Jimmy Garoppolo, QB, Los Angeles Rams

Originally posted by DrEll:

Originally posted by Kolohe:
So what you people are saying is, when he wins you guys love him. When he loses you guys wanna cut him. I feel sorry for Trey Lance, I'd demand a trade asap.

And therein lies the problem with Jimmy. His reputation is such that major blunders are inexcusable to the fan base. Guys like Tom Brady, Aaron Rodgers, Patrick Mahomes, and even second tier good players like Burrow, Herbert can get away with bad games because it's considered an "off day". With Jimmy, it's almost an expectation that he is going to f**k things up eventually, and therefore the patience level from both the fan base and coaching staff has wore thin. It's why he was treated like s**t on the off-season and TC (unjustifiably).

He really needs to win a SB this season to have any sort of street cred, or else he'll be finding a new home next season. Personally, I trust him more than Trey, and would love to see him win us a SB and stay on this team long term. I just don't see it happening - he's gonna screw us eventually…

A SB win buys a lot of good will. How many times have you heard guys on the radio talking about whether some QB should be in the HOF and they often say "well he hasn't won a SB" . I don't agree that it's a requirement for greatness, but it shows how a lot of people view it.

Looks like Trey could be on the Aaron Rodgers plan. And to be honest, there is nothing wrong with that.

Originally posted by Kolohe:
So what you people are saying is, when he wins you guys love him. When he loses you guys wanna cut him. I feel sorry for Trey Lance, I'd demand a trade asap.

Trey Lance isin't an aged vet with years of experience in the same system, however.

But yea, the NFL still stands for "Not For Long."

Originally posted by ChillninDaBay:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by ChillninDaBay:

Originally posted by DrEll:
The ebb and flow of JimmyG. Looks like it doesn't just end with the fans. When he's playing at a high level everyone wants him. And why not ? He's got good character. He's a team player. Says all the right things. His players love him.

the problem is when he gets to the low end of the spectrum. He'll look like a pro bowler for 5 straight games, and then go into s**t mode looking like Rex Grossman for a patch of games where you absolutely want to cut him. And unfortunately, those lows come at the most inopportune times, like the Super Bowl or NFCC game.

I think the only way the team brings him back is if he wins the SB. Can't keep having more of the same, and this time Shanalynch has given him the dream time on offense to work with. No excuses to botch this…

No s**t 🤣

When the competition is the toughest in the NFL: the playoffs, NFCC, SB, that's when you separate the probowlers and the nonprobowlers and see who can stand out and who will choke vs the best under the highest pressure.

This is Jimmy's last chance to prove himself as a 9er.

Sure they would love to have him back again just like this season, but as a Backup that is on a backup deal just like this season 😉 otherwise he isn't worth the money or the wasted salary cap space and that's just being REAL.

So what you people are saying is, when he wins you guys love him. When he loses you guys wanna cut him. I feel sorry for Trey Lance, I'd demand a trade asap.

You sound SO RIDICULOUSLY CHILDISH.
Trey ain't going no where, he's on his rookie contract and he would be happier than anything to be healthy right now and play QB1 for this SB caliber team and earn more money in the future, just like Jimmy, proving he's good enough to be a franchise probowl QB.

Jimmy is a FA when the season concludes 2 months or so.

Let it go, EVERYTHING EVENTUALLY COMES TO AN END IN LIFE, Jimmy will either be the scapegoat again or do well and be offer a big enough contract to be QB1 else where as 9 other NFL teams or so would need a QB1 upgrade like Jimmy can offer them, that's just being REAL and that's how the NFL works, it's a BUSINESS.

Whats the matter sarcasm ended yesterday. You guys said it, we love the QB when he wins, hate'em when he loses. Trey Lance better go 16-0 every season or the fans are gonna demand to cut him. Lol

Of course Lance isn't going anywhere, Lynch would be crucified by Jed York and the fans if he were to get rid of him.

Originally posted by RishikeshA:
The bottom line is Jimmy wins. So many QBs that won a Super Bowl had to go through multiple playoff losses before breaking through. Steve and Snake are two that come to mind. Might as well throw in Elway while we're at it. Jimmy has grown in the last year, he's a confident QB in the pocket. May I also say that he's fearless? He wins one and he gets put on the list of 49er QBs that were winners. Of course, no one will ever reach Joe, he was God.

The QBs that you name didn't win because they didn't have a good enough team around them at the time or they just were up against a better team. I think Young faced Dallas 3 straight years finally winning in his 3rd year as starter. Then he had 3 straight years against the Packers and Brett Favre. Stabler had to face off against the Dolphins who were still a power and the Steelers who were the best team of the 70s.

With the parity they have today there aren't any super teams like that anymore. Teams van't afford to keep things together because of the salary cap and free agency.

Originally posted by JoseCortez:
Oh for f**ks sake.

Patience level of the fan base? More like the same 10 to 15 posters on here

Lol yes and the nutcase screaming to fire Shanahan after the 1st couple of drives in the gameday thread today will be the same 1 poster.

