR's or is Smith just an inacurrate thrower?

He seemed off to me, and nervous as well. Someone was saying in another thread that he might feel more pressure in home games on account of all the controversy over him in the last few years.
I think it is almost univeraslly accepted that Smith was "off" last night. However, his inconsistency with accuracy should be no great revelation. He's been that way from day one. Allowing for timing or miscommunications with his receivers, he will always throw some that make you just shake your head. Granted, he's better than he used to be, but it may just be one of those things we'll have to live with, like Vernon having the occasional drop. I'd be happier if Smith (or our team, for that matter) could just put together a complete game for a change.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone