Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 738 users in the forums

🏈 2026 NFL ENTRY DRAFT 🏈-Do not tip picks!

Browse 49ers books and videos
Originally posted by Rathof44:
Originally posted by 9ers4eva:
Originally posted by jds_49ers:
Higher grades really doesnt mean anything. Example you have a FB, alot of NFL teams dont use a FB. So he gets a very low 6th round grade. 9ers use FB a ton, so the grade to them is much higher. Could be a few picks to multiple rounds higher. Same reason a player plays well with one team and bad with another. Fit matters a ton in sports. I am going to take the coaches and staff opinion way more than some person on a message board as to what the team does or doesnt need.

If you think you are the smartest person in the room then you arnt....

Doesn't mean you take a fb in the 3rd just because you value it more than others. Positional value is a thing and the 9ers continue to fail at understanding it.

Exactly. The guy they drafted to "replace" CMC had 5 catches on 7 targets in his biggest season. Zero route tree. But ok.

Who said he was to replace CMC?
  • Giedi
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 35,220
Originally posted by glorydayz:
Originally posted by glorydayz:
Originally posted by Ajinsc:
At this point this draft is at best a D heading rapidly down to an F

What have we done to earn a D?

Can't wait to see all of the A- & B+ grades from the national media. The lowest they will give us is a C.

https://www.usatoday.com/story/sports/nfl/draft/2026/04/24/nfl-draft-grades-2026-round-2-picks/89776030007/

We got a B+ for the RB pick LOL

This was a head scratcher pick for me. They just drafted Jordan James last year and he's never really played or shown his talent last year. Now they pick Kaelon Black. For what it's worth, Kaelon had 44 catches at James Madison. I know he's no Christan McCaffrey, but I hope he can develop into a decent pass catching RB sooner rather than later.
Originally posted by jds_49ers:
Originally posted by Rathof44:
Originally posted by 9ers4eva:
Originally posted by jds_49ers:
Higher grades really doesnt mean anything. Example you have a FB, alot of NFL teams dont use a FB. So he gets a very low 6th round grade. 9ers use FB a ton, so the grade to them is much higher. Could be a few picks to multiple rounds higher. Same reason a player plays well with one team and bad with another. Fit matters a ton in sports. I am going to take the coaches and staff opinion way more than some person on a message board as to what the team does or doesnt need.

If you think you are the smartest person in the room then you arnt....

Doesn't mean you take a fb in the 3rd just because you value it more than others. Positional value is a thing and the 9ers continue to fail at understanding it.

Exactly. The guy they drafted to "replace" CMC had 5 catches on 7 targets in his biggest season. Zero route tree. But ok.

Who said he was to replace CMC?

lol. So they're not trying to replace a 30 year old RB who had 400+ touches last season and averaged 3.9 ypc as a pure RB. 🤣🤣🤣. Ok.
Originally posted by Rathof44:
Originally posted by jds_49ers:
Originally posted by Rathof44:
Originally posted by 9ers4eva:
Originally posted by jds_49ers:
Higher grades really doesnt mean anything. Example you have a FB, alot of NFL teams dont use a FB. So he gets a very low 6th round grade. 9ers use FB a ton, so the grade to them is much higher. Could be a few picks to multiple rounds higher. Same reason a player plays well with one team and bad with another. Fit matters a ton in sports. I am going to take the coaches and staff opinion way more than some person on a message board as to what the team does or doesnt need.

If you think you are the smartest person in the room then you arnt....

Doesn't mean you take a fb in the 3rd just because you value it more than others. Positional value is a thing and the 9ers continue to fail at understanding it.

Exactly. The guy they drafted to "replace" CMC had 5 catches on 7 targets in his biggest season. Zero route tree. But ok.

Who said he was to replace CMC?

lol. So they're not trying to replace a 30 year old RB who had 400+ touches last season and averaged 3.9 ypc as a pure RB. 🤣🤣🤣. Ok.

Once again who said they are trying to replace CMC with anyone. All that is been said is they want to lighten CMC work load. And they have said that the last 3 years.

You are the one thinking they are trying to replace CMC with a late 3rd round pick...
Originally posted by Rathof44:
Originally posted by jds_49ers:
Originally posted by Rathof44:
Originally posted by 9ers4eva:
Originally posted by jds_49ers:
Higher grades really doesnt mean anything. Example you have a FB, alot of NFL teams dont use a FB. So he gets a very low 6th round grade. 9ers use FB a ton, so the grade to them is much higher. Could be a few picks to multiple rounds higher. Same reason a player plays well with one team and bad with another. Fit matters a ton in sports. I am going to take the coaches and staff opinion way more than some person on a message board as to what the team does or doesnt need.

If you think you are the smartest person in the room then you arnt....

Doesn't mean you take a fb in the 3rd just because you value it more than others. Positional value is a thing and the 9ers continue to fail at understanding it.

Exactly. The guy they drafted to "replace" CMC had 5 catches on 7 targets in his biggest season. Zero route tree. But ok.

Who said he was to replace CMC?

lol. So they're not trying to replace a 30 year old RB who had 400+ touches last season and averaged 3.9 ypc as a pure RB. 🤣🤣🤣. Ok.

Hes part of Kyle's Cabo Click, of course hes not gonna replace him, why do you think Juice is still on the team?
Originally posted by 9ers4eva:
Originally posted by jds_49ers:
Higher grades really doesnt mean anything. Example you have a FB, alot of NFL teams dont use a FB. So he gets a very low 6th round grade. 9ers use FB a ton, so the grade to them is much higher. Could be a few picks to multiple rounds higher. Same reason a player plays well with one team and bad with another. Fit matters a ton in sports. I am going to take the coaches and staff opinion way more than some person on a message board as to what the team does or doesnt need.

