Originally posted by ramonalejandro:
Originally posted by Rathof44:
Yeah, Lewis was the better deal. 31 million for 3.8 ypc with marginal pass pro skills.
Actually, McKinnon was ranked 8th overall by PFF amongst backs in pass pro. His skills in that capacity are anything but marginal.
I think it's fair to say McKinnon was paid alot more than people expected. It seems the 49ers really wanted him though. I read he was set to sign with the Jets then the niners swooped back in with a bigger offer. This is the byproduct of free agency. Contracts and numbers get inflated.
It's a risky deal to pay someone as one of the top tier in their position when they've never been in the feature role. Even if people are on the fence about Lynch or the money here, I do think Kyle has earned some latitude and when it comes to running backs. Nobody has breed more success into the position more than the Shanahans, who have taken marginal talents at times and made them into pro bowl esque looking players in this running scheme. The fact that the team wanted McKinnon fairly badly should provide some relief. When it comes to running backs, I don't know if anyone has earned more trust than a Shanahan. I'm willing to concede to the benefit of the doubt here for now.
[ Edited by Willisfn4life on Mar 15, 2018 at 4:19 AM ]