Teams call to trade up, do we trade down?

I would like to trade down and get more picks. I think it's better than staying put at number 2.

Only if Bosa is gone would I consider a trade down - lowest I'd go is #6 (Giants), to nab one of the remaining ER's.

I posted in the other thread don't hold your breath of Gettleman moving up. He's never done it in the 1st rd and he's never drafted a meaningful QB as a GM.

I also don't see lynch moving off and losing out on Bosa/QW. He's got to hit a home run with this pick.

Depends who's available aka Bosa. If no Bosa yes trade.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

I posted in the other thread don't hold your breath of Gettleman moving up. He's never done it in the 1st rd and he's never drafted a meaningful QB as a GM.

I also don't see lynch moving off and losing out on Bosa/QW. He's got to hit a home run with this pick.

He's got a home run with QW. Bosa has no proven production and can't stay healthy.

Originally posted by NYniner85:
I posted in the other thread don't hold your breath of Gettleman moving up. He's never done it in the 1st rd and he's never drafted a meaningful QB as a GM.

I also don't see lynch moving off and losing out on Bosa/QW. He's got to hit a home run with this pick.

I saw that and also replied to it.

I think it would be nuts for Gettleman not to take a QB, let alone Haskins. I would take Haskins before Murray. Eli is on his very last legs and the Giants have finally run out of time not to draft a QB. Plus, the reports about how interested the Giants are on Haskins including private meeting and extensive workout.

On top of that, I can definitely see more teams being interested. It always happens every year. Teams know they can't function without a QB.

It depends on what they are offering.

i don't want to go past 5 but i feel like the giants are the only logical team that would want to move up.

Originally posted by Rascal:

I saw that and also replied to it.

I think it would be nuts for Gettleman not to take a QB, let alone Haskins. I would take Haskins before Murray. Eli is on his very last legs and the Giants have finally run out of time not to draft a QB. Plus, the reports about how interested the Giants are on Haskins including private meeting and extensive workout.

On top of that, I can definitely see more teams being interested. It always happens every year. Teams know they can't function without a QB.

Haskins is not worth a top 3 pick. I doubt anybody will trade that high for him. But if they did I would not mind trading down.

Filling some holes in FA made it easier to do, they do have flexibility and choices this year

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Haskins is not worth a top 3 pick. I doubt anybody will trade that high for him. But if they did I would not mind trading down.

That is like saying Goff is not worth the No.1 pick or Wentz is not worth the No. 2 pick or Murray not worth the No.1 pick, etc.

QBs are different. They don't need to be graded as the No.2 best player on the Big Board to go No.2.

If you don't have a QB, you are in essence as good as dead.

I am pretty sure people will trade up for Haskins. Heck I would take Haskins over Murray any day. Have you watched him play? If you haven't, watch how he destroyed Harbaugh and Michigan. Absolutely amazing!!

Originally posted by NYniner85:
I posted in the other thread don't hold your breath of Gettleman moving up. He's never done it in the 1st rd and he's never drafted a meaningful QB as a GM.

I also don't see lynch moving off and losing out on Bosa/QW. He's got to hit a home run with this pick.

Agree

And I think both JL & KS realize they have to have an impact #1 pick.

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:

He's got a home run with QW. Bosa has no proven production and can't stay healthy.

I'm done arguing with the Bosa haters if ya'll can't see it then you don't know what you're watching

Originally posted by mayo49:
Only if Bosa is gone would I consider a trade down - lowest I'd go is #6 (Giants), to nab one of the remaining ER's.

IMO, that'd be the only scenario.

They have to get a home-run with that pick.