Originally posted by frankieuc68:
Originally posted by Sask49erFan:
I don't see it with any of those OT's. Will any of them be any better than McKivitz?
Shanahan has shown we can be a top 5 offense with a bunch of average players on the Oline but our D needs massive amounts of reinforcements at every position.
We don't know how the picks will turn out. They can turn to the next Trent Williams/Aaron Donald or the other way around like Mike Mcglinchey/Solomon Thomas. We just hope that our scouts and management do they due diligences, get lucky at the same time and that our coaches develop them. We are about to pay Purdy 40+++ million/year and we know Trent Williams is on his last leg of his career. The least we can do is get one of the higher-grade OT and surround our high price QB with studs. Better than Mckivitz? Heck yeah.
McKivitz gets alot of flak around here but he quietly had a nice season.
PFF had him at 72.2 and the 37th best OT. Considering there are 64 tackles in the league that puts him right in the middle.
He's not a superstar but he is serviceable and dependable.
If we are taking a tackle with the 11th overall pick he better be hands down better than McKivitz and I just don't see it with any of the tackles you mentioned. Maybe Will Cambell or Kelvin Banks.
BUT, are either of those guys that much better than McKivitz and will make that much bigger of an impact as compared to Mason Graham starting over a guy like Jordan Elliot, Malaki Starks over Ja'yir Brown or James Pierce over Leonard Floyd (who is also a free agent in a year BTW leaving a glaring hole at DE)
We need to draft BPA and none of the tackles will be close to the BPA in my opinion.
As for drafting Trent Williams replacement, well Trent Williams is still here. Do we take that tackle and start him at LG for a year or two until Trent is ready to retire? Spending a top 15 pick on a LG for a few years is not good asset management.
When Trent is retired then we deal with it and draft his replacement.
We have glaring holes at both DT positions, a DE who can set the edge and let Floyd be a designated pass rusher for a year until he leaves, a CB to replace Charvarius Ward and possibly a LB and S to replace Greenlaw and Hufunga if they leave.
Our D is a mess and we won't win a game until it's fixed but our offense can still move the ball and protect Purdy with 3rd stringers off the street,
[ Edited by Sask49erFan on Jan 22, 2025 at 11:06 PM ]