49ers vs. Vikings Tickets Available! →

There are 656 users in the forums

Draft Rumors Thread

Browse 49ers books and videos
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by WINiner:
You have no stinking clue if that former GM screwed up, you are an impatient fan who has determined in his own mind that players worth despite reports to the contrary from people within the organization. Stop posting as if your opinion is fact, it is not.

He's a former GM for a reason...and it's not for doing a great job.

At this point assuming his picks will prove to be studs would be stupid, certainly if you're passing up on legit talent because that former GM drafted someone at the same position recently.

He drafted AJ Jenkins in 2012...guess it was good for us not to draft that position again early right? Worked out since we don't have a big need at WR now...oh wait.

You draft the best guys on the board even if it's at a position we've drafted early recently. Buckner is the only guy on the DL we know is legit. If we take Thomas and Buckner and Armstead end up being studs along with Thomas our defense will be better for it.

I assume nothing. Teammates and staff have had nothing but glowing things to say about AA. When asked for generalities they choose to isolate how well AA is doing. I choose to believe them and trust them rather than forming some b******t opinion based on limited information. I trust Shanalynch will look and make their own determination and my guess is AA will continue to be a 49er and I doubt Thomas is the pick @2. I guess the 49ers FO will prove which of our opinions is right now won't they?
[ Edited by WINiner on Apr 25, 2017 at 2:45 PM ]
Originally posted by WINiner:
So every positive word from both staff and teammates, of which there is a LOT, is a bunch of b******t to make you and me feel good about the pick? I'm not buying it.

I could give two s**ts what he's teammates and staff say...they're suppose to say that, if you don't think so that's your opinion same as mine.

All that matters is what he does on the field...not sure how people feel so condindent with him as the starter it's like none of you watched the games. I mean show me the flim of him being this productive DE? If it was all injuries then he shouldn't have been playing at all this yr cause he was a liability with the injury.

I think he could be a good sub-package pass rusher, which is fine. I don't see him on the same level as Thomas and I better 99% of analysts and coaches would say the same thing.

If we don't draft him I'm hope your all right and AA is some star who just hasn't figured it out in college or in the NFL so far...
[ Edited by NYniner85 on Apr 25, 2017 at 2:51 PM ]
Originally posted by a49erfan77:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by a49erfan77:
You can't judge him solely off of last year. He got hurt in training camp and played injured. His 2015 grade had him in the top 25 as a rookie.

He was the 73rd ranked interior defender the yr before
According to PFF paid website

Maybe 25th among rookies

How was he 73rd when he had a rating of 80+ which was good enough for top 25 in 2016?

EDIT: The folks at Pro Football Focus put together a rundown of grades for 2015 first round picks, and San Francisco 49ers defensive tackle Arik Armstead came out looking pretty good. PFF graded him second only to New York Jets defensive tackle Leonard Williams. Armstead also ranked No. 25 among all interior defensive linemen.

http://www.ninersnation.com/2016/4/16/11442604/pff-grades-arik-armstead-second-highest-2015-first-round-pick

Haters jump at any BS they hear and then lay it down as fact when they argue against the hated.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by WINiner:
So every positive word from both staff and teammates, of which there is a LOT, is a bunch of b******t to make you and me feel good about the pick? I'm not buying it.

I could give two s**ts what he's teammates and staff say...they're suppose to say that.

All that matters is what he does on the field...not sure how people feel so condindent with him as the starter it's like none of you watched the games. I think he could be a good sub-package pass rusher, which is fine. I don't see him on the same level as Thomas and I better 99% of analysts and coaches would say the same thing.

If we don't draft him I'm hope your all right and AA is some star who just hasn't figured it out in college or in the NFL so far...

You had me listening, again, until you meantioned a star. Nobody is effing saying that, people always reaching to make their point see, better lol. Rotating pass rusher is what you see, great. Move on, in two days perhaps we'll have a better idea.
Originally posted by SmokeCrabtrees:
You had me listening, again, until you meantioned a star. Nobody is effing saying that, people always reaching to make their point see, better lol. Rotating pass rusher is what you see, great. Move on, in two days perhaps we'll have a better idea.

What do you want at 17th overall? I want a 3 down starter that can be a pro bowler...if people don't expect that then fair enough.

Your right we will see in a couple days...I'm fine if he's not the pick but I think we will need an upgrade from AA....would love to be wrong
[ Edited by NYniner85 on Apr 25, 2017 at 2:58 PM ]
Originally posted by WINiner:
Haters jump at any BS they hear and then lay it down as fact when they argue against the hated.