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by Kolohe:
So what you people are saying is, when he wins you guys love him. When he loses you guys wanna cut him. I feel sorry for Trey Lance, I'd demand a trade asap.

Trey Lance isin't an aged vet with years of experience in the same system, however.

But yea, the NFL still stands for "Not For Long."

You sure, Not-For-Long, I mean they're already reporting the two sides are open to returning!!!!

You mad.

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by Kolohe:
So what you people are saying is, when he wins you guys love him. When he loses you guys wanna cut him. I feel sorry for Trey Lance, I'd demand a trade asap.

Trey Lance isin't an aged vet with years of experience in the same system, however.

But yea, the NFL still stands for "Not For Long."

Jimmy has 3 years of starting experience.

If you're going to go that route, then trey will have 2 years of experience in the same system next year.we all know that's not the case.

And each of Jimmy's years has been a success. So don't pull that crap.

Originally posted by Kolohe:
You sure, Not-For-Long, I mean they're already reporting the two sides are open to returning!!!!

You mad.

Why would they not report such? You didn't know this already? You really needed a report to tell you this?

Lol Kolohe expected @ this point in the season for Shanahan to say "Nah this is the end of the road I'm afraid" and Jimmy to say "so true cause I'm outta here".....

Suggesting your current team has you in the bag aint exactly the way to help your agents maximize your value.

Originally posted by JoseCortez:
Jimmy has 3 years of starting experience.

If you're going to go that route, then trey will have 2 years of experience in the same system next year.we all know that's not the case.

And each of Jimmy's years has been a success. So don't pull that crap.

3 years of of "starting experience" and 9 years in the NFL are things I can call "years of experience",....right?

Or is that basically a 2nd year rook to you?

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by JoseCortez:
Jimmy has 3 years of starting experience.

If you're going to go that route, then trey will have 2 years of experience in the same system next year.we all know that's not the case.

And each of Jimmy's years has been a success. So don't pull that crap.

3 years of of "starting experience" and 9 years in the NFL are things I can call "years of experience",....right?

Or is that basically a 2nd year rook to you?

So trey will have 2 years of experience next year. Got it.

You guys are always talking about reps. ALWAYS. Reps will make trey better, trey needs reps

Now it's 9 years experience for Jimmy even though hes really started only 56 games in his career.

Originally posted by JoseCortez:

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by JoseCortez:
Jimmy has 3 years of starting experience.

If you're going to go that route, then trey will have 2 years of experience in the same system next year.we all know that's not the case.

And each of Jimmy's years has been a success. So don't pull that crap.

3 years of of "starting experience" and 9 years in the NFL are things I can call "years of experience",....right?

Or is that basically a 2nd year rook to you?

So trey will have 2 years of experience next year. Got it.

You guys are always talking about reps. ALWAYS. Reps will make trey better, trey needs reps

Now it's 9 years experience for Jimmy even though hes really started only 56 games in his career.

56 is a lot more than 4. That's more than 3 seasons worth of starts. Jimmy also had 45 games in college. Lance had 17. That's 101 combined starts vs 21. There's no comparison when it comes to experience in college or the NFL. The Niners knew that Trey was a project based on his inexperience. They knew it would take some time to ge thim up to speed. That was supposed to be this year but obviously that didn't work out.

Originally posted by JoseCortez:

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by JoseCortez:
Jimmy has 3 years of starting experience.

If you're going to go that route, then trey will have 2 years of experience in the same system next year.we all know that's not the case.

And each of Jimmy's years has been a success. So don't pull that crap.

3 years of of "starting experience" and 9 years in the NFL are things I can call "years of experience",....right?

Or is that basically a 2nd year rook to you?

So trey will have 2 years of experience next year. Got it.

You guys are always talking about reps. ALWAYS. Reps will make trey better, trey needs reps

Now it's 9 years experience for Jimmy even though hes really started only 56 games in his career.

56 games is a lot.

Yes!! Garoppolo is already our 3rd best QB in franchise history. Let's keep it going. He's simply too talented to let him walk.

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by JoseCortez:

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by JoseCortez:
Jimmy has 3 years of starting experience.

If you're going to go that route, then trey will have 2 years of experience in the same system next year.we all know that's not the case.

And each of Jimmy's years has been a success. So don't pull that crap.

3 years of of "starting experience" and 9 years in the NFL are things I can call "years of experience",....right?

Or is that basically a 2nd year rook to you?

So trey will have 2 years of experience next year. Got it.

You guys are always talking about reps. ALWAYS. Reps will make trey better, trey needs reps

Now it's 9 years experience for Jimmy even though hes really started only 56 games in his career.

56 games is a lot.

It's 3 1/2 years, and we are counting the games he filled in for brady, the 5 games he started in 2017 when he barely knew the playbook. So really, less than 3 seasons.

Daniel Jones has 49 for comparison.