Originally posted by NYniner85:
you asked me who and I provided just a couple quick answers.
You don't think DJ watched anything on Lawerance prior? I mean that's kinda his job. Currently has him ranked 47th on his big board.
Yes McDonald who's knows wayyyyy more than you or I regarding DL said what he said. Nate Tice watched 4 games and came away with the same conclusion.
Bleacher currently has him right around 50th on their big board.
I'm purely talking about the combine, you clearly aren't. I said no one was calling this kid a 1st rd talent until he all of a sudden put up great numbers. His film didn't magically change after he put up those numbers.
I never said he had to be Von Miller as far as bend goes, he is high wasted and stiff imo. He has enough burst length and a pash rush plan, how much better can he get if he can already do that…That's debatable. He beat up on some bad Big 12 OTs and when he played legit guys like Max, not so great.
I don't hate him as a prospect, 27th overall is too rich for me. I think he's closer to that 58th pick or at the very least do whatever you can to move down, gain more picks and get him.
You're honestly making my point for me, so maybe youre just not understanding what im saying, and im okay with leaving it at that.
Malachi Lawrence is not listed in DJs top 50. Please link me, if you have it, to where DJ listed Lawrence as a day 3 player. Malachi Lawrence is not listed in the BR top 250 that you provided. 250 (!!!!) players, and Lawrence isnt listed. Please link me, if you have it, to where BR listed Malachi Lawrence as a day 3 player.
No, I dont see a player going from day 3 to round 1 after the combine. I see a player going from literally unlisted to potential top 50 pick after the date od the combine. Whats more likely: bleacher report thought he wasn't a top 250 player until he jumped high and ran fast, or that they didn't watch him until they were blown away by his numbers. And yes, I am suggesting that DJ didn't watch enough of Lawrence to rank him prior to the combine. He cant watch everyone. As you said, he does this for a living. Id assume he has more professionalism then to ride the "combine" wave.
Top 50 prospects that play edge (or any other "premium position" frequently go end of round 1. Its simple supply and demand. Lawrence is a top 50 prospect.
You can value highly McDonalds opinion, that's fine. I think watching half a game and making your decision is odd, but thats fine. But you also have Ledyard saying he's edge 1, the guy with the tools worth betting on.
In the end, ill value him myself. All of a sudden on the day that a clip of him vs Iheanachor goes viral, he struggles vs good comp. The clip is from November of TWENTY TWENTY FOUR!
He doesnt have "enough burst" and a pass rush plan. His burst is special. His hand usage is maybe the most advanced in the class. He has a more complete set of tools from size, athleticism, technique, bend, length, burst than anyone else in the class. If you have one pick in the top 50, hell yea you bet on those traits with pick 27.
. And he was smaller. And shorter arms. And less explosive. And less diverse with his pass rush plan. And with weaker hands. And he went pick 26. And used a future 1st on top. And that was with character concerns.