Lol no I watch the games and don't proclaim PFF as the end all be all if a player is good. If you do that's fair...they also said Derrick Carr was the 32nd ranked qb his rookie yr and we all know that's not true.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by SmokeCrabtrees:
You had me listening, again, until you meantioned a star. Nobody is effing saying that, people always reaching to make their point see, better lol. Rotating pass rusher is what you see, great. Move on, in two days perhaps we'll have a better idea.

What do you want at 17th overall? I want a 3 down starter that can be a pro bowler...if people don't expect that then fair enough.

And he possibly could be. If he's a two down player, it is what it is. Heck Patrick Willis became a two down player when we went to our Dime package(when him and Bow were at their peaks). I'm not going in circles anymore, we're better than that
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by SteveYoung:
Originally posted by a49erfan77:
Here is a chart from 2015. You can see that PFF only graded him negatively vs the run in one game.

https://gyazo.com/0494fa3b9d8c21f34f6dd1c8bdcd5781

Boom

yeah cause he was in on sub-package with 375 snaps to his name in 2015...when teams ran the ball in those sub-packages we were the 4th worst team giving up over 5 yards per carry (Williams was very underrated) . He looks to me like a sub-package pass rusher, which isn't horrible but that doesn't make him a starter in this scheme.

He's gonna play this yr regardless of who we draft and if he steps it up awesome.... if not we got a guy that can take over for him and we trade AA...good problem to have IMO. We see good teams doing that all the time.

also it's no different then all the people who want LF (beside the fact that a RB is dependent of multiple things to be successful).

So lets waste our time and draft capitol potentially making a solid spot on our roster even more solid only to screw around with trying to trade and blah blah blah, when we could just take an elite prospect at a different position where we have a need, like at FS, or CB, or QB or............
Originally posted by SmokeCrabtrees:
And he possibly could be. If he's a two down player, it is what it is. Heck Patrick Willis became a two down player when we went to our Dime package(when him and Bow were at their peaks). I'm not going in circles anymore, we're better than that

We will see
Originally posted by WINiner:
So lets waste our time and draft capitol potentially making a solid spot on our roster even more solid only to screw around with trying to trade and blah blah blah, when we could just take an elite prospect at a different position where we have a need, like at FS, or CB, or QB or............

Who's elite at QB? If there was one I'm all for it...there's never been a DB drafted top 2 not even sanders. Your cool with drafting a FS with injury issues at two? I'm not.

People complain about taking a DL but how many DBs have we drafted over the yrs?

I'm sorry how was our DL solid last yr...I watch our asses get run on by fozzy Whitaker lol and that's with AA buck and Bow.

I hope we trade down if not I'm going BPA we just have different opinions on who it is...I'm gonna leave it at that.

This is the draft rumor thread not the b***h at each other thread....
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
They should stop being pussies and just make the 49ers a good offer to move up to #2. That wwy they get both Garrett and Trubisky. These fockers acting like its Burger King and they can have it their way all the time.

That's what I'm saying...enough p***yfooting around. They have the capital this yr and next to do it and we know it's not gonna take a kings ransom to make it happen.

Yup. Browns have the ability to have it both ways. Trubisky and Garrett. Get your pass rusher and your QB and go home happy. Meanwhile we get a couple extra high picks in a talented draft. Everybody's​ happy.
Originally posted by Willisfn4life:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
They should stop being pussies and just make the 49ers a good offer to move up to #2. That wwy they get both Garrett and Trubisky. These fockers acting like its Burger King and they can have it their way all the time.

That's what I'm saying...enough p***yfooting around. They have the capital this yr and next to do it and we know it's not gonna take a kings ransom to make it happen.

Yup. Browns have the ability to have it both ways. Trubisky and Garrett. Get your pass rusher and your QB and go home happy. Meanwhile we get a couple extra high picks in a talented draft. Everybody's​ happy.

Anybody else rather trade down before 12 like with Panthers,bills instead so the Saints don't take our guy at 11?
  • Jcool
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 44,549
Everyone is saying don't reach on a QB & all these teams have more then just one need. But there is no faster way to fix your team then hitting on the right QB. You also have no idea what could happen next year. Should you draft this year expecting to win 1-3 games next year? Seems like a mistake.
Originally posted by Jcool:
Everyone is saying don't reach on a QB & all these teams have more then just one need. But there is no faster way to fix your team then hitting on the right QB. You also have no idea what could happen next year. Should you draft this year expecting to win 1-3 games next year? Seems like a mistake.

I see what you're saying, but I think it's just really simple: If Kyle sees a QB in this draft that is "the one" - draft him at #2.
I'm not buying that Cleveland is thinking about taking Trubisky at #1. Not for a second.

I DO buy that they're willing to trade up so they can have both him and Garrett. But passing Garrett at #1? No chance. Unless a team offers a goldmine for #1 overall.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone