Michael Penix Jr, QB, Washington

Would have been better off losing Texas

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by Dirtydonedirtcheap69:
This is the guy you trade 3 1s for

Hell no I wouldn't trade three 1st round picks for him, actually no QB coming outta the draft I would trade for right now. Well unless his last name was Manning. If I'm trading three 1st round picks for a QB it's gonna be a veteran like Joe Burrow, Josh Allen or Justin Herbert. And Brock Purdy showed, you don't need to trade the world for a QB in the draft, you just gotta do your homework.

I wasn't saying I would, idk why any Niner fan would be ignorant of relevant context, I'm comparing what Penix brings to what Lance did not bring: experience and a proven track record throwing the ball out of the pocket. He's the best pure passer I've seen in a LONG time. He's got a stronger arm that Tua and he actually can move in the pocket pretty well. He was f'ing fantastic against Texas and most of the time in his two years at Washington. Looking at his numbers at Indiana, he was great there as well. He'll be taken in the first.

Originally posted by Dirtydonedirtcheap69:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by Dirtydonedirtcheap69:
This is the guy you trade 3 1s for

Hell no I wouldn't trade three 1st round picks for him, actually no QB coming outta the draft I would trade for right now. Well unless his last name was Manning. If I'm trading three 1st round picks for a QB it's gonna be a veteran like Joe Burrow, Josh Allen or Justin Herbert. And Brock Purdy showed, you don't need to trade the world for a QB in the draft, you just gotta do your homework.

I wasn't saying I would, idk why any Niner fan would be ignorant of relevant context, I'm comparing what Penix brings to what Lance did not bring: experience and a proven track record throwing the ball out of the pocket. He's the best pure passer I've seen in a LONG time. He's got a stronger arm that Tua and he actually can move in the pocket pretty well. He was f'ing fantastic against Texas and most of the time in his two years at Washington. Looking at his numbers at Indiana, he was great there as well. He'll be taken in the first.

In your original text you said "This is the guy you trade 3 1s for". Sure you're not saying the 49ers should, but in context you would trade 3 1s for. WTF else does your post say, if not next time edit it.

AND NO Penix is not a QB you trade three 1st round picks for. For one, I don't trust Washington Huskie QB's. Two, even though he has a pretty strong arm, he just doesn't show me that "It-factor". But thats just my opinion

Bro listed Brock in his top 5 QBs. He gets my respect.

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
His injury history is also longer than a CVS receipt. Two torn ACL's and multiple shoulder injuries make him an injury red flag so bright that you can see him from space.

In 4 college seasons, dude has never played in more than 6 games in any of them.

lol

From too injured to consider to 1st/2nd round grade.

Amazing what happens sometimes when u give a kid time.

Originally posted by VaBeachNiner:
Bro listed Brock in his top 5 QBs. He gets my respect.

I saw that he really likes Brock Purdy. That's cool and shows a lot of respect.

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
His injury history is also longer than a CVS receipt. Two torn ACL's and multiple shoulder injuries make him an injury red flag so bright that you can see him from space.

In 4 college seasons, dude has never played in more than 6 games in any of them.

Guy hasn't even played a full season of NFL games.

Insane luck regarding injuries.

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
His injury history is also longer than a CVS receipt. Two torn ACL's and multiple shoulder injuries make him an injury red flag so bright that you can see him from space.

In 4 college seasons, dude has never played in more than 6 games in any of them.

Guy hasn't even played a full season of NFL games.

#Falcons QB Michael Penix Jr does, in fact, need surgery to repair his ACL, with 9 months of recovery, at least, coming.

He's sought the opinion of experts, including from Dr. Neal ElAttrache. Penix has an ACL sprain, but full reconstruction is needed. pic.twitter.com/rdz34X1eAh

— Ian Rapoport (@RapSheet) November 19, 2025

That sucks for him