If you think you are the smartest person in the room then you arnt....

Doesn't mean you take a fb in the 3rd just because you value it more than others. Positional value is a thing and the 9ers continue to fail at understanding it.

The position value is whatever the value is to that team. It doesn't matter if Mike Mayock thinks that the player could have been drafted two rounds later or "yOu DoNt dRaFt a FB iN dA 4th RouNd!"
Originally posted by Fresno49er:
Originally posted by Rathof44:
Originally posted by jds_49ers:
Originally posted by Rathof44:
Originally posted by 9ers4eva:
Originally posted by jds_49ers:
Higher grades really doesnt mean anything. Example you have a FB, alot of NFL teams dont use a FB. So he gets a very low 6th round grade. 9ers use FB a ton, so the grade to them is much higher. Could be a few picks to multiple rounds higher. Same reason a player plays well with one team and bad with another. Fit matters a ton in sports. I am going to take the coaches and staff opinion way more than some person on a message board as to what the team does or doesnt need.

If you think you are the smartest person in the room then you arnt....

Doesn't mean you take a fb in the 3rd just because you value it more than others. Positional value is a thing and the 9ers continue to fail at understanding it.

Exactly. The guy they drafted to "replace" CMC had 5 catches on 7 targets in his biggest season. Zero route tree. But ok.

Who said he was to replace CMC?

lol. So they're not trying to replace a 30 year old RB who had 400+ touches last season and averaged 3.9 ypc as a pure RB. 🤣🤣🤣. Ok.

Hes part of Kyle's Cabo Click, of course hes not gonna replace him, why do you think Juice is still on the team?

Because he's still a great player and a huge part of what makes our offense work.
Originally posted by jds_49ers:
Originally posted by Rathof44:
Originally posted by jds_49ers:
Originally posted by Rathof44:
Originally posted by 9ers4eva:
Originally posted by jds_49ers:
Higher grades really doesnt mean anything. Example you have a FB, alot of NFL teams dont use a FB. So he gets a very low 6th round grade. 9ers use FB a ton, so the grade to them is much higher. Could be a few picks to multiple rounds higher. Same reason a player plays well with one team and bad with another. Fit matters a ton in sports. I am going to take the coaches and staff opinion way more than some person on a message board as to what the team does or doesnt need.

If you think you are the smartest person in the room then you arnt....

Doesn't mean you take a fb in the 3rd just because you value it more than others. Positional value is a thing and the 9ers continue to fail at understanding it.

Exactly. The guy they drafted to "replace" CMC had 5 catches on 7 targets in his biggest season. Zero route tree. But ok.

Who said he was to replace CMC?

lol. So they're not trying to replace a 30 year old RB who had 400+ touches last season and averaged 3.9 ypc as a pure RB. 🤣🤣🤣. Ok.

Once again who said they are trying to replace CMC with anyone. All that is been said is they want to lighten CMC work load. And they have said that the last 3 years.

You are the one thinking they are trying to replace CMC with a late 3rd round pick...

Maybe replace is the wrong word, because no one will really replace that dude. But they've drafted guys year in and year out to spell him and Kyle never uses them. So maybe Black is fine, but his comp on one site was the dude SF drafted last year out of Oregon. It's just wild to me to use 3rd round picks on guys that'll most likely never play. The end for RBs in the NFL isn't a gradual decline, it's pretty much cliff jumping. And it'll be sooner than later for CMC. Shouldn't have drafted a RB at all, just go all in on Breece next year. That's the only way Kyle gets good backs….let someone else draft them.
[ Edited by Rathof44 on Apr 24, 2026 at 10:10 PM ]
I'm going back to skipping the draft next year. What a waste of f**king time.

Originally posted by btthepunk:
The position value is whatever the value is to that team. It doesn't matter if Mike Mayock thinks that the player could have been drafted two rounds later or "yOu DoNt dRaFt a FB iN dA 4th RouNd!"

I agree with you that fans treat these media big boards as gospel way too often
But at a certain you gotta realize, other teams dont use FB, so were literally bidding vs ourselves.
Originally posted by Heroism:
I'm going back to skipping the draft next year. What a waste of f**king time.


Unfortunately we are all very slow learners, not as slow as our FO, but slow.
Originally posted by adrianlesnar:
Originally posted by btthepunk:
The position value is whatever the value is to that team. It doesn't matter if Mike Mayock thinks that the player could have been drafted two rounds later or "yOu DoNt dRaFt a FB iN dA 4th RouNd!"

I agree with you that fans treat these media big boards as gospel way too often
But at a certain you gotta realize, other teams dont use FB, so were literally bidding vs ourselves.

But if you feel that FB is going to make your team better than an OG that isn't likely to start over who you currently have then it doesn't matter. Player fit is a thousand times more important than positional value.
  • 9moon
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 22,399
SAD picks thus far... I'm just not sure how any of these 3 picks can help the team.. it's almost like we DID fill certain needs, but we took the wrong players ... players we could have drafted a round later or so..

SHANNY MUST GO..
Originally posted by btthepunk:
But if you feel that FB is going to make your team better than an OG that isn't likely to start over who you currently have then it doesn't matter. Player fit is a thousand times more important than positional value.

You can have both. Baltimore has for years.
DeZuan Stribling is Polynesian, don't know why but it makes me feel better about the pick. Puka Nacua effect
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone