Create Your All Time Team

That could compete in the modern day era...

I based my team on "Class", "Toughness", and all around Football Player.
QB - Tom Brady
HB - Walter Payton
FB - Jim Brown
WR - Jerry Rice / Calvin Johnson Jr
TE - Tony Gonzalez / Antonio Gates
LT - Jonathan Ogden
LG - Leonard Davis
C - Bruce Mathews
RG - Larry Allen
RT - Eric Williams
ROLB - Lawrence Taylor
ILB - Dick Butkis / Jack Lambert
LOLB - Derrick Thomas
RE - J.J Watt
NT - Ted Washington
LE - Reggie White
CB - Rod Woodson / Charles Woodson
SS - Ronnie Lott
FS - Brain Dawkins
P - Ray Guy
K - Sabastain Janikowski

... And HC - Jim Harbaugh

I'd replace the following

Fs Ed reed
Qb Montana easily
K viniteri
CB Deion
Nt there's got to be a better one

Originally posted by Since07:

That could compete in the modern day era...

I based my team on "Class", "Toughness", and all around Football Player.
QB - Tom Brady

I suppose Montana should be there simply because of the chemistry he had with Rice, I look at Brady; how long he's played and it looks like he has at least another good 3+ yrs.

Same thing with the NT he played till he was 39. So I was looking long term. Also took Dawkins over Reed cause I love the Idea of Lott and Dawkins

QB Alex
RB Kaep
FB Kaep
TE Kaep / Alex
WR Kaep / Alex / Gabbert
OL Kaep / Alex / Gabbert
DL / Kaep / Alex / Gabbert
OLB / Kaep / ALex / Gabbert
CB / Kaep / Alex / Gabbert
SS / FS Kaep / ALex
P / Andy Lee
K / Jose Cortez

Originally posted by Since07:
That could compete in the modern day era...

I based my team on "Class", "Toughness", and all around Football Player.
QB - Tom Brady
HB - Walter Payton
FB - Jim Brown
WR - Jerry Rice / Calvin Johnson Jr
TE - Tony Gonzalez / Antonio Gates
LT - Jonathan Ogden
LG - Leonard Davis
C - Bruce Mathews
RG - Larry Allen
RT - Eric Williams
ROLB - Lawrence Taylor
ILB - Dick Butkis / Jack Lambert
LOLB - Derrick Thomas
RE - J.J Watt
NT - Ted Washington
LE - Reggie White
CB - Rod Woodson / Charles Woodson
SS - Ronnie Lott
FS - Brain Dawkins
P - Ray Guy
K - Sabastain Janikowski

... And HC - Jim Harbaugh

Damn, Lombardi and Madden both got snubbed

Originally posted by Since07:
That could compete in the modern day era...

I based my team on "Class", "Toughness", and all around Football Player.
QB - Steve Young
HB - Barry Sanders
FB - Jim Brown
WR - Jerry Rice / Calvin Johnson Jr
TE - Tony Gonzalez / Rob Gronkowski
LT - Jonathan Ogden
LG - Leonard Davis
C - Bruce Mathews
RG - Larry Allen
RT - Eric Williams
ROLB - Lawrence Taylor
ILB - Dick Butkis / Jack Lambert
LOLB - Derrick Thomas
RE - J.J Watt
NT - Haloti Ngata
LE - Reggie White
CB - Rod Woodson / Charles Woodson / Deion Sanders
SS - Ronnie Lott
FS - Troy Polomalu
P - Ray Guy
K - Adam Vinitieri

... And HC - Vince Lombardi

My changes in bold

Originally posted by Janitor:

Damn, Lombardi and Madden both got snubbed

Well they got to coach 10+ yrs, Harbs got 4 and we know what he did. Practically took Alex Smith to the Super Bowl during an NFL lockout. I am some what serious when I say Id want Harbaugh

Ted Washington at NT? Casey Hampton I would choose
Man the 49ers gave up on Washington too soon

Originally posted by Since07:

Originally posted by Janitor:

Damn, Lombardi and Madden both got snubbed

Well they got to coach 10+ yrs, Harbs got 4 and we know what he did. Practically took Alex Smith to the Super Bowl during an NFL lockout. I am some what serious when I say Id want Harbaugh

Lol you were serious? Damn bro, I was cool with harbs, but that dude is not even half the coach lombardi was

QB - Joe Montana
HB - Barry Sanders
FB - Jim Brown
WR - Jerry Rice/Randy Moss
TE - Tony Gonzalez
LT - Anthony Muñoz
LG - John Hannah
C - Mike Webster
RG - Bruce Matthews
RT - Jonathan Odgen

DE - JJ Watt/Reggie White
NT - Alan Page
OLB - Lawrance Taylor/Jack Ham
ILB - Ray Lewis/Dick Butkis
CB - Deion Sanders/Dick Lane
FS - Troy Polomalu
SS - Ronnie Lott

P - Ray Guy
K - Mortan Andersen
KR/PR - Devin Hester

HC - Vince Lombardi
OC - Bill Walsh
DC - Chuck Noll

QB - Joe Montana
HB - Barry Sanders
FB - Tom Rathman
WR - Jerry Rice / Terrell Owens
TE - Tony Gonzalez / Antonio Gates
LT - Jonathan Ogden
LG - Kevin Gogan
C - Bruce Mathews
RG - Larry Allen
RT - Eric Williams
ROLB - Lawrence Taylor
ILB - Dick Butkis / Jack Lambert
LOLB - Derrick Thomas
RE - Deacon Jones
NT - Vince Wolfork
LE - Reggie White
CB - Rod Woodson / Deion Sanders
SS - Ronnie Lott
FS - Ed Reed
P - Ray Guy
K - Sabastain Janikowski

PR Hayne
KR Hayne

Leonard f**king davis????? Do you even Alan Faneca? ?

Originally posted by crabman82:
Leonard f**king davis????? Do you even Alan Faneca? ?

haha I completely missed that.

So many of these lists wouldn't work. Basically any trenches player pre 80s has no shot. He'll I am not sure any pre 90s player could.

Montana
Tomlinson
Rathman
Rice Owens Carter
Witten
Ogden
Larry Allan
Stepnoski
Will shields
Walter Jones

This is where I think many are making their mistakes. They are taking 4-3 guys and putting them in a 3-4.

Reggie white
Casey Hampton
Bryant young

Lawrence Taylor Kevin green (this one was tough)
Ray Lewis
patrick Willis
Derrick Thomas

Deion Sanders
Darrel green
Ronde barber

Ed reed
Ronnie Lott
Many of the safeties listed could not play today I might even consider polamalu rod or Charles woodson at safety over Lott.


Adam vinatieri
Ray guy